3 ms·
> The best option is to let uncompetitive businesses fail and concentrate on things the private sector can't do well. This is such an Economics 101-style respo
by rchaud 8y ago
> The best option is to let uncompetitive businesses fail and concentrate on things the private sector can't do well.
This is such an Economics 101-style response, I'm not even sure how to address it.
When the plant stops production, it's not only the 2500 people who lose their jobs, it's also the auxiliary economy of parts suppliers, logistics networks and food and drink businesses that are affected and may have to shut down as well. That creates a negative multiplier effect that pushes economic activity down further. Not to mention the long term impact of lower tax receipts, lower property values.
You can't snap your fingers and replace the underpinnings of an entire community overnight via the magic of the "free market". Another company will only accept the costs of relocating there if the government starts offering tax incentives and the like to make it worth their while.
I agree that we need a better system, especially when companies can simply move when it's convenient. But manufacturing is a strategically important industry and governments are willing to pay to keep that industry at home.
- tonyedgecombe 8y agoMeanwhile if you prop it up the business will remain uncompetitive and the Japanese or Germans will come in and win in the marketplace.
- hackeraccount 8y agoIt is Econ 101. Governments can do and pay whatever they want but the parent comment will still be correct.
- toomuchtodo 8y agoBeing correct doesn’t make you right.
- ryanwaggoner 8y agoI can't tell if this is sarcastic or not.
- ryanwaggoner 8y agoThis is such an Economics 101-style response, I'm not even sure how to address it. I keep seeing this response pop up. "Sure, my position fails to demonstrate even the most basic understanding of economics, but your argument reeks of being built on the fundamentals of the field!"