2 ms·
"I'm a shareholder and board member of a large privately-held, family-owned academic publishing company. ... You have to realize publishers are in the reputati
by specialist 8y ago
"I'm a shareholder and board member of a large privately-held, family-owned academic publishing company. ... You have to realize publishers are in the reputation business."
Prove it. Get out ahead of these issues. Add value. Progress marches on. Lead the way.
Let's assume (for scope of this comment) the replication crisis is the biggest threat to everyone's reputation.
What would a solution look like?
More access & transparency & accountability.
Imagine a scholarly clearing house that facilitated the existing processes and workflows.
Something like github.com for warehousing all the data. Something like a collaborative editor. Something like scholar.google.com to better find & forage for stuff. Something like linkedin.com for researchers to connect and share their thoughts.
Maybe even a brokerage for grants, connecting funders with applicants, help administrate the administrivia.
Publishers would still publish journals. The cream rises to the top. aka curation. As Scott Galloway likes to say "Information wants to be expensive."
TL;DR: Innovate to add value in a changing world, instead using the status quo to continue rent seeking.
--
"It's like discussing politics online."
For policy work (vs electoral politics), I very much agree. Policy work has it's own replication crisis.