4 ms·
Nobody knows if it's easier to build a commercial fusion power plant with the tokamak design or with the stellarator design or with another of less known compet
by gus_massa 8y ago
Nobody knows if it's easier to build a commercial fusion power plant with the tokamak design or with the stellarator design or with another of less known competing designs or with another design that nobody has imagined yet.
Moreover, perhaps some of these design (including thetokamak and stellarator) perhaps are nice for a lab demo or a model plant that doesn't break even or a tiny scale plant, but they may not scale to a full power plant that can produce energy at a useful level. (That's why this is called "research", you don't know if it will work.)
So they are following the usual path that is allocating some money to a few competing groups with different ideas and hope that one of them will get something useful. The problem is how to distribute the money between the alternative approach, and the method is a mix of analysis of the proposals, the intermediate results, grantbaits, and politics.
- brian_cunnie 8y agoAgreed — the problem is that, from an energy perspective, it "doesn't break even". Zach Hartwig of MIT has an excellent video [0] of how to evaluate announcements of nuclear fusion advances. The big problem is breaking even. There are other problem, too: plasma containment, etc. [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L0KuAx1COEk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L0KuAx1COEk
- pfdietz 8y agoNeither tokamaks nor stellarators appear promising for reaching commercial viability. Both are very complex, very expensive, and will have very poor power density compared to fission reactors (making them much larger for a given power output). It's difficult to see how they could approach the levelized cost of energy that solar and wind have already achieved, never mind the costs of these decades hence.