4 ms·
Confining the plasma is easier in a larger reactor, so you might be better off building one big reactor instead of 20 small ones.
by adrianN 8y ago
Confining the plasma is easier in a larger reactor, so you might be better off building one big reactor instead of 20 small ones.
- nine_k 8y agoIf confinement is easier in a large machine, why are not very large machines being built? If this is economically infeasible, then again, building piecemeal may be better, in the same way as taking a credit and paying interest on it might be better if you can't secure the upfront sum anyway.
- gmueckl 8y agoPlease have a look how frigging huge ITER is. There is no other way to put it. This thing has its own campus. It is also delayed because it is the first of its kind and also underfunded with some mismanagement on top. But
- Obi_Juan_Kenobi 8y agoCost. Building huge magnets and a huge vacuum vessel is simply expensive. Fusion scales very well with two parameters: size and magnetic field strength. Size works great, but it's just too expensive. Even if you could justify the costs in theory, ITER is demonstration that the political will to invest that much capital with such a long payoff time just isn't there. Magnetic field strength is the new hope of the fusion industry: 'Cheap' high temperature superconductors have been commercialized and could make smaller fusion designs practical and economical.
- bsder 8y ago> If confinement is easier in a large machine, why are not very large machines being built? They are. ITER was designed to be as large as the engineering allows. But that is Expensive. The groups at MIT are trying to take advantage of the fact that newer superconductors allow you to get to ITER levels with smaller designs. However, those are Not Cheap either.
- DennisP 8y agoNot cheap, but about an order of magnitude cheaper than ITER.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- cygx 8y agoIf confinement is easier in a large machine, why are not very large machines being built? Money and politics. You might want to take a look at the original logo of the ITER project: https://www.iter.org/img/resize-900-90/www/content/com/Lists/Stories/Attachments/1328/logo.jpg https://www.iter.org/img/resize-900-90/www/content/com/Lists... The Soviet Union collapsed, and the US pulled out of the project in 2000, rejoining only in 2006. This necessitated a down-sizing of the original design.
- maxxxxx 8y ago"If confinement is easier in a large machine, why are not very large machines being built? " That's the plan. But first you have to figure out a lot of details in smaller machines.
- philwelch 8y agoThis is kind of similar to how we use rockets instead of Lofstrom loops. The cost per kilowatt-hour of One Giant Fusion Reactor may be infinitestimal, but if you don't actually realize lower unit costs without a huge upfront investment, and there's no way to incrementally get some of the benefit for only some of the cost, it's a very hard sell. Rockets are an easy sell because you can design a rocket that launches from Holland and lands on London and you can find someone to fund that. Later, based on that track record, you can design a rocket that launches from Florida and reaches low earth orbit, and you can find someone to fund that. After you pull that off, you can make a rocket that launches from Florida and reaches the moon, and you can find someone to find that based on your track record. Conversely, if you wanted to build a Lofstrom loop, you would have to tell someone, "hey, there's no track record of something like this working, but give me tens of billions of dollars and you'll make it back by not blowing as much money on rockets". Nobody's gonna pay for that. And if you start building it piecemeal, you're still not going to get anything to space, and then people will point and laugh and talk about how Lofstrom loops are a stupid technology that will never work out because they're always another 20 years away, so you never get the necessary funding to actually finish the thing, which means people will just continue to point and laugh, and in allegorical form, this is the history of fusion power.