9 ms·
"Although Wendelstein 7-X is not designed to generate energy, the device is intended to prove that stellarators are suitable for use in power stations. With Wen
by chiefalchemist 8y ago
"Although Wendelstein 7-X is not designed to generate energy, the device is intended to prove that stellarators are suitable for use in power stations. With Wendelstein 7-X the intention is to achieve for the first time in a stellarator the quality of confinement afforded by competing devices of the tokamak type."
This was at the very end.
While competition is certainly a positive, this doesn't sound like they're interested. Therefore, given the importance of fusion (read: there's a massive immediate need on the order of saving the planet), shouldn't the time and effort being put into stellarators be devoted to something that's important in the immediate?
- Tepix 8y agoThere's still ways to go. If they manage the same confinement as a tokamak they (hope to) have the advantage of continuous operation.
- maxxxxx 8y agoI am not an expert but from what I have read there are still a lot of unknowns in plasma physics and fusion so it makes sense to tackle fusion from a lot of different angles and not pick a winner already. In the end what's needed is more money for research. It'a s little sad that people are complaining about the high cost of ITER while spending multiples of that for military. Fusion may be a big contributor for peace in the future if it reduces the need for fighting about access to oil.
- theresistor 8y agoI would say the opposite. Achieving fusion power is so critical to the long term sustainability of human technological civilization that we cannot afford to put all of our eggs in one basket, and hope that we picked the right one.
- chiefalchemist 8y agoFair enough. And I agree. However, to be clear, that's __not__what this article says. Per the quote I pulled.
- chiefalchemist 8y agoDown voted __again__ for stating a fact. Only on HN. And I thought CNN was bad.
- aqme28 8y agoI think you're misinterpreting the quote, and that's probably why you were downvoted.
- pfdietz 8y agoFusion power is not critical to long term sustainability. There are perfectly adequate, even superior, alternatives. Fusion has inherent problems that, in my strong opinion, are going to render it uncompetitive against these alternatives.
- drjesusphd 8y agoFusion is only necessary for long-term sustainability if you're talking about interstellar travel (and even then, fission may be fine). There's a real physical ceiling to how much power can be consumed on Earth's surface, regardless of its source.
- aqme28 8y agoWhy is this not important? Tokamaks are "better" right now mostly just because they have had a lot more time and energy invested in them. We need stellarator experiments to see if stellarators like this one might be valid. > something that's important in the immediate That's not easy to find in fusion research.
- avar 8y agoGiven the importance of transportation for society, shouldn't this effort going into "automobiles" go towards better wooden wheels for horse-drawn carriages?
- alexgmcm 8y agoFrom my classes some years ago IIRC the main benefit of the Stellarator was the lack of a plasma current which is no longer needed for plasma heating due to advances in neutral beam injection technologies. The plasma current seems to create some instabilities so we may be able to achieve better confinement with a device that doesn't have one. I would also agree with the other comments that we can't afford to put all our eggs into one basket - we spend a pitifully small amount on fusion research.
- cygx 8y agoThe promise of stellarators is continuous operation, whereas tokamaks traditionally rely on inductive pulses for the two-fold purpose of confinement and heating.
- pfdietz 8y agoThe big advantage of stellarators vs. tokamaks is their lack of disruptions. Tokamak disruptions are a very serious problem that, if not well-solved, promise to put tokamaks into the technology garbage can. A disruption can, in the worst case, generate runaway relativistic electron beams that can melt holes through the first wall. The first and primary goal of ITER is to show that the disruption problem can be and has been solved. If they don't do this, ITER will never be allowed to operate with a DT plasma. And they are still scrambling to solve the problem.
- lambdadmitry 8y agoAre talking about ELMs? Isn't it a basically solved problem then? I was under impression that between KSTAR's active field disruption coils and pellet injection they are more or less controlled (and we'll have confirmation from MAST Upgrade quite soon). Or am I wrong?
- pfdietz 8y agoNo, disruptions are catastrophic events where confinement is lost very rapidly. As the plasma cools an electric field builds up from the decaying current, and this field can accelerate runaway electrons in narrow beams to relativistic energies. Worst case >70% of the stored magnetic energy from the current in the plasma gets dumped into these electrons. If they hit the wall they can explode a hole in it. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tokamak#Plasma_disruptions https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tokamak#Plasma_disruptions
- _ph_ 8y agoWendelstein is clearly targeted at research leading to fusion. It is just, that the Wendelstein 7-X experiment is purely limited to reasearching plasma containment. Once this experiment is concluded successfully - and all the results are very encouraging, implementing actual fusion would be the purpose of a successor to 7-X.
- scarejunba 8y agoYou have not adequately argued that a Depth-First Search is superior to a Breadth-First Search here (or that the balance here is wrong). The value you describe is the goal value which influences the search strategy not very much.
- gus_massa 8y agoNobody knows if it's easier to build a commercial fusion power plant with the tokamak design or with the stellarator design or with another of less known competing designs or with another design that nobody has imagined yet. Moreover, perhaps some of these design (including thetokamak and stellarator) perhaps are nice for a lab demo or a model plant that doesn't break even or a tiny scale plant, but they may not scale to a full power plant that can produce energy at a useful level. (That's why this is called "research", you don't know if it will work.) So they are following the usual path that is allocating some money to a few competing groups with different ideas and hope that one of them will get something useful. The problem is how to distribute the money between the alternative approach, and the method is a mix of analysis of the proposals, the intermediate results, grantbaits, and politics.
- brian_cunnie 8y agoAgreed — the problem is that, from an energy perspective, it "doesn't break even". Zach Hartwig of MIT has an excellent video [0] of how to evaluate announcements of nuclear fusion advances. The big problem is breaking even. There are other problem, too: plasma containment, etc. [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L0KuAx1COEk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L0KuAx1COEk
- pfdietz 8y agoNeither tokamaks nor stellarators appear promising for reaching commercial viability. Both are very complex, very expensive, and will have very poor power density compared to fission reactors (making them much larger for a given power output). It's difficult to see how they could approach the levelized cost of energy that solar and wind have already achieved, never mind the costs of these decades hence.
- 08-15 8y ago60 years ago, when nobody knew anything about fusion (so not a very different situation from today...), the stellarator was the favored design. The advantages are obvious on paper (which is all they had back then): continuous operation, more stable plasma. But then the Russians built a small tokamak and it worked surprisingly well. So the whole world went "given the importance of fusion, shouldn't the time and effort being put into stellarators be devoted to something that's important in the immediate?" and started working on tokamaks. 60 years later, tokamaks still haven't been turned into power plants. Things were harder than imagined, and much more expensive, too. It doesn't look as if ITER will ever yield something practical. Maybe the MIT guys can make the Arc Reactor a reality; but all they have right now is... exactly, paper. (The whole world? No! A tiny village outside Munich built the Wendelstein series of stellarators...)