2 ms·
Ask HN: How to prevent hacking votes?
Are there any good solutions in the literature to collusion-resistant voting and reputation?
Something like hotornot is collusion resistant because it shows RANDOM photos so it would take a lot of effort and time for people to collude to upvote a particular photo.
But that is a site about one topic: hotness. How do you get people in smaller forums rate eg the strength of an argument without causing people opining on stuff they have no idea about.
I am seriously interested in building a site where each claim is debated exactly ONCE - you come and either upvote a pro/con argument (which itself rests on other claims) or submit a new one, and it would use Randall Munroe’s ranking system for display.
The idea is to make people discuss the truth or falsity of each claim once and for all. Politics, religion, news etc.
What if submissions are doctored and heavily upvoted in a coordinated attempt by “sleeper” accounts that behaved well until that point?
How does wikipedia and science do it? They don’t, sometimes.
When it comes to centralized beliefs about truth, whether it’s who owns a token (preventing double-spending) or whether Gandhi “really” said that quote or whether Tienemen square really did happen, what is some literature about consensus about REAL WORLD (not electronically verifiable) claims that actually can’t be gamed so easily?