3 ms·
One upvote is not from agreement, but from interest to see replies to your comment (which upvoting it makes more likely). Personally, I do think the matter is
by YeGoblynQueenne 8y ago
One upvote is not from agreement, but from interest to see replies to your comment (which upvoting it makes more likely).
Personally, I do think the matter is complex. However, if you're trying to protect the current model by arguing that building a reputation costs money, you will not convince those who, quite reasonably, believe it should be earned by contributions to knowledge, instead.
- simonh 8y agoDo you think the current legacy model of journals and the peer review of articles isn't contributing to knowledge?
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y agoI'm sorry, I don't know what the legacy model is. If you mean the way academic publishing works right now, I don't think anyone disputes the fact that publishing to a journal, free or not, constitutes a contribution to knowledge. I mean, I sure do not. The way I understand the debate about reforming academic publishing, it's about the morality of profiting from resources set aside for public benefit, rather than private (or corporate) profit.