4 ms·
> which is technology, and reviewers, which are academics. There is another factor to consider - the outsiders. They need to know which research is good and wh
by im3w1l 8y ago
> which is technology, and reviewers, which are academics.
There is another factor to consider - the outsiders. They need to know which research is good and which isn't and independent journals giving a stamp of approval to create "branded" science helps.
- em-bee 8y agothe same can be done by independent reviewers. i would not trust a commercial entity whose goal is profit, to be able to decide for me what research is good, the same way that i don't trust movie distributors. i'll look for outside reviewers who earned my trust because they understand the subject matter.
- im3w1l 8y agoThere are two types of outsiders, individuals and institutions. For an individual, choosing a reviewer to trust can potentially work but it does get harder if you have to pick multiple different reviewers to get good coverage. For institutions, especially those in charge of grants, something more stringent and organized is needed than "I like that science guy". And those organizations will need to be payed somehow, preferably in such a way that it doesn't create too perverse incentives.
- em-bee 8y agohow about the institutions themselves? it's their money after all. we pay you to do research, you send us your results, and we publish them. or someone higher up, if the institutions get their money from the government, then that same government could fund a separate institution to review the results (so as to see whether the money is well spent) there is still a room for commercial publishers, but instead of controlling access to the papers they publish, they get to republish what their audience thinks is interesting. so they are no longer gate-keepers, but add value instead. and whoever thinks that added value is worth it, will pay for it. universities, and especially individual researchers need not pay for it, because they can go directly to the source. magazines like nature or national geographic for example. but it could also be a company like microsoft that funds reviews of papers that are interesting for their business. or some independent thinktank. or the government of a different country. everyone gets free access to the original research. that's what open access is all about. and anyone can fund reviews to suit their needs.
- dougmccune 8y agoSome folks are trying to do this. The Conversation [1] is meant to be a bridge between academic research and layman's news stories about that research. And Kudos[2] is trying to encourage academics to write more layman-focused summaries of papers to explain the research and appeal to the larger world outside of your particular subfield. [1] http://theconversation.com/us http://theconversation.com/us [2] https://www.growkudos.com/ https://www.growkudos.com/