3 ms·
Here is a question what is the sort of theoretical good for the gatekeeping? What is the functional purpose of it? I think that answer would prove insightful fo
by Nasrudith 8y ago
Here is a question what is the sort of theoretical good for the gatekeeping? What is the functional purpose of it? I think that answer would prove insightful for determining the future.
I can see two noncynical reasons for it one. One is educational purposes. Two would be quality control - if it is already debunkable or widely known there is no point in publishing in Nature "thinking done in the brain".
The cynical abuses and perverse incentives however are myraid and academic politicking is already infamous. I don't know what solution will work but understanding the system goals and functions should help decide what to replace and what to keep.
- avs733 8y ago>Here is a question what is the sort of theoretical good for the gatekeeping? What is the functional purpose of it? I think that answer would prove insightful for determining the future. Because I am not at all prepared to assess the quality or accuracy of a quantum physics paper and I doubt a molecular biologist is prepared to assess the quality or accuracy of a sociology paper. In what I have seen there are a lot of cargo cultists who think kthey understand a field, and use big words, and just don't get it. I feel that there should be some filtering function to remove that. As an example: This guy: https://www.mountainproject.com/forum/topic/113602967/near-miss-on-cathedral-peak https://www.mountainproject.com/forum/topic/113602967/near-m... This guy: https://www.reddit.com/r/badphilosophy/comments/7x3t1g/stand_the_test_of_time_where_did_t https://www.reddit.com/r/badphilosophy/comments/7x3t1g/stand... This guy: http://ecclesiastes911.net/ http://ecclesiastes911.net/ and This guy: https://arxiv.org/search/math?searchtype=author&query=Simkin%2C+M https://arxiv.org/search/math?searchtype=author&query=Simkin... are all the same person.
- x220 8y agoThat guy has some pretty interesting articles.