> when class Player hits() a class Monster, where exactly do we modify data? Monster's hp has to decrease by Player's attackPower, Player's xps increase by Mons

> when class Player hits() a class Monster, where exactly do we modify data? Monster's hp has to decrease by Player's attackPower, Player's xps increase by Monster's level if Monster got killed. Does it happen in Player.hits(Monster m) or Monster.isHitBy(Player p). What if there's a class Weapon involved? Do we pass it as an argument to isHitBy or does Player has a currentWeapon() getter? I don't see how this is a problem unless you think programming objects correspond with physical objects. My first thought is make a separate Swing class representing the player swinging their weapon. There's probably an even better way to do it but this gets around the issues mentioned above. class Player { fun takeSwing { swing = new Swing( this.currentWeapon, this.location.offset(this.direction) ) if swing.killedMonster { this.xp += swing.monster.level } } } class Swing { fun new(weapon, location) { this.weapon = weapon this.monster = findMonster(location) if this.monster != null { this.monster.takeHit(this) } this.killedMonster = this.monster != null && this.monster.dead } fun damage { return this.weapon.baseDamage + this.weapon.bonusDamage } } class Monster { fun takeHit(swing) { this.hp -= swing.damage - this.defence if this.hp <= 1 { this.die } } }