9 ms·
The strange postulated link between the human mind and quantum physics (2017)
- deepnotderp 8y agoHmm, I remember thinking about this several years ago, the big issue is that it's almost unfalsifiable. I remember thinking that an experiment looking at whether anesthetics (that caused loss of consciousness in neurons) also stopped quantum phenomena in said neurons. But alas, that was a hard experiment to do back then :)
- zamalek 8y agoAny experiment concerning consciousness is likely unfalsifiable. It's a subjective phenomenon, by definition. Even if you could get approval to futz with someone's consciousness, you have to ask them what they are experiencing.
- crazygringo 8y agoSubjective doesn't mean unfalsifiable. If the experiment is double-blind and a statistically significant proportion of participants report subjective differences according to a survey, and the results can be replicated... then you're good to go. Obviously there's the question of what it would mean which could be argued over... but if the effect is there, it means something.
- adrianN 8y agoThe fundamental problem is that you can test whether the drug causes people to report that they're not conscious, but you can't test whether they're actually conscious or not.
- deepnotderp 8y agoI was planning to use animals actually, but yeah, at that point in time I decided against it, I didn't think I had the necessary skills to humanely handle animals for such an invasive experiment.
- bascule 8y agoThis article covered more than I was expecting, but still manages to squeeze a small amount of substance into a relatively large article. Here's a tl;dr: - Penrose and Hameroff postulate microtubules might have quantum mechanical behavior in their Orch-OR hypothesis. This hypothesis was refuted by Max Tegmark in the 90s. Penrose doesn't care and keeps preaching his hypothesis, and has not put forth any new scientifically compelling arguments in the past 2 decades. - Photosynthesis is shown to be quantum mechanical. I'm not sure quantum mechanical behavior in plants is the best argument that quantum mechanics are responsible for consciousness. - Fischer hypothesizes that phosphate ions in biological cells might exhibit distinctly quantum mechanical behavior, but is wary about any link to "quantum consciousness". This is pretty much all of the substance of the article. Even if there were a conclusively demonstrated link between quantum mechanical behavior in human cells (there isn't), using that to argue that our brains are quantum computers and that consciousness is a fundamentally quantum phenomenon would be a huge non sequitur.
- selimthegrim 8y agoPosner molecules are not the same as phosphate ions.
- bascule 8y ago> Fisher says, if the phosphorus atoms are incorporated into larger objects called "Posner molecules". These are clusters of six phosphate ions, combined with nine calcium ions.
- selimthegrim 8y agoYes, my point exactly. It’s a complex with calcium.
- bascule 8y agoIf that was your point, perhaps you should've mentioned it. That would've made your post informative, rather than merely nitpicking.
- johnjohnsmith 8y agoAhhh the old fallacy of "two things we don't understand must be related because we don't understand them!" See also: eclipses and human sacrifices; planetary orbits and the radii regular polyhedra; even Graham crackers and masturbation.
- self_awareness 8y agoMy thought exactly. When I've clicked on the link, I was intrigued, but then I've read the headline and all the magic disappeared.
- tomhoward 8y agoI've heard this dismissal made by the likes of Sam Harris and Michael Shermer against Deepak Chopra, which is fair enough. But Roger Penrose is not Deepak Chopra, and he's earned the right to be treated with far more respect than this. Perhaps the article doesn't do his work justice, but that doesn't make it reasonable to draw these kinds of derisive and vulgar comparisons.
- acetoxy 8y agoStanislav Grof talks about this in a recent interview he did with Tim Ferriss. Very interesting. https://tim.blog/2018/11/20/stan-grof/ https://tim.blog/2018/11/20/stan-grof/
- eternalny1 8y ago"Solipsism may be logically consistent with present quantum mechanics" - Eugene Wigner
- kevinpet 8y agoMy internal understanding of Penrose's "hypothesis" is that there are structures in the brain that relate individual quantum events to macroscopic neurological processes, in a way not explained by the usual aggregation of quantum events into chemical behavior. I'm very skeptical of this because nothing I've read has proposed any mechanism whereby it could evolve, nor any reason why these events should related to "consciousness" as opposed to any other mental process. Admittedly, I haven't spent a whole lot of time looking into it, because time is limited and the history of science is littered with enough great scientists who latch on to mysticism (Newton being a prominent example) that I don't assume that everything coming from a recognizable name is worth exploring.
- giardini 8y agokevinpet says>"...nothing I've read has proposed any mechanism whereby it could evolve..."[italics mine] If a biochemical mechanism exists then it is possible for it to be conscripted in evolution. Its not as if something called "evolution" sits around waiting for permission (and from whom and when?). Instead, a gene is modified randomly and blam a new mechanism occurs (or doesn't, mostly) which either enhances replication and persists in the genome or doesn't. In the long run you'd expect all chemical pathways possible to be eventually probed many, many times by evolution.
- TheOtherHobbes 8y agoThat's only true if the space of possible pathways is small enough for evolution to perform a random search of all of them in a realistic timescale, and they're all more or less equally probable. This seems unlikely in practice.
- giardini 8y agoWhy? Show me the math.
- sdenton4 8y agoMy guess would be 'easily available random number generator.' Whether access to an rng is a prerequisite for consciousness is another question...
- damip 8y agoCouldn't it be that the measurement device (or any other interacting object) "falls" into all of the possible states of the measured system, therefore we see the measurement device itself as a quantum object when we don't interact with it, but every possible "outcome" of the measurement device sees the system as classical. At a higher scale, a human being itself is an object interacting with the measurement device, and every possible "outcome" of the human being sees the device as a classical system, showing a classical system. At least this explanation does not involve "quantum brains" nor enthropocentrism.
- krastanov 8y agoWhat you describe is really close to the "multiverse interpretation" of quantum mechanics. It is an interesting thought exercise, but it is really important to acknowledge that it is only an interpretation, mathematically equivalent to the other ones, and experimentally unconfirmable. As to Penrose's ideas on consciousness, they are many other problems with them (see Wikipedia for a quick list of sources; or Scott Aaronson's lecture notes).
- stevenwoo 8y agoClassical mechanics cannot explain a lot of observed behavior of the dual slit experiment - for instance IIRC a single electron or photon can interfere with itself - this cannot be explained with classical mechanics or obviously ordinary experience at human scale.
- spot 8y ago"and his thesis is considered erroneous by experts in the fields of philosophy, computer science, and robotics." from wikipedia. what clown writes about penrose without including the standard criticism?
- bra-ket 8y agoQuantum probability is just a generalization of classic probability. Busemeyer in his book [1] mentions several experiments in psychology that can only be explained by quantum probability [2] but not by classic one [1] https://www.amazon.com/Quantum-Models-Cognition-Decision-Busemeyer/dp/1107419883 https://www.amazon.com/Quantum-Models-Cognition-Decision-Bus... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_cognition https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_cognition
- klyrs 8y agoSince the use of a quantum-theoretic framework is for modeling purposes, the identification of quantum structures in cognitive phenomena does not presuppose the existence of microscopic quantum processes in the human brain. [2]
- crazygringo 8y agoThis is one of those ideas that (rightly) won't go away. I've recently been quite inspired by Christopher Alexander's "The Luminous Ground" (2003). For those who don't know, he's an architect and mathematician [2] whose work greatly influenced object-oriented programming (he's best-known for "A Pattern Language"), and in this most recent work of his, he addresses the concept of "wholeness" head-on -- investigating what can be done to integrate the completely separate worlds of art/spirit and physics, under the belief that they can't stay separated forever... and following in the steps of thinkers like Bohm, Penrose and Mandelbrot. (I.e. he's serious, not some new-age QM crackpot.) The print copy is sadly ridiculously expensive, but whether online or in libraries there are definitely ways to read it if you're determined... [1] https://www.amazon.com/Nature-Order-Building-Environmental-Structure/dp/0972652949 https://www.amazon.com/Nature-Order-Building-Environmental-S... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christopher_Alexander https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christopher_Alexander
- platz 8y agoThere may indeed between the human mind and quantum physics, just not the one you're thinking. Namely, that QM doesn't represent anything physical about reality at all, and ONLY encodes probabilities relating to observations; the wavefunction is only a probability calculating math tool and doesn't represent reality in the slightest.
- Retra 8y agoThat's not a very useful perspective, because you could say the same thing about any part of language or science. Human knowledge is an abstraction, and can only ever indirectly represent reality. (And surely, "not in the slightest" is an exaggeration.)
- platz 8y agohttps://youtu.be/jvZ5m3UMer4 https://youtu.be/jvZ5m3UMer4
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- jerry40 8y agoSo we have several facts: - your attention can change an particle's experiment outcome (you choose future) - we see quantum effects on tiny particles only - perhaps gravity makes quantum effects for "heavy" objects impossible Which leads to an idea that actually all objects have quantum effects but someone watches for all objects in the universe and makes choices (chooses future) ahead of us. And apparently we can feel his attention as gravity. But his wathcing power is restriced and he/she/it can't watch every particle in the world. So to see the quantum world and to say hello to the god we should overload his attention with DDOS attack (perhaps Babylon tower experiment was about this).
- devwastaken 8y agoAfaik 'observe' is not in the human context, it's in the measurement context. Our eyes don't change the outcome, it's that we don't know the outcome of quantum happening without measuring in some manner, and because quantum physics is essentially nature's statistics, measuring those physics themselves provides different outcomes. I probably have that wrong in definition.
- jerry40 8y agoAs far as I understood the article, there is a possibility that our brain can choose one of experiment's outcome. So basically we do not change the outcome, but select one of possible options. And we continue living in that chosen reality after the choice.
- buboard 8y agoAll that one can deduce from this line of (mostly philosophical) investigations is that "consciousness is randomness in our behavior". If that definition of consciousness fits you, then fine, but the whole discussion is not very productive for neuroscience. For all i know, consciousness is an undefined term. The article doesn't mention Francis Crick, who was even more qualified to tackle the subject. http://blog.wellcomelibrary.org/2016/09/crick-on-consciousness/ http://blog.wellcomelibrary.org/2016/09/crick-on-consciousne...
- adrianN 8y agoYes, there is no proper definition of consciousness. All the "definitions" I've heard so far either don't allow you to distinguish what a rock does from what a human brain does, or they're not compatible with our understanding of physics, or both. I found this highly entertaining https://www.smbc-comics.com/comic/compatibilism https://www.smbc-comics.com/comic/compatibilism
- titzer 8y agoLike most people here, I have been thinking this quantum consciousness stuff is a lot of woo. However something new I saw in this article is the mysteriousness around the different effects of different Lithium isotopes on treating mania. That's pretty weird, as isotopes should be chemically identical.
- kgwgk 8y ago> isotopes should be chemically identical. Not really. I don't know about lithium isotopes, but there are drugs "improved" by replacing some hydrogen atoms with deuterium (an isotope of hydrogen): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deuterated_drug https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deuterated_drug Apparently isotopic food is also a thing: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ifood_(isotopic_food) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ifood_(isotopic_food) Edit: I found this 1986 reference about lithium https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/3530801 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/3530801 Stable isotopes of lithium: dissimilar biochemical and behavioral effects. Lithium, which is used routinely in the treatment of mania, is composed of two stable isotopes, lithium-7 (92.58%) and lithium-6 (7.42%). Usually there is minimal physiological or biochemical differentiation between isotopes of an element, but lithium is an exception. Data derived from a variety of biochemical and behavioral experiments are reviewed to support this idea. Additionally, the clinical implications of this work are presented.
- hackerbabz 8y agoMy expectation is that as we get closer to developing an artificial mind, we will continue to discover previously unknown processes in the human mind that continue to separate it from the most advanced artificial one we have built.
- RobertoG 8y ago>>"[..] we will continue to discover [..]" Do you mean indefinitely? Why that would be the case?
- tarcyanm 8y agoFor me, the question of consciousness is more than a question of pure mechanism. The mystery for me is the particularity/locality of experience. It's one thing to say that we have encountered these thousands of clocks, and here is exactly how they work (mechanism). It's far more mysterious to find one's entire experience suddenly located at the epicenter at one clock in particular - with seemingly no access to similar experience of other clocks. The issue of particularity is the real problem for me. And I can't see how claiming that it is imaginary helps - it's my most convincing experience.
- yters 8y agoIt's funny when people say science proves consciousness is an illusion, when all that we know of science comes to us through our consciousness :D