4 ms·
Like the phantom time hypothesis, bicameralism is a sort of massively revisionist theory that relies on wild interpretations of historical information. And both
by Apocryphon 8y ago
Like the phantom time hypothesis, bicameralism is a sort of massively revisionist theory that relies on wild interpretations of historical information. And both are pretty entertaining, regardless.
- goto11 8y agoAnd the theories of Immanuel Velikovsky. Like the bicameral mind, the theories of Velikovsky are attractive to modern lay people because they give a "rational" explanation for mythology.
- harshreality 8y agoI think you're making a category error comparing quackish theories of planetary dynamics to questionable theories of mind. Nobody really knows how the modern human psychological consciousness developed. To compare a theory about that, to a theory claiming as-near-as-we-can-tell-physically-wrong things about Jupiter and Venus and Earth's rotation and physical forces, is invalid. When I read criticisms of Jaynes, they seem a lot like criticisms of Darwin's original, simplistic view of evolution. Saying the bicameral mind is not a perfect theory is uninteresting; hardly anything is a perfect theory. What matters is the specific criticism (do you have one?) leveled at it, and whether the bulk of Jaynes's ideas can be modified and extended, with another few decades or century's worth of knowledge, into something that's roughly (empirically tested to be) accurate. Nobody takes Darwin's original expression of evolutionary theory as gospel today, but it's part of the scientific canon for a reason. It was incomplete and therefore misleading in some ways, but the core ideas are essentially taken as true today. We can see evolution in action through microbiology and genome analysis, even if some specific (narrow) ideas and predictions by Darwin and early primitive evolutionary theory have been falsified. Or look how relativity developed. First people were tinkering around with ideas about electromagnetism, discovering things about light, then came special relativity, which led to a bunch of problems, which led to general relativity. And even GR is wrong, since it doesn't currently accommodate quantum theory. That doesn't make special or general relativity wrong, so much as it makes them incomplete. They may be wrong in an absolute sense, but they're still quite useful. Even special relativity, being the wrong-er of the two, has some important "first step" realizations, like speed of light being invariant. Even the ether theory, now pretty much falsified, might end up having some contribution to future physics, if it turns out that there's some substrate (in a sense, though it would probably be neither matter-like nor light-like, and instead coupled to matter and light in interesting ways) that binds things together.
- goto11 8y agoThe difference is the purported evidence for the theory does not hold as all, as opposed to the theory of natural selection which has observable and reproducible evidenced in the form of breeding. You are kind of turning the burden of proof on its head by claiming that the hypothesis could develop into an better theory. You can say than about any unproven hypothesis. Some parts of the theory are unfalsifiable (e.g that ancient people did not have self-awareness) which is impossible to disprove, which means it is not a scientific theory at all. The parts based on "evidence" is easy to disprove: Take the theory that gods speaking to Achilles is the bicameral mind. According to the theory the Odyssey is composed after the watershed moment...but gods are still talking to people. So you need another explanation for that (e.g. it is actually fiction). But in that case you can apply the same explanation to the gods speaking in the Iliad, so the theory does not give you any additional explanatory power.
- hliyan 8y agoIt would have been better if you had included the reasons for your opinion...
- k__ 8y agobicameral mind is based solely on historical books. "Achilles didn't hear the gods, he heard his other mind!" etc.
- berberous 8y agoHave you read it? It’s not based solely on that. It’s also filled with brain research.
- freeflight 8y agoTbh Achilles hearing his other mind is a much more plausible, and realistic, explanation than pretending that invisible and all-powerful gods and deities spoke to him in "thoughts" with their psychic abilities.
- k__ 8y agoThe only plausible explanation is that the author of the story just made it up. Someone started the trend and others followed.
- goto11 8y agoIt doesn't make it a good theory that you can come up with an even more ridiculous theory. It is not even clear if any of the events of the Iliad are historical beyond there probably was some kind of war. You can explain Gods talking to Achilles with this theory...but can you explain Achilles literally fighting a river-God and winning? Even if this is based on historical events, the Homeric epics are centuries removed. And the Iliad is even fairly realistic compared to the Odyssee.
- Apocryphon 8y agoYeah, using bicameral theory to explain away myths and religions (and vice versa) completely ignores that there are loads of reported miracles and supernatural events that go beyond visions and voices. Bicameral theory makes a dull Occam's Razor, and myths and religion aren't great evidence for testing a scientific hypothesis.
- armitron 8y agoUnlike the phantom time hypothesis, you can find actual non-historic evidence for the bicameral theory of mind. The strongest of which you can actually experience yourself by triggering psychotic states (through the use of psychedelics or other practices). There were times where I fully regressed into a psychological state perfectly described by Jaynes in his book, voices and all.
- goto11 8y agoSorry, how are hallucinations evidence for the bicameral theory?
- whatshisface 8y agoIt works because the bicameral theory is a hallucination. ;)
- Apocryphon 8y agoPerhaps there is stronger physiological basis for the non-historic evidence for the bicameral theory, but the historic evidence sure sounds like phantom time/New Chronology jury-rigging accounts to fit a wacky thesis.