5 ms·
> Amazon delivers things to your house. Google helps you find things online. Apple sells actual objects. Facebook … helps you get into fights? Delivers your old
by ignoramous 8y ago
> Amazon delivers things to your house. Google helps you find things online. Apple sells actual objects. Facebook … helps you get into fights? Delivers your old classmates’ political opinions to your brain?
Strawman. The article's writer can do better than view Facebook as a one trick pony. It is an internet behemoth. Instagram aside, there is so much media sharing on WhatsApp alone that it might blow away most of the other internet properties away. WhatsApp with VoIP now has the mobile network operators by their balls. No one is logging out of that, by far.
> Some empires fall because they’re invaded from the outside or rot from within. Zuckerberg’s could be the first in history to collapse simply because its citizens logged out.
Couldn't be further from the truth. People might get dis-interested in Facebook, over time... but existence of Facebook is more than folks just logging out.
- WaylonKenning 8y agoIf people stop using Facebook, is anyone around to like its posts? I stopped using Facebook (though still use Instagram and Whatsapp) and my life is much the same as it was before. And here's the secret - I'm not even loyal to Instagram or Whatsapp, more to the network. If friends fall off Facebook, then there's even less reason to go. In fact, Instagram has entirely replaced it for me. And if Photos on iOS had a public sharing feature, I'd probably just use that, and then fall off Instagram too.
- knolan 8y ago> And if Photos on iOS had a public sharing feature, I'd probably just use that, and then fall off Instagram too. It kinda does. You can make an album public and it generates a link that you can share.
- ganeshkrishnan 8y agoYou are right. People often associate facebook with "just that website" when in fact there is much more to it: ads on facebook, commercial groups, fb pages, whatsapp, insta. Not to mention their open source projects; we use fb prophet a lot for our ML
- jayalpha 8y agoWhatsApp? Is this so difficult to program? Just VOIP and messaging? The Chinese WeChat hat much for features (e.g. send money, pay etc.) And even my mother has installed Threema on her phone because a friend of her asked for it. This tells you something. It is hard to come up with another social network like facebook. But a chatting client on the phone? The tide can change very fast there. Threema gets used more in Europe than in the states. But even a US buddy recently suggested we switch to threema. It is closed source but claims to offer more privacy. https://threema.ch/en https://threema.ch/en
- statictype 8y agoChat apps also have network effects. People use Whatsapp because that's what everyone else uses. I would prefer Signal but no one I know uses it. Everyone I know uses Whatsapp. So I use Whatsapp.
- josteink 8y agoClearly anecdotal. Nobody I know uses WhatsApp. So I don’t use WhatsApp. See how that works?
- function_seven 8y agoIf you count the number of anecdotes on the WhatsApp side vs. Signal or other similar networks, you will find that a massive quantitative difference. There are about 1,000 WhatsApp users for every 1 Telegram or Signal user. The anecdote is supposed to show why one can't just write their own app. It doesn't work that way.
- jayalpha 8y agoNo, it does. I am not going to post the same story on five different social networks. But I can easily have 5 different chatting clients on my phone.
- 8y ago
- sgt101 8y ago>WhatsApp with VoIP now has the mobile network operators by their balls. No one is logging out of that, by far. Interesting - when did you last evaluate / buy a phone based on voice quality capabilities?
- spullara 8y agoIt is because it is free to call any distance, not the quality.
- brianwawok 8y agoAll operators in the US offer unlimited free long distance within the US for several years. A very large percentage of the country never makes international calls.
- ToFundorNot 8y agoThe reason for Whatsapp's success is because of the lack of borders in communication. It's not only free in the US, it's free worldwide.
- spullara 8y agoSee other comments but literally inside the US calls are not what I am talking about. WhatsApp is used internationally.
- WeAreGoingIn 8y agoLeft Facebook about 8 years ago. I block all their domains on my internal DNS. I mean they are not getting any metrics from me. Period. I used WhatsApp but dumped it for privacy reason, Facebook is not trusted. Google is the next company that will come under heavy scrutiny. They are aggressively trying to circumvent ad-blockers with their recent usage of semi-random domains. You can’t abuse ordinary people’s privacy and shove ads in people’s face for too long time.
- cmuguythrow 8y agoThis is something that I would like to do. Do you have resources you could share that could help me? Specifically interested in how to find the list of all FB domains that need blocking
- tlb 8y agoI cut&pasted this into my /etc/hosts: https://github.com/jmdugan/blocklists/blob/master/corporations/facebook/all https://github.com/jmdugan/blocklists/blob/master/corporatio...
- medius 8y agoI've setup a DigitalOcean instance of PiHole [1] VPN where I have added all the Facebook domains[2] and other add blockers. This helps me block these domains on all my devices including the phone. I don't see any ads in any apps. I also use this list to temporarily add HN when I want to focus. This setup works well for me. Some of my family members and friends use WhatsApp and that's something I regret (tiny bit) not using. But I don't miss Facebook, Instagram, etc. at all. [1] https://pi-hole.net/ https://pi-hole.net/ [2] https://github.com/jmdugan/blocklists/blob/master/corporations/facebook/all https://github.com/jmdugan/blocklists/blob/master/corporatio...