5 ms·
It's insane what schools can get away with for price discrimination. Remember the uproar over Orbitz (and others) price discrimination based on Mac/iOS usage?
by paulddraper 8y ago
It's insane what schools can get away with for price discrimination.
Remember the uproar over Orbitz (and others) price discrimination based on Mac/iOS usage? [1]
Schools have been doing the same thing in broad daylight for years and years with far greater consequence, basing their price on your parent's income levels.*
And near zero public blowback. It's confusing.
* This is all done through school scholarships, but there's practical difference between that and a more direct price adjustment.
[1] https://www.wsj.com/articles/SB10001424052702304458604577488822667325882 https://www.wsj.com/articles/SB10001424052702304458604577488...
- closeparen 8y agoIt’s an informal social program. The rich subsidize everyone else.
- Retric 8y agoNot so much the rich as like social security the cost caps out fairly low. Save on the low end ~100$ to high end ~500$ a month from birth and collage is mostly paid for via compound interest. That’s expensive, but students with 100+k in debt mostly don’t go to affordable schools.
- paulddraper 8y ago> ~500$ a month from birth That is literally half my mortgage. For a single child. For years.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> And near zero public blowback. It's confusing. It seems like there should be a market opportunity for an above-median school that charges below-median tuition by just charging everyone the same amount, and then picking up slews of high quality middle class students. I suspect what's preventing it is the state universities. The states with large middle class populations also generally have above-median state schools with below-median tuition for in-state students, so the market is already served and the public universities out-compete the private ones without an existing endowment because they're subsidized with public money. It's also quite unfortunate because it locks everyone into the university of their own state, so they don't really have to compete with each other and the students in a state with a poor quality state university get the shaft. What the states could do to improve this is to separate "in-state tuition" from the state university -- if you qualify for in-state tuition then you get that much money toward your tuition no matter which school you attend. It would probably devastate the state universities (because they wouldn't be competitive if people had that choice), but if the replacement would be better and cost less...
- loceng 8y agoWhen we're isolated and not shown the schematic of how money is distributed, incoming and outgoing - and it's planned complexity like planned obsolescence, a subtle yet powerful design - it is a purposeful state of chaos/confusion created that leads to something similar to, if not the same, as decision fatigue (and in most cases this would require a lot of individual research to understand the underlying structures); you either don't understand and buy into it out of necessity (you need a place to live, you need education), and you either can afford it or not (loan), or you don't understand and don't buy into it because you don't understand or can't afford it - but then you can't move forward in life, at least not in as comforting as a way the path that "everyone" is seemingly following, or at least that indoctrinated systems and structured paths, industrial complexes, and marketing/advertising tells us "everyone" is doing and are important to do/solves a problem for us. Society needs to decide that we want transparency, accountability/accounting, and I believe we need to focus on promoting a unit cost structure, so people can see the full relative cost; what are the different models, what ecosystems/cities are using which model, and how can I "vote" for that system model by spending/buying into the model that I want to be perpetuated?
- snidane 8y agoWhy isn't there any public blowback regarding unequal pricing for public goods and services? They are mostly funded from income taxes which are not proportional to the amount of service thr payer gets at all. Property taxes would actually be different. The more you own, the bigger the effort the state has to gear towards you to guarantee you your ownership. Laws, law enforcement, judges, fire department in case it catches fire etc. Income taxes are the largest most discriminating schemes ever.
- paulddraper 8y agoIDK about "any public blowback"...income tax was and is very unpopular. It took an entire constitutional amendment before it was adopted in the U.S.