4 ms·
Toss String Theory onto the garbage heap already. Maybe what is worst than having steered your career in the wrong direction for decades is that there is nothi
by JKCalhoun 8y ago
Toss String Theory onto the garbage heap already.
Maybe what is worst than having steered your career in the wrong direction for decades is that there is nothing better than String Theory to instead invest in.
I'm an armchair physicist, never bought into String Theory due to the growing mathematical kludginess of the thing. But what else is there?
- whatshisface 8y agoRejecting strings on aesthetic grounds is no better than accepting it on aesthetic grounds.
- Retric 8y agoThe problem is not asthetics the problem is overfitting the data. Add enough knobs and you can approximate anything, but your simply encoding data not finding anything new.
- whatshisface 8y agoThere is an infinite amount of complexity in a randomly selected real number. A famous example of packing lots of behavior in to a small number of parameters is [0]. A physical constant that will change everything drastically if it is changed even a little bit carries just as much information as one hundred constants to which the universe is less sensitive. That's the argument behind why the fine-tuning in the standard model is an indication that it is not sufficient. [0]https://fermatslibrary.com/s/drawing-an-elephant-with-four-complex-parameters https://fermatslibrary.com/s/drawing-an-elephant-with-four-c...
- Retric 8y agoThat argument falls flat in two ways, first we are dealing with 12-13 digits so taking about infinity is silly. Second, the standard model is simply the most ifnomation dense way of describing ~all known observations. Nobody thinks it’s truth just accurate. So, saying it overfits the data is fine, that’s how it’s constructed. Supplanting it needs to reduce the amount of information required to describe the model or similar amounts while being more elegant to call it progress.
- JKCalhoun 8y agoNot aesthetics, more like Occam's Razor.