4 ms·
The root cause of all of this: an economic system predicated on the notion of growth. Unrestrained greed, sole focus on maximization of profit, and unlimited gr
by andrepd 8y ago
The root cause of all of this: an economic system predicated on the notion of growth. Unrestrained greed, sole focus on maximization of profit, and unlimited growth. It's not enough to sell as many mobile phones as you did last year, no, you must sell 10% more each quarter, or whatever. Doesn't matter if you're mining the earth bare, generating millions of tons of garbage, optimising for inferior products that break sooner, treating workers like slaves in a race to the bottom... in other words making the world objectively worse. All social considerations, moral, ecological, of welfare, of justice, all those considerations don't enter the calculations. All that matters is the quarterly shareholder report.
Like some guy said, "the only people who believe in infinite growth on a finite planet are madmen and economists".
- howlin 8y ago""" It's not enough to sell as many mobile phones as you did last year, no, you must sell 10% more each quarter, or whatever. """ But if the next gen of phones use 30% less resources, it's still possible to grow without increasing the rate of resource consumption. GDP growth has been driven much more by innovation than added resource consumption for years.
- platz 8y agoIf you don't produce more than you consume (i.e. grow), how do you sustain yourself?
- Klinky 8y agoSustenance is not the same thing as unrestrained growth.
- kiliantics 8y agoThere's a difference between growing enough food to have enough to eat plus some reserves and buying a new smartphone every year, a new car every few years, new clothes every month, etc.
- platz 8y agoSo are you going to stop accumulating wealth in your own life and just sustain at your current level based on your basic bodily needs?
- DennisP 8y agoI don't know about you but my current level covers a lot more than my basic bodily needs. I'd love to trade any future wealth increases for a healthy planet.
- platz 8y agoSo you're saying this is a tragedy of the commons, principal-agent scenario then? You will continue to accumulate unless everyone else stops accumulating.
- DennisP 8y agoAbsolutely it's a tragedy of the commons. That's why it's such a hard problem to solve. But one way we often solve these problems is with taxes. We pay for all sorts of public goods with taxes and it works pretty well. So I completely support a high tax on carbon, even if it significantly impacts my personal wealth.
- kiliantics 8y agoI think that's overly simplistic. There are systemic forces beyond our individual control that pretty much force us to consume at irresponsibly unsustainable rates. Planned obsolescence is an obvious one when it comes to technology products. Fast fashion is another. There are also many ways in which artificial scarcity forces us to consume more than we otherwise would. If things like handtools were "common" property, then not everyone would have to buy a hammer or drill for each house which they then only use once or twice a year. There are many ways this could be different but they are just not profitable so our current system won't allow it. In the past, for instance, even things like ovens were common property, fired up once a week for everyone in the community to bake their loaves in.
- wpietri 8y agoI don't think seeking growth is the root cause. We all want things to be better tomorrow than today, and a large part of the way we experience "better" is captured in economic notions of value. And as Jesse Ausubel points out [1], use of many resources has been decoupled from economic growth. Take video games as an example. It's a $100bn/year industry. At worst its resource usage is modest. But I suspect it's net negative: every hour people are driving in-game vehicles is an hour they aren't driving ones that burn fossil fuels; virtual purchases replace goods that get shipped or bought in stores. I think you're more on target with the shortsightedness that relates purposefully wrong accounting and unchecked drives for dominance and greed. But I don't think ending that is incompatible with creating a system where we keep improving the amount of value we create for each other. [1] http://longnow.org/seminars/02015/jan/13/nature-rebounding-land-and-ocean-sparing-through-concentrating-human-activities/ http://longnow.org/seminars/02015/jan/13/nature-rebounding-l...
- rapnie 8y agoI love the animations of Steve Cutts that demonstrate some of this quite well, like: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MTTr7RGH37c https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MTTr7RGH37c https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uG8bNDw6Ftc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uG8bNDw6Ftc http://www.stevecutts.com/ http://www.stevecutts.com/
- dorgo 8y ago>"the only people who believe in infinite growth on a finite planet are madmen and economists" There are 10 more planets in the neighbourhood. And even more some lightyears away..
- DennisP 8y agoI used to base a lot of hope on things like asteroid mining and solar power satellites, but we frittered away the decades and now I'm worried it's too late for that stuff to save us.