4 ms·
Why is weight an issue when we are talking power plants for housing? Here's a 8.3 kW diesel generator (6.3 kW generator) from Home Depo: https://www.homedepot.
by rightbyte 8y ago
Why is weight an issue when we are talking power plants for housing?
Here's a 8.3 kW diesel generator (6.3 kW generator) from Home Depo:
https://www.homedepot.com/p/Boss-Precision-Products-Inc-Portable-Generator-2-Speed-12-HP-120-240-Volt-Diesel-Motor-with-Single-Cylinder-Vertical-4-Stroke-Air-Cooled-DY8500LN-D/306061038 https://www.homedepot.com/p/Boss-Precision-Products-Inc-Port...
3900 USD.
367 lbs + fuel = 180 kg + fuel
http://www.nordensolar.se/produktdetaljer/solceller-luxor-solar-265w-poly/ http://www.nordensolar.se/produktdetaljer/solceller-luxor-so...
One random 265W solar panel, you need 31 off them, one is 18,6 kg gives 582 kg of solar panels to get to 8.3 kW (obviously you wont get 8.3 kW cont. from them). Not counting inverters, mounting rackets etc.
So for equal weight and way more power you have one 8,3 kW diesel generator and 402 kg of diesel.
1 kg diesel is ca 12 kWh energy. Lets guess 30% efficiency gives
1447 kWh electricty for the same weigth. That's about as much as the solar panels will produce in 2,4 months assuming 129 kWh/m2/year.
According to this site it's 3,14 USD per watt solar panel installation for consumers.
https://news.energysage.com/10kw-solar-systems-compare-prices-installers/ https://news.energysage.com/10kw-solar-systems-compare-price...
8300 * 3,14 = 26 000 USD.
So, you can buy a generator and 22 000 USD of diesel (about 22 000 litres or 22 000 litres * 10kWh * 0,3 efficiency = 66 000 kWh electricty) for about the same price. Or about what the same dollar in solar panels will produce in 8 years with way lower peak power.
- Retric 8y agoBackpacking is one example where you want lightweight solar power, but aircraft and balloons are a more extreme example. In such cases those stiff panels are a long way from what you want. Also, good luck averaging 30% effecency from a basic diesel generator for home use. Without going to extreme: https://www.solbian.eu/en/4-flexible-solar-panels https://www.solbian.eu/en/4-flexible-solar-panels That’s 130 W for 1.7kg. Your 8.3 KW would be 108kg which is 238 lb and thus less than the generator even excluding fuel.
- rightbyte 8y agoYe, of course. But the comparison was with ICEs and given that you could bring an ICE weight carrying capacity is usually not that scarce like back packing or balloons. Depends on if you need power, or, energy over time for the same weight.
- Retric 8y agoWeight is often an issue to some degree. For example the US military has adopted solar for many remote bases because moving fuel is a logistical issue. Again, I think for the most common case the only real advantage of increased effecency is lower installation costs. I am just saying solar fits in a very wide range of use cases and sometimes say for satilites you want something very specific and paying for it is worth it.
- delbel 8y agothere's an extremely efficient diesel engine called the Lister CS that became popular in the 1920s. It's claim to fame is that it can run 30-45 years without major maintenance and produce 1kwH per .125 gallons of diesel. That's 8kwh per gallon. It was banned in 2009 by the Obama administration because it was considered fuel inefficient by bureaucrats who didn't understand the design. There was a movement to try and de-list it from the ban. My dream has been trying to find one and draft it into freecad so people could 3d print cast iron molds and re-manufacture them. https://youtu.be/NhAD8D3sM2A?t=98 https://youtu.be/NhAD8D3sM2A?t=98
- FlyMoreRockets 8y agoFrom what I can tell, the Lister was banned because of carbon particulate emissions, not due to efficiency. However, very slow turning engines like the Lister tend to have a more complete combustion and lower emissions.
- felipemnoa 8y ago>>can run 30-45 years without major maintenance I think it would be better to list the number of miles it can run before maintenance is needed. Just stating the time does not provide a complete picture.