7 ms·
Anti-vaccination stronghold in NC hit with worst chickenpox outbreak in 20 years
- methodover 8y agoWe need to figure out how to better persuade people to get their kids vaccinated. Perhaps a mix of education targeted at families who claim these exemptions, and fines to represent the negative externality of their choices?
- cmsj 8y agoor just make vaccines mandatory for every child able to have them?
- krapp 8y agoThat's a good way to ensure anti-vaxxers are both paranoid and violent.
- chris_wot 8y agoActually, in Australia we prevented childcare payments for those who conscientiously object. Religious grounds aren’t accepted. It’s called “no jab, no pay”.[1] It has arrested the slide in vaccinations, and in fact increased the vaccination rate by a few percent. We also have strongly endured that groups like the Australian Vaccination Network are curtailed. They are now called the Australian Vaccination-risks Network, by court order after a statutory body the NSW HCCC pursued them. You don’t need to make vaccines mandatory, you just need to have consequences for those who refuse; and you need to go after groups who peddle in lies. https://beta.health.gov.au/file/1126/download?token=nF1qzHkN https://beta.health.gov.au/file/1126/download?token=nF1qzHkN
- conanbatt 8y agoRefusing childcare payments is just another flavor of mandatory, enforced through the tax system. A responsbility approach would be a health insurance on third parties.
- FlyMoreRockets 8y agoOnly vaccinate the kids you want to keep.
- conanbatt 8y agoWhat better way to persuade than to pay for it.
- cmurf 8y agoMost children are covered for varicella vaccination through Medicaid or parent's insurance, as well as all the ACIP recommended vaccinations.
- conanbatt 8y agoI mean on top of the cost. Just reward people for getting the vaccination. Normally you gotta persuade people or pay them for the inconvenience to get them to do something for you.
- eesmith 8y agoPeople don't work that way. For example, I suspect some will decide to hold out for higher money. http://freakonomics.com/2013/10/23/what-makes-people-do-what-they-do/ http://freakonomics.com/2013/10/23/what-makes-people-do-what... gives a well-known account of how monetary incentives don't always work, in that case with late fees for parents who are tardy picking up their children from day care. > The picture that emerged from this experiment, co-authored with Aldo Rustichini, was that parents had a whole set of non-financial incentives for being on time – incentives that were completely incompatible with money. Like, for example, avoiding the guilt of inconveniencing the day care workers. As soon as parents had the option to pay a small fine and avoid that guilt, they took it en masse.
- conanbatt 8y ago> People don't work that way. For example, I suspect some will decide to hold out for higher money. Which is fine, you dont need 100% vaccination rate to get herd immunity. The value of the last people getting a vax is low. Bear in mind people already pay a price but refusing to get vaccinated in time. Also, i would be very surprised to find that the solution to "hold-outs" would be forcefully doing it to them, in almost any scenario.
- oldgradstudent 8y agoThis is hilarious. Most of Western Europe does not vaccinate against chickenpox. https://vaccine-schedule.ecdc.europa.eu/Scheduler/ByDisease?SelectedDiseaseId=11&SelectedCountryIdByDisease=-1 https://vaccine-schedule.ecdc.europa.eu/Scheduler/ByDisease?... There are 600,000 cases every year just in the UK, but the Washington Post doesn't even bother mentioning that there is a disagreement between national health organizations about the cost benefit trade-off of vaccinating against chickenpox.
- RobertRoberts 8y agoYou are getting voted down, but I _wanted_ all my kids to get chicken pox. We tried to get them together with other kids that have it so they could get it. Everyone got chicken pox decades ago, it was expected. No one cared. Why does anyone care now?
- jesseb 8y agoBecause Shingles is awful, for one. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shingles https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shingles
- RobertRoberts 8y agoThis is _exactly_ the reason why we wanted our kids to get chicken pox! Or at least that is the story we have all been told. I know personally at least 3 elderly people that have had shingles (or do right now) that had chicken pox as kids.
- shepardrtc 8y agoYou misunderstand. Shingles are a resurgence of chickenpox when you're old and your immune system is too weak to fight it off. Chickenpox is herpes. It hides in your body, but as long as you're healthy, your immune system doesn't have much issue fighting it off. When you get old, then it can come back and be potentially deadly.
- RobertRoberts 8y agoI am hoping this is a logical place to ask this question. And I am seriously asking for a logical argument, maybe not even proof and I am not trolling. It seems logical that if you get your shots (US traveler) and go to Africa, you are a single person surrounded by millions and the vaccine is supposed to protect you from their diseases. (Edit: hurd immunity doesn't protect you in Africa, as the majority of people there are no immunized) But somehow, in the US one unvaccinated child is a risk to a school full of vaccinated children? This doesn't make sense. The only partially reasonable argument I have heard is that there are "sick" kids who can't get vaccines, so everyone else has to. But then aren't those kids unvaccinated too? And just as much a "threat"? So even this argument is extremely flawed. There seems to be so much emotion and lack of logic on this topic on the internet. I am genuinely interested in a logical argument not fear mongering. Edit: I removed the question about "hurd immunity" because people are copy/pasting answers. I actually want think there should be some logic involved in an answer.
- mcculley 8y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Herd_immunity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Herd_immunity (in case it is the misspelling that is keeping you in the dark). It is all about reducing the probability to almost zero once you hit a threshold.
- RobertRoberts 8y agoYes, "probability" but does it "transfer immunity"? The article says "...large percentage of a population..." This means hurd immunity is enough so that any child that doesn't get vaccines can safely go to school as long as a "large percentage" does. But "hurd immunity" is often stated as a way to make others "immune" or protected, but it doesn't seem to be the case at all if it's just percentages? Edit: I notice down votes with no logical responses?
- mcculley 8y agoNo, it does not "transfer immunity". It simply makes the environment of other potential carriers much safer for children who are unvaccinated, not yet vaccinated (e.g., for age reasons), or whose vaccination is not completely effective (vaccinations can fail).
- cmurf 8y agoThis was chickenpox. Imagine if it were rubella. Or polio. They can't be physically or economically coerced by a government because of the religious exemption, so far that's the law of the land as the Supreme Court conservative shift gave us the Hobby Lobby case. So there's nothing to do about it legally in the near term, short of something so horrific that even the conservative court reverses itself somehow. But I wonder to what degree insurers and businesses could affect the decision making: if you're not immunized, we won't cover your hospitalization; and refuse to hire people who's immunizations aren't up to date. I've been an employer, and if I'm the one paying for a majority of health care premiums, I'd absolutely be on board with discriminating in hiring people who think immunizations are some b.s. conspiracy. That sort of paranoia is a hiring risk even aside from the loss of herd immunity.
- conanbatt 8y ago> if you're not immunized, we won't cover your hospitalization; and refuse to hire people who's immunizations aren't up to date. Can this also apply for alcohol drinking, unhealthy food habits, lack of exercise?
- jerkstate 8y agoWell it does already, if you apply for life insurance they do a alcohol/drug test, nicotine test, BMI, weight, blood pressure, heart rate etc. Some companies insurers offer this sort of test to their employees for a health insurance "rebate" if you are deemed healthy.
- rayiner 8y agoNo, because lack of immunizations endangers your coworkers by compromising herd immunity, while unhealthy eating habits do not.
- conanbatt 8y agoDebatable at best.
- will4274 8y ago
- will4274 8y agoWhy is this marked as a dupe? Past shows no other submissions. No moderator comment indicating what this is a dupe of. What is this a dupe of?
- thaumaturgy 8y agoIt's a dupe of this discussion from three days ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18494345 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18494345
- will4274 8y agoThat article appears to have been flagged and removed before it hit the front page.
- rayiner 8y agoSo my dad worked in international development his whole life. A big part of it was helping deploy vaccinations to countries around the world. When he was a child in Bangladesh, 1 out of 3 kids died before age 5. Today it’s down to 1 in 25, thanks in large part of vaccination. People in the third world, with vastly inferior education systems, understand the importance of vaccinations and are lining up to get them. So the idea that people in the first world are deliberately turning them down just blows my dad’s mind. In my view a sign of some serious cultural decay that this is happening. Some combination of declining trust in core institutions and a rise in pernicious individualism.
- occamrazor 8y agoPeople in Bangladesh see their children, and their neighbors’ children, suffer and die of those diseases for which they can receive a vaccine. People in developed countries are not confronted in the same way by fatal childhood diseases and have the luxury to ignore the consequences of avoiding vaccinations, thanks to advanced healthcare and to the herd protection provided by the majority of responsible parents who vaccinate their children.
- bane 8y agoThere's a weird phenomena at play where ignorance has been advertised as a virtue and willful ignorance can be used as a superiority or virtue signal and used to socially position people above others in the same way that other beliefs and belief purity tests end up harming the believer. It seems to be fed by a bizarre ecosystem of pseudo-information that fill the minds of people and discourage critical thinking -- and maybe plays on some desire for social belonging to a group with secret knowledge. I remember reading some papers and articles on this and how it kind of hacks the minds of people by playing to base insecurities. Critical thought is not really a natural state of humans, so it can be very easy to subvert.
- ghthor 8y agoI think its caused by disenfranchisemnt. When you feel like you have no control or are involved in decision making, it's easy for that to break down trust. That's what I see in myself, and those around me.
- kapauldo 8y agoReligious thinking never works
- ryanmercer 8y agoWait, is there a chickenpox vaccination now? Sure wasn't 20-something years ago when I had it, on my birthday, ugh.
- gus_massa 8y agoIt's quite modern. The vaccine didn't exists when I was a child and I'm not sure when it become mandatory in each country. From https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chickenpox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chickenpox > Since its introduction in 1995, the varicella vaccine has resulted in a decrease in the number of cases and complications from the disease.
- howard941 8y agoYes. See the Prevention section at https://wwwnc.cdc.gov/travel/yellowbook/2018/infectious-diseases-related-to-travel/varicella-chickenpox https://wwwnc.cdc.gov/travel/yellowbook/2018/infectious-dise...
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- stmfreak 8y agoChicken Pox is a harmless right of passage as a child. Better to get it young than old when it has serious complications. I don’t know why we need a vaccine for this except for adults who missed it as children.
- eesmith 8y agoIt's not harmless for some. Quoting from the CDC at https://www.cdc.gov/chickenpox/surveillance/monitoring-varicella.html https://www.cdc.gov/chickenpox/surveillance/monitoring-varic... : "In the early 1990s, an average of 4 million people got varicella, 10,500 to 13,000 were hospitalized (range, 8,000 to 18,000), and 100 to 150 died each year."
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- curran736 8y agoYou people really trippin over chicken pox? What about the CDC doctor Dr William Thompson who admitted to fraud in vaccine paper? What about another Dr. Thorson wanted by interpol bc he stole CDC money for autism and vaccine research? People will blindly inject vaccines and not even ask about the safety tests for the nano aluminum particles their using... or the XMRV retroviruses from animal byproducts contaminating the supply lines