4 ms·
Social Credit is merely a virtual representation of something that is already very real. Our reputations precede us, a decade of hard drinking, abuse and fight
by lifeisstillgood 8y ago
Social Credit is merely a virtual representation of something that is already very real. Our reputations precede us, a decade of hard drinking, abuse and fighting in pubs will earn you a social score amoungst your local area, as will a decade of volunteer work with a local charity.
Putting those online is not inherently a stupid or bad thing. Putting them online without a means to view them, without controls on who can view them, without ability to redress wrongs or corrections, without institutions that support it, yes that's crazy.
We are never going back to a world where only your neighbours knew what you were like, but we do not either have to go to a world where only the Stasi or ad-tech firms do too.
- whatshisface 8y agoNobody seriously thinks that the Chinese system is your "local reputation," it's an East-German style reporting system where everyone informs on everyone else and only the state's interests are served.
- lifeisstillgood 8y agoYes, I know. But the point is that a cctv camera that is accessible only to the police is the same camera that is open to the web. It's the use not the technology.
- ENGNR 8y agoYour local reputation is relative, there’s maybe a different version of it for every pair of eyes that assess you THE Chinese credit score is objective, there’s only one. It’s merely what the government thinks of you, with no room for disagreement, with the consequences of that assessment automatically enforced throughout all of China
- acct1771 8y agoAfter reading your comment, we immediately need to reject the term "social credit" and instead adopt the phrase "government credit". As discussed, in true social credit, many people/citizens reporting their accounts of an individual's credit to the "centralized image" would be similar. Their government-held system is not.