5 ms·
It's extremely disingenuous to assume that attacks on George Soros are necessarily anti-Semitic. Soros is a quintessential politically-active-billionaire bogeym
by philwelch 8y ago
It's extremely disingenuous to assume that attacks on George Soros are necessarily anti-Semitic. Soros is a quintessential politically-active-billionaire bogeyman like the Koch brothers, or Sheldon Adelson (who is also Jewish). In fact, Zuckerberg and Sandberg are Jewish themselves, and I don't think they're necessarily the self-hating type.
Sure, actual anti-Semites probably also criticize George Soros, but (a) of course they would, and (b) why the fuck are you paying attention to those bozos anyway?
Of course, accusing people of anti-Semitism is, in reality, usually a dog-whistle for calling them Nazis.
- starbeast 8y ago>It's extremely disingenuous to assume that attacks on George Soros are necessarily anti-Semitic. The messages may be paid for by people with other overall intents, but the receptive audience for the messages is people like that recent bomb maker. And the people paying for the messages know this. I could tell people all day long that something was being funded by Warren Buffet and nobody would give a shit. Tell them it is funded by Soros and suddenly you have raised a following crowd of prime fuckwits and I do not think it is because he is Hungarian. edit - assembled prime fuckwits, you know who you are, there is a reason I picked Warren Buffet for comparison and once you have bothered to look it up, you are really not going to like it.
- Jach 8y agoMaybe it simply has something to do with what Soros has funded[0], and partly with what he's alleged to have funded (such as riots), that people don't approve of? Not the act of funding. Additionally Soros has been at this for decades. I think that you would find people caring about Buffet funded projects if he had the same streak. Honestly I'm just impressed by the master play at deflecting so much criticism, critics are either anti-semites or part of a nutty conspiracy group like the fake moon landing folks. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_projects_supported_by_George_Soros https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_projects_supported_by_...
- fzeroracer 8y agoI can't believe I'd see someone the whole pull the whole 'paid protestor' nonsense here on HN but here we are. The reason why people dismiss a lot of criticism against Soros is because a lot of the criticism is not based in reality, period. I am more than happy to criticize rich billionaires but the meme around Soros is clearly based around the anti-Semitic idea of a Jewish cabal running everything behind the scene rather than any sort of issue with wealth.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- nhaz 8y agoThe downvotes here say all that needs to be said. Just put your fingers in your ears and scream "antisemites!!!". It's like that episode of Seinfeld, everything is antisemitic, even Jews. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yQpvK72le4Q https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yQpvK72le4Q
- virtuabhi 8y agoDownvote such commentators. It is a common tactic of racists to write anti-semitic comments and pretend that they are only asking innocent questions.
- Nasrudith 8y agoReally the thing is that said criticisms need actual substance to be legitimate. Every kook blames him for stuff that happens anyway. People protest or riot when angry about something. A pattern of innuendos doesn't mean anything other than some people hate him. Hillary Clinton isn't a leader of a cabal of assassins. Vladmir Putin also has plenty of innuendos about killing people. However he actually does have them and has taken pains to make it clear it was him doing stuff like using rare nerve agents instead of any far cheaper method of assassination - just common cyanide in a large enough dose kills just as well as polonium, better in fact but it causes too quick and clean a death for terror purposes.
- Nasrudith 8y agoBut wouldn't that be on them always ethically? Exposing evidence that definitively proves Bill Cosby is a rapist might cause some idiot to try lynching black men as all rapists but that doesn't mean reporting him suddenly becomes immoral.
- meowface 8y agoWarren Buffett generally isn't a political financier. The Koch brothers and George Soros are.
- starbeast 8y agoAnd I am generally not sarcastic. No, really.
- meowface 8y agoSo why did you pick Warren Buffett for comparison? I did look it up, and do not see what point you were trying to make.
- starbeast 8y agoHe was one of Obama's first funders, advisers and public fundraisers, way back when Obama was still a senator. It is very unlikely that Obama would have become and then stayed president without Warren Buffett's initial and continued support. Warren Buffett is a liberal, very politically involved billionaire philanthropist, very much like George Soros, but with quite literally ten times as much money and political influence. Furthermore, he has promised to spend all of this money on fluffy liberal causes and social welfare programs and all sorts of other scary commie-sounding stuff before he dies. And he is very old. Yet, where the hell are all the Warren Buffett conspiracies? He must feel really left out.
- philwelch 8y agoIt's easier for each side to have one designated boogeyman. Why do the Koch Brothers take all the heat from progressives when there's still Sheldon Adelson and Robert Mercer and Peter Thiel?
- starbeast 8y ago>Why do the Koch Brothers take all the heat from progressives when there's still Sheldon Adelson and Robert Mercer and Peter Thiel? I'm not sure they do. Mercer particularly is getting a lot of flack right now. I just find it slightly odd that people put George Soros up as some scary liberal billionaire kingmaker while completely and utterly ignoring an actual liberal billionaire kingmaker.
- throwawaymath 8y agoI don't follow what you're trying to get at with Warren Buffett. What are you referring to that people won't like?
- Iamhisalt 8y ago>people like the recent bomb maker. You actually believe that was real?! Ok.
- changchuming 8y agoSome people hate Soros because of his role in the Asian financial crisis, where he literally broke banks which resulted in many going into poverty. He has also shorted the British pound and other currencies, so I imagine that there are people mad at him for that too.
- anigbrowl 8y agoa) Anti-Semites rarely make any effort to criticize Sheldon Adelson, though, and b) because ignoring them doesn't lead them to disappear, since the popularity of falsehoods is well understood to exceed that of truth over the short run.
- philwelch 8y agoI do not think the best way to fight anti-Semitism is to widely publicize every anti-Semitic conspiracy theory, publicize the Jewish ethnicity of every controversial figure, and accuse as many people as possible of being anti-Semitic. I do think that's the best way to convince yourself and those who already agree with you that everyone on the other side is a Nazi.
- anigbrowl 8y agoGood thing I'm not doing that then. I have very particular criteria for deciding whether someone is a Nazi and reject your insinuation.
- fzeroracer 8y agoI would argue it's extremely disingenuous to not recoginize that the crowds that blame Soros for everything have a distinctly anti-Semitic streak. You would have to be either blind or deliberately ignoring the massive dog whistles.
- aylmao 8y agoBeing Jewish isn't his only defining characteristic. There's also the fact that he's a billionaire who is politically active. I would argue it's extremely disingenuous to not recoginize that the crowds that blame Soros for everything could very likely have a distinctly anti-billionaire streak.
- philwelch 8y agoThis is an extremely disingenuous guilt-by-association argument that groups together "generic conservatives who gripe about billionaires financing their political adversaries" with "anti-Semitic nutjobs". There are anti-Semites in many movements, both left and right. Louis Farrakhan has been openly anti-Semitic for years. Jesse Jackson has referred to New York City as "Hymietown". Should we dismiss the entire black civil rights movement as "crowds with a distinctly anti-Semitic streak", or should we condemn Farrakhan and Jackson personally while acknowledging that not all of the people they work with share their most repugnant views? Should we dismiss the UK Labour Party as a "crowd with a distinctly anti-Semitic streak" because of Jeremy Corbyn's uncomfortably friendly comments about Hamas? Let's also not miss the facts that (a) much of the criticism towards Facebook has been directed at Mark Zuckerberg personally, (b) Mark Zuckerberg happens to be Jewish, and (c) there is also no shortage of anti-Semites who make the connection between A and B. But, because it doesn't serve the media's vested interests to protect Zuckerberg the way they protect Zuckerberg's critics (remember that Facebook is a direct competitor to the mainstream media), they don't go out of their way to point out this connection.
- sek 8y agoYour last sentence is a disingenuous straw-man or you have no idea what you are talking about. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antisemitism#Manifestations https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antisemitism#Manifestations Soros is the most popular target because he combines many traits and is very public.
- nhaz 8y agoSoros is a very wealthy person who uses his wealth to push a leftist agenda all around the world. There's no doubt about that, you just have to take a look at the "Open Society Foundations" website to see it. Discrediting all of his detractors as "antisemitic" is merely a tactic used to delegitimise them.
- Iamhisalt 8y ago>Soros is a very wealthy person who uses his wealth to push a leftist agenda all around the world. There's no doubt about that, you just have to take a look at the "Open Society Foundations" website to see it. Discrediting all of his detractors as "antisemitic" is merely a tactic used to delegitimise them. This.