5 ms·
I already said I don't approve of the practice. But the reality is that the actual solution here is: 1. Turn the country into a developed country. 2. Eradica
by DoreenMichele 8y ago
I already said I don't approve of the practice.
But the reality is that the actual solution here is:
1. Turn the country into a developed country.
2. Eradicate sexism so women can have money and power in their own right.
This cannot be done overnight.
Even if you pull that off, there will be women who actually want to be home with their children when they are little. When I worked at a Fortune 500 company, I had female colleagues who expressed regret that they could not be home with their children. They could not afford it. They envied me the fact that I had been home with my kids.
So there doesn't appear to be a perfect solution here. But I can assure you that marrying a man who can afford to feed and house you is better than marrying a man who can't afford that, all other things being equal, especially when you can't possibly have a real career yourself that will provide for you.
- watwut 8y agoI dont need to have immediate solution to point out that "are properly cared for by upstanding citizens who are productive and take care of their family because they are good men" is nonsense. Reality is that it sux and even if we have no solution, we should not pretend it is something that it is not. Wanting to stay at home and being sold are two miles away different experiences. > But I can assure you that marrying a man who can afford to feed and house you is better than marrying a man who can't afford that, all other things being equal, especially when you can't possibly have a real career yourself that will provide for you. Well then, you don't get to be at home. I assure you that rich abusive or emotionally distant man who think less of you is victory either. Lastly, the ratio of males vs females wont change, so there wont be enough of rich guys for every girls anyway. But beyond that, while kids need that relationship with caregiver, I don't find the situation as you described it particularly noble. Men are not and should not be treated as wallets only. They deserve equal effort from women including in getting food. In traditional farms, everybody worked. There was gender split in both power and tasks, but nevertheless, there is no entitlement to be idle.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoYou are judging this from the perspective of what is possible in a developed country today. I am judging this as a student of history. Historically, famine was commonplace. We make a big deal about it now, but from what I gather, The Irish Potato Famine is remembered ironically in part because it was kind of one of the last big famines in Europe. Before that, famine wasn't even newsworthy. So in a very poor country where survival is a big issue, "good man" starts with "does he even have the capacity to provide for a wife and kids?" It does not begin with other niceties concerning how kind and so forth he is. "I want a man who's kind and understanding. Is that too much to ask in a millionaire?" -- Zsa Zsa Gabor (Has "first world problem" written all over it, to the max) Edit in response to your edit: there is no entitlement to be idle. Full time wives cook, clean, raise children, etc. Implying that being a full time wife and mom is a life where one is "idle" is incredibly misogynistic as it completely pisses on the very real value provided to the world by traditional women's work. On a traditional farm where women had a garden near the kitchen for spices and vegetables and men provided meat, grain, etc, both worked to literally put food on the table. Around 300 years ago or so, we began shifting labor around to free men up to go do paid work as money began to become more commonly available. "Women's work" wasn't inherently valued less than the work of men because there wasn't a clear dividing line between "This work is worth pay and this work is not and the dividing line closely corresponds to gendered roles." The problem is we now devalue women's work because it doesn't pay money and money has come to be more central to our lives than it once was. Historically, money was not the way we parceled things out.
- jlawson 8y agoI've heard this notion that "we devalue women's work" but I can't actually put my finger on any example of this. I'm not sure it's really true. Yes, homemakers are not paid in money. That doesn't make the work any less valuable. And I think that anyone who thinks about this for a few seconds would come to this conclusion. There's nothing more valuable about a man cooking in a restaurant than a woman cooking in her home. Maybe the opposite, because a restaurant cook can be replaced more easily than the mother to a particular child. When I read traditionalists talking about this, they tend to emphasize the value of what women provide in that traditional role. They'd never say that the women are idle or useless or worthless. I remember old Chinese stories about a man choosing a wife based on her cooking skills. And on the modern side, one of the Proud Boys' core tenets is "venerate the housewife". Is it progressives/feminists who are devaluing womens' work? Is it a side-effect of the campaign to free women from having to do that work, that the work itself ends up getting denigrated along with the women doing it? I think feminists would generally also say that home work is fully respectable, but maybe there's an undercurrent of disrespect there. To say women should move from home to career is in some sense implicitly valuing career over the home. --- You point to the daily use of money as the source of the difference. I think that may be wrong. I think the cause may actually be education. Traditional women's work doesn't require more than a primary education. When everyone is uneducated, one may see that work as equal to an equally-uneducated man's work doing subsistence farming or laboring. But once society starts educating men (and only men, because resources are scarce and there are no washing machines or dishwashers and every woman is occupied on all-day every day home work and so they cannot be spared), a difference in hourly value appears between the man and the woman. Because of education, the woman's work is in some sense actually less valuable per-hour than that of her educated husband - hiring a replacement for him would cost a lot more than hiring a replacement for her. So the mens' work becomes literally more valuable. The asymmetry seems to be that the men got educated first. And I think the basic reason for that is technological: The work men did in medieval times was largely about simple muscle power (farming, building etc), and can be automated with simple industrial-era technology. The work women did was based on hand-eye coordination and social interaction (cooking, cleaning, child discipline), and largely still can't be automated very well today. So the men were automated out of their jobs first, which allowed them to spend time getting educated instead of pushing plows, while the womens' work still needed to be done by hand. Anyway, it's an interesting set of questions. I'd be curious to see what examples of people "devaluing womens' work" actually exist, if anyone can point them out. I'm not sure I've really seen it.
- qball 8y ago>In traditional farms, everybody worked. There was gender split in both power and tasks, but nevertheless, there is no entitlement to be idle. You don't seem to understand the implications of that statement. In a country where the way to obtain food is tightly coupled to physical strength, men dominate because they are stronger. That's reality. Even though women can (and do) substantial, non-trivial, and important work, the work they do [in unindustrialized nations] is derivative of a man's; you can't operate on resources that aren't there (preparing food is impossible if there's no food to prepare). That's also reality. Those two things are the reason why women are second-class citizens in unindustrialized countries- implying that there's some grand conspiracy by men that makes this so is intellectually dishonest. Once industrialization renders the physical strength to resource equation moot, women are able to be productive in their own right (a farming combine does not care who is sitting in the driver's seat), and they become first-class citizens shortly thereafter as the Western world has demonstrated without exception. (Residual effects may vary and are to be expected because humanity evolved with this concept; I needn't elaborate as to what they are).
- nixarian 8y agoThe problem is that women still look for men who can provide for them, even if they can provide for themselves.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoYes. I think I covered that when I said Even if you pull that off, there will be women who actually want to be home with their children when they are little. When I worked at a Fortune 500 company, I had female colleagues who expressed regret that they could not be home with their children. They could not afford it. They envied me the fact that I had been home with my kids. Given that pregnancy can result in debilitating health problems, a woman can wind up bedridden while pregnant, a woman lactates following pregnancy and may want to breastfeed the baby, etc, I don't think we will ever have a slam dunk solution here. If you are capable of getting pregnant, you cannot realistically discount the possibility that you will need your partner to be capable of adequately providing for you and one or more children, even if you have zero desire to actually be home with them. That may not be a choice. Sex can lead to a pregnancy you didn't intend and that can lead to situations where working full time is worse than staying home if you can afford it.
- Pica_soO 8y agoOh, there is a solution there- just force men to take a equally long sabbatical/education/family break from their jobs. If both sides are absent for up to 5 years, suddenly, there is no disadvantage.
- devwastaken 8y ago"I can assure you that marrying a man who can afford to feed and house you is better than marrying a man who can't afford that" In practice, sure, that's how that goes, because women are deprived of Independence. But given the will they would actually prefer to be poor than to be picked up by some rich asshole. Typically called morals.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoI am going to assume you are unaware that I both appear to be the highest ranked woman on HN and also achieved that status while homeless for nearly six years, in spite of having about six years of college, etc. while I bitched about how my gender appeared to be a barrier to networking here and got told I was imagining that. So you will have to excuse the hell out of me for being a hair skeptical about the possibility that banning this practice will somehow immediately lead to women having better options and wonderfully middle class lives on their own efforts from their gratifying careers and yadda.
- matt4077 8y agoYou are attacking some argument, but certainly not one anybody was making. As for the rest, you seem rather to be rather proud of karma points on the Internet. As someone with almost as many of them, I am somewhat intrigued. Do I get access to some secret club that I never even dared to dream about before? FWIW I have never had as much as an email conversation that started on HN. I actually doubt anybody even notices usernames. Personally tptacek(?) is the only name on HN I remember, and that’s only because he tends to make exactly my arguments, only better.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoAs someone with almost as many of them My other account, that I retired shortly after it hit the leaderboard last year, has 25k karma. I will refer you here and then say no more on the matter cuz Reasons: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18466918 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18466918
- belorn 8y ago> "I can assure you that marrying a man who can afford to feed and house you is better than marrying a man who can't afford that" It is nice to see that the open secret being spoked out aloud. It is the basis for the counter argument by MRA that instead of bias against women, it is different incentives for men and women that is driving men to get money and power in disproportional amount. This then lead to stereotyping and sexism where a large portion of society assume and even associate those desire with male gender, and they judge male worth and social status based on it. > They envied me the fact that I had been home with my kids. From a social status perspective I am not surprised. I would hazard a guess that if you instead told them how you worked for months on a oil rig for a heavy pay check while the kids were young it would generate a very different response. The difference in how social status is gained and maintained is significant for men and for women. To then go to actual solutions, developed countries does not have a significant different view on social status and gender roles. The gender expectations if anything has an even large impact if we look at places like Sweden, often called the Gender-equality paradox. Bride price does not exist in developed countries simply because children there are not expected to support the parent. There is multiple ways for men to signal wealth so that aspect of bridge price is resolves through other means such as expensive ring, clothing, cars, restaurant dinners and other social status signals. In order to eradicate the practice of bride price you have to distance the dependency that parents has on children when they grow old, and how important a large family is for survival and success.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoI doubt "social status" is the best explanation for those statements. Bride price does not exist in developed countries simply because children there are not expected to support the parent. That's insightful and good info. It suggests working on retirement funds et al is one of the things that can be done by anyone who wants to try to find a realistic and constructive path forward to end this practice.