18 ms·
Robert Langlands: The Greatest Mathematician You’ve Never Heard Of?
- avip 8y agoThere should be a submission guideline that disallows such useless titling.
- Rainymood 8y agoYou can downvote and flag the post, but the title of the submission is the same as the title of the article, so I see no problem. Unless of course the article is pure clickbait.
- avip 8y agoI don't think it worth flagging, maybe some HN readers are interested in Langland's work? Just retitle it, prefix [note for clickbait-aversed: it's Langland]
- OJFord 8y agoI wouldn't do that, I'd just prefix `Langland: `, so the title remains as in the article, but a bit like a subtitle. (I Would Also Remove Clickbait Case But Maybe That's Just Me!)
- ColinWright 8y agoMany, many times I've put in the time and taken care to create a better title than the one on the article, only subsequently to have it changed by the mods. I've given up doing that.
- garblegarble 8y agoIt's Robert Langlands[1], for anybody who doesn't want to give in to the clickbait title 1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Langlands https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Langlands
- coldtea 8y agoWe should stop abusing the term clickbait for everything and anything. Journalists (and editors) used juicy titles since centuries, as part of the art of writing a piece, even when the piece was buried well inside a newspaper or magazine that you would have already bought to see it anyway... "This is an article about Robert_Langlands the mathematician" doesn't strike as nice as a title. This is a typical journalistic title, and not at all the same as the modern notion of clickbait (not to mention the article is a legit article, and not some clickbait listicle or similar BS).
- garblegarble 8y ago>This is a typical journalistic title, and not at all the same as the modern notion of clickbait I can see where you're coming from (since the article does contain interesting details and isn't just restating the headline), but I think this title sits closer to modern clickbait, in the spectrum that runs from dry description to full-on clickbait. I will admit, that this style of title has always infuriated me in particular: it feels like the editor is infantilising their audience by imagining the public only know the things that journalists decide to write. Also I'd personally expect a journalistic title to at least mention the subject. Even something as simple as "Robert Langlands: the mathematician you've never heard of" would be a big improvement
- diegoperini 8y agoI've heard of him and I'm just a regular everyday normal guy who codes for a living.
- coldtea 8y agoYou'd be surprised how "regular everyday guys" haven't heard of him. In fact I'd be surprised if most US citizens can even name the vice president of the US, even with all the hoopla around Trump's presidency...
- martinbalsam 8y agoOh, Robert Langlands! I worked on a short film about him, for the Abel Prize ceremony, last March. http://www.abelprize.no/artikkel/vis.html?tid=73176 http://www.abelprize.no/artikkel/vis.html?tid=73176
- BucketSort 8y agoThis is a charming film! How did you decide to include things like that little bit about him paying for the lectures he had posters of? Or the scene where you were peaking in from outside (which I suppose is a metaphor for the craft of creating character films in the first place).
- wenc 8y agoNice short film. Langlands was a theory builder as opposed to someone like Erdos who was more interested in solving problems. Theory builders are often admired, but because the endeavor is so broad, very few of them emerge and even fewer are actually successful. I like the part where he said he began to write before he understood everything, and in order to write he had to discover many things, and even had to discover them after he started to write. It underscores the crucial role of writing in discovery. Most writers will tell you they are exploring the space during the writing process. Writing isn't a process of committing what you already know to paper; it's a process of learning what you don't know and or haven't considered. It often leads you down paths you would never expect. (this happens to me with my HN comments too -- I often myself writing a very different comment from the one I set out to write) This is why I think a Ph.D. dissertation should be a continuously evolving collection of notes, and not something you "write-up" in the end after all the work is ostensibly done.
- Koshkin 8y ago> as opposed From The Rising Sea: Grothendieck on simplicity and generality by C. McLarty: Grothendieck describes two styles in mathematics. If you think of a theorem to be proved as a nut to be opened, so as to reach “the nourishing flesh protected by the shell”, then the hammer and chisel principle is: “put the cutting edge of the chisel against the shell and strike hard. If needed, begin again at many different points until the shell cracks—and you are satisfied”. He goes on to say: "I can illustrate the second approach with the same image of a nut to be opened. The first analogy that came to my mind is of immersing the nut in some softening liquid, and why not simply water? From time to time you rub so the liquid penetrates better, and otherwise you let time pass. The shell becomes more flexible through weeks and months—when the time is ripe, hand pressure is enough, the shell opens like a perfectly ripened avocado!"
- BucketSort 8y agoHe has a lecture series I've posted about a few times - https://video.ias.edu/The-Practice-of-Mathematics https://video.ias.edu/The-Practice-of-Mathematics
- impendia 8y agoWorking mathematician here -- 1. Langlands is indeed a great mathematician, whose work has been enormously influential. 2. Most of us aren't all that eccentric. He wrote his paper in Russian, a language which he (presumably) does not natively speak, apparently just for the heck of it? That's just weird. Most of the mathematicians I know, including the most influential ones, are relatively normal people. And they want as many people to read their work as possible, and don't throw up artificial roadblocks. (Most working mathematicians cannot read or write Russian.) 3. There is not that big of a conflict between pure and applied mathematicians. (Except when they're competing for money, or trying to decide whom to hire in their departments.) The most common attitude among pure mathematicians is: we work on mathematical questions for their own sake, and don't think too much about applications to the "real world" -- but we are happy if it is brought to our attention that such applications exist.
- thanatropism 8y agoIn the library here they have a book called "Russian for Mathematicians".
- Double_a_92 8y agoMaybe if you need to look up some soviet era literature?
- thanatropism 8y agoThe weird thing is that while modern-style mathematics with lots of display maths is supposedly to be less dependent on subtleties of text (as opposed to the arguments of old-style topology books like Munkres, which use display equations a lot less and pack a lot of oomph into dense paragraphs with inlined symbols). But mathematical terminology actually changes a lot -- it's enough to open a page in Wikipedia and switch languages to see. A "field" in the algebraic sense (the real numbers are a "complete ordered field") in portuguese is corpo, but vector fields are campos. And both in Portuguese and French, manifolds and algebraic varieties are the same word (variedades/varietés). Maybe if one starts graphing these separations and collisions across many languages some structure emerges -- obviously no one mixes up algebraic fields with physics fields, but the manifold/variety collision hints at some historical commonality that matters for expressive power at the level of a Grothendieck trying to say something sweeping about the entire landscape of mathematics.
- imron 8y agoBut did he win the Putman?
- ColinWright 8y agoIt seems to me that doing well in competitions is a separate question from going on to do amazing research. There are plenty of people who did phenomenally well in competitions and then went on to be successful being mathematicians in other fields, working at Big Co, or starting up their own company, but most of the really, really top mathematicians that I know didn't go in for competitions. There are exceptions, but it's almost like being a top research mathematician is independent (in the technical sense) of doing well in competitions.
- thanatropism 8y agoI've had a couple of experiences with math olympians. They were both very bright (I don't know how they're not followed by throngs of beautiful ${people who are attracted to men} -- solving compass-and-straightedge problems can be as performative and awe-inspiring as an impressive guitar solo), but they lacked in other hard-to-define areas. They had thin skins for criticism (people like me who have failed in competitions and gotten low grades etc. have a lot more emotional scar tissue) and tended to overestimate themselves. Interestingly, they were never arrogant, they just overpromised a little. They were still valuable workers, but took a strange onboarding process compared to regular dummies (like me) who just want to be the best they possibly can under skull constraints.
- Koshkin 8y ago> women Or men, for that matter.
- thanatropism 8y agoFair enough. Fixed!
- deleted 8y ago
- Koshkin 8y agoE. Frenkel who was also mentioned in the article (as being in a kind of opposition to Langlands), is an interesting figure in his own right. His own account on his career in mathematics is fascinating.
- gnulinux 8y agoI took linear algebra from Professor Frenkel. He was indeed one of the most eccentric professors I had. He made a film called Rites of Math and Love whose trailer was very popular (as a laughing material) in our class.
- nilkn 8y agoIf you haven't heard of Langlands but have heard of Andrew Wiles and his proof of Fermat's Last Theorem, you may be interested to learn that the two are somewhat closely related. Wiles actually proved a part of the modularity theorem, which had been shown by Frey, Serre, and Ribet to imply FLT in the 80s. The modularity theorem is very much a Langlands-style theorem and could be seen as a more concrete version of many of the ideas and conjectures that form the Langlands program. The conjecture now known as the modularity theorem was formulated as early as the 50s and 60s by Taniyama and Shimura, thus predating the Langlands program, and it was taken seriously once Weil gave conceptual evidence for it (but did not come close to a proof). In fact, the modularity theorem is just a very oddly phrased reciprocity law. General reciprocity laws often look astonishingly nothing like the simple law of quadratic reciprocity, or they require some clever squinting to see the relationship. Modularity gives you for any rational elliptic curve E a modular form which is a simultaneous eigenvector for the Hecke operators (one for each prime number p) and whose eigenvalues give the solution counts of the elliptic curve equation modulo p for various primes p. These eigenvalues are also the coefficients in the Fourier expansion of the modular form.
- maliker 8y agoMore like greatest mathematician whose work I’ve never understood. Sadly. At least I can reduce Grothendieck to algebraic topology or Wiles to number theory plus that one old problem. Terry Tao to analysis. But Langlands? Interconnectivity of all sub-fields? I’ve got nothing.
- nicklaf 8y agoI highly recommend reading Edward Frenkel's memoir, Love and Math, which is more or less an up close and personal popular account of the author's involvement with the Langlands Program: Perhaps the most remarkable part of the book though is the way it makes a serious attempt to tackle the problem of explaining one of the deepest sets of ideas in mathematics, those which go under the name of the “Langlands program”. These ideas have fascinated me for years, and much of what I have learned about them has come from reading some of Frenkel’s great expository articles on the subject. To anyone who wants to learn more about this subject, the best advice for how to proceed is to read the overview in “Love and Math” (which you likely won’t fully understand, but which will give you a general picture and glimpses of what is really going on), and then try reading some of his more technical surveys [...] http://www.math.columbia.edu/~woit/wordpress/?p=6266 http://www.math.columbia.edu/~woit/wordpress/?p=6266
- maliker 8y agoThanks! I'll take a look.
- dang 8y agoHN has heard of him: https://hn.algolia.com/?query=Langlands%20points%3E3&sort=byDate&dateRange=all&type=story&storyText=false&prefix=false&page=0 https://hn.algolia.com/?query=Langlands%20points%3E3&sort=by...
- vanderZwan 8y ago> Most mathematicians also agree that the Langlands Program could help find a proof for the Riemann Hypothesis, probably the most famous unsolved mathematical problem (about the distribution of prime numbers). These problems are just as abstract as Langlands’s own work, however, which means his research program as it was originally conceived has little relevance to everyday life. I dunno, figuring out the Riemann Hypothesis could have some far reaching consequences for our understanding of prime numbers, and therefore cryptography, no?
- zornthewise 8y agoNo, for any practical applications, we might as well work assume it is true, the same way we assume quantum physics or relativity are true when building stuff.
- c3534l 8y agoAnd if we actually prove it's not true?
- oluckyman 8y ago“Langlands’s”! Now that’s eccentric.