3 ms·
> "The reaction of the Intelligence Community to many problems is to collect more information, even though analysts in many cases already have more information
by chiefalchemist 8y ago
> "The reaction of the Intelligence Community to many problems is to collect more information, even though analysts in many cases already have more information than they can digest. What analysts need is more truly useful information--mostly reliable HUMINT from knowledgeable insiders--to help them make good decisions. Or they need a more accurate mental model and better analytical tools to help them sort through, make sense of, and get the most out of the available ambiguous and conflicting information."
I would think the key is the latter. That is, even if you get more data it does not become __useful__ information unless you're willing and able to process it.
That aside, it's difficult, if not impossible for us "on the outside" to judge the value of these concept to the IC as we only get to know what the IC wants us to know. They're playing the long game. They're playing chess. Maybe it's just me but when I hear a news story (or a friend / colleague) that says "The NSA said..." or the "CIA said..." I accept those as close to meaningless. The IC is, afterall, in the misinformation business.
p.s. I believe the proper term for tbinking about thinking is meta-cognition. I find it odd that the CIA would avoid using the proper term.
- derefr 8y ago> I believe the proper term for tbinking about thinking is meta-cognition. I find it odd that the CIA would avoid using the proper term. A large part of "intelligence analysis" is just using domain-specific knowledge to take primary sources and translate/summarize them, such that you remove the need for others to have domain-specific knowledge in understanding that data. As such, if you're pedantically using ten-dollar words just because they're "correct", you're not doing your job as an analyst. High-level IA is about other things, but that doesn't mean you unlearn the skills you have ground into you as a desk worker.
- chiefalchemist 8y agoCorrect me if I am wrong, but the primary role of IC analysis is to connect dots that other "lay people" / "civilians" might not normally see. To cross bounds and span silos, etc. in other to add value. That being said, if this book is afraid to venture outside its safe zone (and mention meta-congition, even in a passing reference) then this book, by defintion, has failed to do what IC analysis is supposed to do. Ironic, huh. I think it's ssafe to say history is on the side of my analysis of this analysis ;)
- notduncansmith 8y ago> I think it's ssafe to say history is on the side of my analysis of this analysis ;) You’ve provided no examples to support this conclusion.
- chiefalchemist 8y agoUm. The a good number of the known IC mis-analysises are fairly obvious. If you believe there was Russian election hacking, start there and work your way back. A highlight going back would be the CIA training of UBL. The IC was instrumental in escalating the Vietnam War. Etc. If the IC's job is to think about thining the unthinkable, they have in fact come up short in a big way often enough. I sincerely didn't think stating the obvious was kosher on HN. Sorry.
- ckastner 8y agoThe concern you voiced is expected and addressed in the preface of the book: The articles are based on reviewing cognitive psychology literature concerning how people process information to make judgments on incomplete and ambiguous information. I selected the experiments and findings that seem most relevant to intelligence analysis and most in need of communication to intelligence analysts. I then translated the technical reports into language that intelligence analysts can understand and interpreted the relevance of these findings to the problems intelligence analysts face. The result is a compromise that may not be wholly satisfactory to either research psychologists or intelligence analysts. Cognitive psychologists and decision analysts may complain of oversimplification [...]
- ACow_Adonis 8y agoAs an analyst, using the "right term" is down at about the very bottom of my list of things to do, especially in the form of a book. More important is communication to your audience, and in that respect "meta-cognition" is pretty awful vocabulary that strongly limits your audience in this case.
- chiefalchemist 8y agoI see it differently. Meta-congition is fairly straightforward. You have meta, we know what that is. And we have cognition. Again, obvious. Put another way, if you're in the IC or getting info from the IC and the use of the word / concept meta-cognition scares you then something is very very wrong. The audience here isn't TMZ viewers. Is it?
- chrissam 8y agoYou know what's even more straightforward than "metacognition"? "Thinking about thinking".
- chiefalchemist 8y agoWho was the famous thinker who said less words are better? And please see my comment up a level but still below my original comment. Long to story, the IC, by definition, shouldn't be afraid to use the word meta-cognition; it ultimately exposes its analysts to another area of study that could / would broaden then. The irony being, this is what this book is championing. If the IC is too good for dog fooding then we're all in big trouble.
- jonnybgood 8y agoImagine someone coming up to you with no internet available and asks you, "What is metacognition?". What would be your answer?
- ss248 8y ago
- TangoTrotFox 8y agoThink about the countless examples of individuals successfully publishing papers, in a variety of different academic fields, that were intentionally nonsensical or absurd. A big part of the reason they were able to do this is because academia has turned towards excessive use of jargon and estoteric language, even when it's completely arbitrary and serves no purpose other than to try to signal 'hey look how smart I am.' But the point is that as this language seeps into papers, what is actually said becomes ever more difficult to discern and bad logic can be masked in a guise of smart sounding language. And as the fake papers illustrate, this deception works even against experts in the field, or at least related fields. So back to metacognition. This is clearly phrased in a way everybody can understand as 'thinking about thinking.' The latter is, at worst, slightly more verbose. By contrast let's consider another fairly esoteric term such as 'cognitive dissonance.' There is really no way effectively communicate and convey the idea of cognitive dissonance, with all its nuance, in a comparably brief phrase so it makes sense to use the word. But metacognition? It's really just taking a simple concept and replacing it with a fancy sounding word. I don't know why we do this in so many fields. It just creates artificial barriers to communication and clear conveyance of ideas.
- avip 8y agoExactly. Every time I read this Academia mambo-jambo I get an instance Will Hunting flashback. Please, speak, as you might, to a young child. Or a Golden Retriever. Then you have me listening.
- hardlianotion 8y agoThat's a quote from Margin Call - I watched it again last week.
- ekianjo 8y agoNobody understands meta cognition. Thinking about thinking is pretty much as clear an expression as one can get.
- avip 8y agoThe preference of "correct terms" that no one understands (or uses) over simple phrasing is an Academic habit, which should be avoided (and actively condemned) when possible.
- chiefalchemist 8y agoHis target market isn't children. It's not too much to expect him to name the proper term in passing. Even a title of: Meta-cognition: Thinking About Thinking would have been appropriate. Certainly better than: Thinking About Thinking (But Don't Think Too Much) as seems to be implied by some.
- coldtea 8y ago>That aside, it's difficult, if not impossible for us "on the outside" to judge the value of these concept to the IC as we only get to know what the IC wants us to know. They're playing the long game. They're playing chess. "In a game of chess, you must never let your opponent see your pieces", as renowned military strategist Z. Brannigan said.
- ThomPete 8y agoThinking about thinking is a much more powerful concept than meta-cognition. Its much more open-ended and unpredictable and sets you free. Meta-cognition instantly lock you into academic semantics, the last place you want to find yourself if you have to think about a very open ended world.