4 ms·
Everything about this sounds so fucking gross. > A scrappy breed of independent investor > During the boom before the bust, lenders made mortgage loans to cou
by pavel_lishin 8y ago
Everything about this sounds so fucking gross.
> A scrappy breed of independent investor
> During the boom before the bust, lenders made mortgage loans to countless buyers who couldn’t afford them. Lenders later wrote off many of the loans, but borrowers’ obligation to pay remained. Today, in an improved economy, a rag-tag group of individual investors, plus some Wall Street giants, is buying these old loans and trying to tease value out of them.
It's a feel good story of the year! A group of scrappy rag-tag enterpreneurs, with a can-do attitude, hustling by ... going after people who were already fucked at least once.
> Others use loan servicers to try to get mortgage payments restarted so they can feed the loans back into the Wall Street mortgage securitization machine.
Yes, feeding things to a machine definitely sounds like a morally neutral proposition.
- seibelj 8y ago> going after people who were already fucked at least once. I'm not sure it's so clear cut. The last anecdote in the article was a civil engineer with savings and a good salary, who thought his entire mortgage was forgiven by PNC and he got a free house. At least in that case, he should be obligated to pay his mortgage.
- admax88q 8y agoYes I'm sure that's the majority of cases.
- seibelj 8y agoThese are people who haven’t paid their mortgages and weren’t foreclosed on. I don’t think they deserve free houses. These entrepreneurs may use shady tactics but it doesn’t change the fact that they are living for free in a house they don’t own, can’t sell, and don’t have the title to.
- diggernet 8y agoHere is another example of people I don't feel too sorry for... When I was house-hunting after the crash, I noticed that the loan history of most of the short sales (underwater mortgages) I looked at followed the same pattern: - Buy house with minimal down payment. - Over 5-10 years or so as the market climbed, refinance with ever-larger cash-out mortgages. - After the crash, apply for short sale, forcing the bank to take a loss. So, for example, I might see a house with $750k loan on short sale for $350k. But on closer inspection of the history, find that they put $15k down on a $250k house, then pocketed $500k in cash-outs. Sure, they "lost their home", but at the end of the day it feels more like bank robbery to me. Now they probably didn't have all that cash sitting in a bank somewhere. It was probably all spent on one thing or another. But they still got the advantage of spending that $500k. (Not necessarily wisely. The one I remember details of lost both his house and his wife because he blew it all on racing toys.) Yes, there were certainly plenty of people who were legitimately burned in that whole mess. I'm just mentioning that from what I saw, more often than not there were huge cash-outs involved.
- jwhitlark 8y agoYea, I saw several instances of people who milked it for all it was worth, then retired and left everyone else to clean up the mess.
- fierro 8y agowait, can you explain this to me? How does refinancing the home in this example give them a 500k windfall? eli5 plz
- shanedog 8y agoAssume his home was worth 1mm at the peak. He got a new loan for $750 k, paid off his old loan of ~$250k, and pocketed the difference.
- fierro 8y agoright, but now he has much bigger monthly payments, and still owes that 500k back... so it seems all he did here was get a big loan....
- diggernet 8y agoThat is true. But then he stops making the payments. The bank either forecloses and takes the house to settle the loan, or he sells it in a short sale for $350K and the bank writes off the difference. Worst case, he has to file bankruptcy and maybe pay income tax on the amount forgiven. Either way, he still got to spend the $500K on...whatever. Now that I think about it (and these are pure anecdotes), at the time I heard tales of people using the money from refinancing to buy a smaller home with cash. Then they'd move into that and let the first house get foreclosed on (because their paid-in-full primary residence is protected in bankruptcy).
- monochromatic 8y ago>people who were already fucked at least once People who were given money and didn’t repay it. Why should that loan just be forgiven?
- timavr 8y agoI don’t see much wrong in terms of the financial process. People default on the mortgage but keep living in the property. That’s not the way to go. The problem is that most likely foreclosure is not profitable for investors, so in order to collect money, they have to make life miserable for people. But this is just messed up, because mental health is as important as physical health. So if someone stresses people out to get their money, why the taxpayer/family had to get stuck with economic externality? Imagine instead of stressing people out, we cut their limbs if they don’t pay.
- hueving 8y agoHow were they already fucked once? They either went bankrupt and this doesnt apply to them or they kept the house and this does. Nobody is paying for a house twice or losing the house and paying the mortgage.
- jwhitlark 8y agoThere were people who were fucked, but there were also people that were explicitly taking advantage. I know of two cases were individuals bought lots of property, borrowed to the hilt, took the money out of the country, refused to pay the mortgage, collected rent from renters while the foreclosure process was going on, then rode off into the sunset, retiring on OPM.