3 ms·
> It seems odd that society feels entitled to decide what the richest person in the world should and shouldn't do with their money. IMHO society is entitled to
by lisper 8y ago
> It seems odd that society feels entitled to decide what the richest person in the world should and shouldn't do with their money.
IMHO society is entitled to decide whether or not the concept of "private property" should be part of the rules of the game at all. And it is certainly entitled to decide whether or not a vast amount of wealth and power should vest in the hands of a single individual who is accountable to no one. It may be that the answer to both of those question is "yes", but that is not a straightforward consequence of the laws of physics.
- notyourwork 8y agoDoesn't society determine how wealth is concentrated based on how they use their wallets? The wealth accumulated by founding Amazon is due to millions of people's purchases on the retail site. It is further enhanced by the amount of money being spent on AWS cloud services. This is how a free market works, the market dictates where wealth concentrates and disseminates. I don't disagree that in theory we shouldn't have it so lop sided but I don't see how we have a free market without the possibility of a Jeff Bezos rising to the top.
- lisper 8y ago> Doesn't society determine how wealth is concentrated based on how they use their wallets? Only when consumers actually have a choice. That's why monopolies are bad. This is something many people miss about capitalism. The way it is supposed to work is that if Bob starts to make a ton of money, Alice notices this and enters the market herself so that she can capture some of the market currently being served by Bob. The resulting competition drives prices down so that eventually goods and services become available at the lowest possible price. If one person or company is getting fabulously wealthy, that means that the market has failed. Society has a lot of mechanisms for preventing this from happening. Progressive taxation. Anti-trust laws. The laws of physics do not lead inexorably to laissez-faire capitalism.
- davidivadavid 8y agoI think that's a very unique definition of market failure you're going by there. It seems hard to argue that Amazon hasn't driven prices down for consumers.
- lisper 8y agoYou're making the wrong comparison. There is no question that Amazon has improved the retail experience and driven down prices. I love Amazon. I use them all the time. But what you have to compare is the world we live in and a hypothetical world where Amazon had a real competitor. In that world, prices would be even lower. And there would be other benefits as well. There might be an on-line retailer that was every bit as good as Amazon, but which exercised better oversight of their supply chain so that, say, ordering a name brand from them wasn't a total crap shoot in terms of whether you're getting the real thing or a counterfeit, or which carried items that you can't find on Amazon.
- notyourwork 8y ago> I use them all the time. But what you have to compare is the world we live in and a hypothetical world where Amazon had a real competitor. No you don't have to imagine a world where every successful company has a competitor that is completely equal. That isn't how free markets work, that is how things work in theory but never in practice. There is always someone at the top. > There might be an on-line retailer that was every bit as good as Amazon, but which exercised better oversight of their supply chain so that, say, ordering a name brand from them wasn't a total crap shoot in terms of whether you're getting the real thing or a counterfeit, or which carried items that you can't find on Amazon. You love Amazon but you are shooting craps when you "use them all the time"? It seems you want it both ways and want to just imagine a world where Amazon has more competition because Jeff Bezos is the worlds wealthiest person. I can imagine a world where there is a free market and the most successful become the most wealthy.
- lisper 8y ago
- cazum 8y ago>I don't see how we have a free market without the possibility of a Jeff Bezos rising to the top. Abolish the concept of a CEO. If the company is run democratically, as a cooperative, where every worker has a say in how the company is run and how much everyone gets paid, there is nobody to sit at the top of the hill with the whip telling you to break your hands working for $7.50 an hour so they can scrape off and take the 30 dollars an hour of surplus value that your labor generates.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- notyourwork 8y agoInteresting idea though I think you are blending two problems into one. Let's entertain a hypothetical Amazon where its democratically run. Majority of employees are low wage fulfillment workers. So they vote to increase their wages because they are majority. Now amazon isn't able to sustain profitability because low wage work is by very definition low wage work. Would Amazon be as successful in this scenario? I doubt it because their prices would be higher to cover larger employee costs. I don't think democracy in a free market works because a business would self consume.
- dang 8y agoIt looks like your comments for the last six months have all been in political arguments. Regardless of your politics, that's the sort of thing we HN users here not to do. The guidelines say: "Please don't use Hacker News primarily for political or ideological battle. This destroys intellectual curiosity, so we ban accounts that do it." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html Occasional political comments are fine, as I've explained many times: https://hn.algolia.com/?sort=byDate&dateRange=all&type=comment&storyText=false&prefix=false&page=0&query=by:dang%20political%20occasional https://hn.algolia.com/?sort=byDate&dateRange=all&type=comme.... But using HN primarily for that purpose degrades the main mandate of the site. If you'd please not do that, we'd appreciate it.