4 ms·
Democracy the denotative Ideal: rule by the people. In capital-I Ideal form that implies all of the people, otherwise you have some form or another of an oligar
by WorldMaker 8y ago
Democracy the denotative Ideal: rule by the people. In capital-I Ideal form that implies all of the people, otherwise you have some form or another of an oligarchy or theocracy or plutocracy.
The US has always been a compromise between the Ideal and what was seen as practical, codenamed "Representative Democracy" or "Democratic Republic", so it is intentionally never been a strong example of the core tenets of (the ideal form of) democracy, and wasn't originally built to be. It can be said that progressivism in the US has had it a long term goal to make the US more of an ideal democracy, including the ever-widening push towards universal suffrage. That struggle continues and the debate goes on, just as Heinlein's book here is a part of that debate and whether or not the US actually wants an ideal democracy / universal suffrage.
But yes, earned suffrage systems do not make for an ideal democracy, and do seem to be in history slippery slopes towards oligarchy and plutarchy, if not outright fascism and dictatorship. "Merit-based" suffrage systems have been used by dictators to seize power. It's surprisingly easy to do when you control the tests of who can vote that only the people that want to vote for you can vote at all.
- pdonis 8y ago> Democracy the denotative Ideal: rule by the people. I thought we were talking about the core tenets of democracy, not some "denotative Ideal". The core tenet of democracy, it seems to me, is that the people have the ultimate say: they must consent to the government they live under. That does not mean the only government they could or should consent to is one with universal suffrage.
- WorldMaker 8y agoEven if you want to quibble about theoretic versus practical democracy, this side of the US Civil Rights Movement, this side of the US Women's Rights Movement, from where I sit the practical US version of democracy that works the best, more times than not, is one with universal suffrage. Gerrymandering and the remains of suffrage-denying compromises that have far surpassed their usefulness such as the Electoral college are in very point of fact, antithetical to "modern" views of democracy in the US, in my view. I do see it as a core tenet of modern "practical", even representative, democracy today that the only government that people should consent to is one with universal suffrage because "representation without suffrage" is meaningless in democracy and has historically been shown to be such. (Who did the 3/5ths compromise benefit? The slaveholders, not the slaves, never the slaves. There is more than enough retrospective evidence to indict the US founding fathers on that compromise as a non-democratic mistake.) Yes, I realize mine is not the only viewpoint on the subject, because politics is still debating this, but you aren't going to convince me that a "democracy" without universal suffrage is in any practical fact a "democracy" in name or belief. It does sound like the two of us may have evolved very different definitions of democracy in 2018, and we may not come to an agreement on it, sorry.
- pdonis 8y ago> from where I sit the practical US version of democracy that works the best, more times than not, is one with universal suffrage I think you are misinterpreting the historical evidence. The historical evidence is that suffrage should not be restricted for reasons that have no relationship to whether or not a person is a sufficiently responsible citizen. That is why we abolished slavery and gave women the vote. But that's not the question Heinlein is addressing. He's addressing the question of whether suffrage should be restricted to people who can give positive evidence that they are sufficiently responsible citizens. The system he describes in Starship Troopers is such a system: until a person gives positive evidence in the form of at least two years of service (which doesn't have to be direct military service of the kind Rico does), that person cannot vote. (And note that the person cannot vote until they have finished serving; while they're in the service, even if they stay in as a career, they don't vote.) Your position seems to be that any such system will end up being worse than a system where no evidence of responsibility is required to vote. But I don't see why that would be the case. The system we have now is a system where no evidence of responsibility is required to vote, and we have a Congress with approval ratings in the single digits and incumbent re-election rates in the high 90s. Nobody is willing to hold their elected representatives accountable. If that's what universal suffrage looks like, maybe it's time to consider a change.
- WorldMaker 8y agoI'm saying that every time in history where voting has been restricted to "people who can give positive evidence for being 'responsible citizens'" has been used to define 'responsible citizens' purely for (white) nationalism, giving plutocratic power to a minority party. I certainly appreciate Heinlein's thought experiment in the book. It is a useful strawman to argue about/against. In reading the book it gave me a lot of reasons to agree that it sounds good in theory, but sounds abysmal and is likely to fall to cronyism if not fascism in practice. As I stated well above, I appreciate that the film is a particularly strong indictment of the idea by very strongly showing it leading to fascism and propaganda. I read the book that way, assuming the narrator (Rico) to be unreliable and subject to very visible propaganda in the corrupt system to which he is so deeply embedded. The movie does alright by me making that subtext into very visible (not very subtle) text. > The system we have now […] we have a Congress with approval ratings in the single digits and incumbent re-election rates in the high 90s The system the US has now is not universal suffrage. We've seen the highest rates of elections won that do not match the popular vote. The majority of US states are dealing with gerrymandered districting that verges on ludicrous. The approval ratings are an indictment that suffrage is not being universally observed, and that election results are unreflective of actual US demographics. It's time to consider fixing US democracy, and making it more of an actual democracy, not changing it to something that no longer resembles democracy.