2 ms·
You can make this argument about anything: meteorites, viruses, tigers, supernovae... And yet, we're still here.
by mcguire 8y ago
You can make this argument about anything: meteorites, viruses, tigers, supernovae...
And yet, we're still here.
- vidarh 8y agoThis is flawed line of thinking. We can say with certainty that the probability of us being wiped out by meteorites, viruses, tigers and supernovae over any unit of time that fits in our past is less than 100%, but the probability over the same time period repeated over a suitably long multiple of time could still approach 100% to whatever number of precision for any one of those for what we know. By investigating specifics of each of those threat we may be able to assign lower probabilities to them, but the fact we have survived them so far is not in itself evidence of much, because if we had not we wouldn't be here to talk about it and hence, no matter what the prior probability of us surviving the sequence of events leading us here is, the posterior probability of us having survived all the events in our past is 100% (This is basically just a restatement of the anthropic principle) That we've survived so far just tells us that surviving what we've been through so far is possible. It doesn't tell us that doing so is probable if we were to go through it again. Nor does it say anything about the probability of us surviving future threats that is likely to include things we have not yet seen.
- red75prime 8y agoSome of those we cannot control or mitigate. There's, therefore, no point in preparing for them. And neither of those can have a goal (or unfortunate subgoal) of destroying humanity, which goal they will pursue with superhuman perseverance, creativity, coherence and reaction time.