15 ms·
To play devil's advocate - one could argue that allowing gene's to be patented would result in a vast amount of resources being invested, immediately, to decode
by ghshephard 16y ago
To play devil's advocate - one could argue that allowing gene's to be patented would result in a vast amount of resources being invested, immediately, to decode and determine precisely what each of them do - with the rewards from such decoding being secured for 18 years (patent lifetime) - at which point anyone would be free to use the information.
In the absence of a patent incentive, the alternative, then, will hopefully be large government and other large public investments making up the difference.
- carbocation 16y agoI won't do the full analysis justice in a brief comment, but this is an empirical question that has some evidence. The draft human reference genome was published 10 years ago. Prior to this, dozens of genes were discovered and patented by Celera. Celera gave free access to these genes to academics, but required payment for any for-profit activity. By one analysis, genes that were ever controlled by Celera, despite these relatively loose restrictions, as of 2009 had 30% less research done on them than those genes that were never controlled by Celera. http://www.nber.org/~heidiw/papers/5_12_10a_hlw.pdf http://www.nber.org/~heidiw/papers/5_12_10a_hlw.pdf
- JunkDNA 16y agoI worked for a very well known company who licensed some of the early genes that were patented by companies like Celera. It was such a painful experience and the arrangement caused tons of legal knots years later. When the license period ended I distinctly remember an email asking that in addition to surrendering all documents related to the genes, we had to "forget" anything we might have learned personally about them. By that time they were all publicly known, so it was a bit hard to tease out what was learned as a result of the patented genes vs. what you learned from a search at NCBI.
- carbocation 16y agoIf you blog, I'd love to see that comment fleshed out in longer form. Your story sounds very interesting!
- JunkDNA 16y agoI don't have a blog because I have yet to convince myself other people would be interested in what I have to say. I might have to start one.