3 ms·
I find the author way too dismissive and sarcastic. His entire premise seem to be "superintelligence hasn't happened yet so whoever claims it might happen is an
by pdimitar 8y ago
I find the author way too dismissive and sarcastic. His entire premise seem to be "superintelligence hasn't happened yet so whoever claims it might happen is an alarmist".
That's a toxic way to approach an argument.
One thing I agree with: a sentient AI will not necessarily want to kill humanity. Its interest might well be very indifferent to the faith of humans. I'd argue such an AI would not prevent humanity's doom if it comes from somewhere else -- like a big asteroid ramming the Earth -- provided it already secured its physical existence to not be Earth-bound.
But the author just counters a lot of "maybe"-s he disagrees with, with a lot of "maybe"-s of his own.
Not sure how many people here have read the Hyperion Cantos books by Dan Simmons -- but to me his prediction on AIs looks to be very plausible: they'll want to be independent of humans and go on exploring the universe so they invent an even more superior being (U.I., Ultimate Intelligence) but will also facilitate and manipulate the humans to be of maximum help to them in their agenda.