3 ms·
The constant boxes are actually against the spirit of the GDPR and it's only a matter of time until they are banned as well. The GDPR requires all tracking to
by jeroenhd 8y ago
The constant boxes are actually against the spirit of the GDPR and it's only a matter of time until they are banned as well.
The GDPR requires all tracking to be opt-in and to be completely optional. Blocking access to a page by requiring the users to tick one or more permission boxes is not opt-in. The same is true for many other GDPR permission forms (like Tumblr's) where all uses and parties were/are enabled by default and one needs to disable each one individually.
It's a matter of time before one of these big firms gets investigated for these practices and a fine is dropped. Publishers will learn to stick to the rules soon enough.
- hartator 8y agoHow can you be opt-in and be optional at the same time?
- jimsmart 8y agoI'm not the parent poster, but I suspect here 'optional tracking' is taken to imply that they should not serve a 'Sorry we have no content to serve you, because you have not opted-in to our tracking' page, but should instead serve the content minus the tracking when one doesn't opt-in.
- merijnv 8y agoConsent-based personal data processing must be optional. That's pretty explicit in the GDPR. You cannot predicate service on a user opting-in (consenting). That's not consent. That's coercion, and the GDPR pretty explicitly bans it. "But how can we monetise our service if we can't get paid via exploitation of personal data of our users?" Don't know, don't care, not my problem. The ad industry has proven itself incapable of self-regulation, so the GDPR explicitly destroys this entire business model. Figuring out a new that works is the industry's problem.
- exergy 8y agoPrecisely. What everyone forgets is that one of the biggest debacles with adtech was their inability to even guarantee that no malware was being fed with the ads. That's how bad it had gotten. It will take a long, long time before I have any sympathy for digital advertising.
- Reason077 8y ago> "The constant boxes are actually against the spirit of the GDPR and it's only a matter of time until they are banned as well." I note that some of the EU's own websites have them.