4 ms·
> maybe life is common, but sending messages clearly over interstellar distances is pointless and extremely expensive It certainly is. I've heard that we would
by mcv 8y ago
> maybe life is common, but sending messages clearly over interstellar distances is pointless and extremely expensive
It certainly is. I've heard that we wouldn't be able to detect Earth's most powerful broadcasts from a distance of half a light year. So expecting broadcasts to make it across interstellar distances is ridiculous. Tight beam signals might work, but then you've got to know somebody is listening. Nobody knows anyone here is listening, so nobody is sending anything to us.
But I thought the real paradox according to Fermi is not that we don't receive signals, but that they're not already here. If interstellar travel and colonisation is even the slightest bit possible, and spacefaring civilisations are somewhat common, then some of them must have had a millions or billions of years head start on us, which should have been plenty to colonise the entire galaxy. Why did nobody discover this fertile planet somewhere during the age of the dinosaurs?
The obvious solution here is of course that interstellar travel is so impractical that even in a million years, nobody will ever colonise another solar system.
That, or Erich von Daniken was right.
- krapp 8y ago>The obvious solution here is of course that interstellar travel is so impractical that even in a million years, nobody will ever colonise another solar system. It's also entirely possible that a civilization that colonizes another solar system won't also inevitably colonize the entire galaxy. I think people assume this because the mathematical progression makes sense and because the precedent of humans colonizing other continents makes it seem intuitively plausible, as if space were just a bigger ocean. Decades of space opera and science fiction stories have turned the metaphor into an archetype. Yet if it is true that rockets and radio waves are all anyone ever gets, then every new colony is an investment of hundreds or thousands of years' effort or more, assuming there is always a stellar body nearby with a planet which is amenable to colonization, as if stars were equidistant from one another, and assuming all previous colonies continue and survive. Many people seem to assume that either the entire galaxy must be converted to computronium by Von Neumann probes or no life exists elsewhere in the universe, but to me, detecting the signs of interstellar civilization anywhere in the universe is the least likely possible scenario even if life is common.
- mcv 8y agoEven if it takes a colony 10,000 years before it's ready to colonise, a billion years is a lot of time. If each colony spawns a new colony every 10,000 years, that's enough to colonise the galaxy. But it's entirely possible that colonies don't feel such an urge to spread. We may feel it because our planet is fairly densely populated, but a high-tech colony with all the education and medical tech to not require large families, might grow so slowly that their planet will never feel cramped.
- overgard 8y agoOne thing that strikes me about the idea of colonising the galaxy is it has practically no economic benefit to the people making that investment. Not to mention that any society you set up on a neighbor star is likely to diverge culturally (and perhaps biologically) in significant ways — perhaps to a point where they’re more likely to be mysterious rivals rather than friends.