5 ms·
Perhaps ironically, I can't access this article because I'm unwilling to just click "OK" and allow TechCrunch to pass my data to all and sundry, and their 'cont
by Nursie 8y ago
Perhaps ironically, I can't access this article because I'm unwilling to just click "OK" and allow TechCrunch to pass my data to all and sundry, and their 'controls' links lead to a warren of pages at their parent company's site, and eventually to some sort of login page, with no controls in sight.
In apparent contravention of the GDPR, various parts of the page say that I must agree to their use of my data for third party advertising or I cannot access the site.
- Semaphor 8y agoFWIW, TC works perfectly well with the default uMatrix config (as in block everything third party) and only sets a single, empty session cookie.
- exergy 8y agouMatrix is a life changer. No one can understand the sheer scope of how much one gets tracked until you log into a random article on the internet where bloody Pinterest or LinkedIn scripts and cookies are present. It's maddening, and uMatrix is amazing.
- laurent123456 8y agoI'm wondering actually, is there any browser extension that would get rid of these popups (as well as all these "we use cookies" useless banners)?
- nephrite 8y agoSwitch off JS or use uBlock - it can block arbitrary elements in any page, and works in two clicks.
- olex 8y agoThe Oath consent is not just an overlay, it's a separate page that TC redirects to. Not as easy to block as on-page elements.
- icebraining 8y agoTC, to their credit, works really well without JS, so it's just a matter of disabling it.
- sbhn 8y agoBut what happens when Oath buys uBlock
- grive 8y agoIt cannot buy uBlock origin.
- downandout 8y agoIn apparent contravention of the GDPR, various parts of the page say that I must agree to their use of my data for third party advertising or I cannot access the site. They can say that they have a legitimate interest exemption - and they do. Sites must be able to earn money from their content, or they cannot operate. Therefore, they have a "legitimate interest" exemption for this practice (allowed under GDPR) - they cannot provide you with the service you requested because you are unwilling to help pay for it by allowing third party ads. Edit: By the way, none of this addresses the other elephant in the room. TechCrunch is US based, and to my knowledge they do not offer foreign language translations of their site, at least on the .com version of the site. This meets the test under Recital 23, which says that if it doesn’t “envisage” serving EU users, it isn’t even subject to the GDPR. Any privacy notices on TechCrunch.com are essentially a courtesy.
- hadrien01 8y agoIt has nothing to do with showing ads or not, it's about the use of your data to show "relevant" ads. Publishers can still show ads.
- Nursie 8y ago> They can say that they have a legitimate interest exemption - and they do They don't. That's not a legitimate interest. Making money from the data is not covered and if it was then the entire law would be moot. > they cannot provide you with the service you requested because you are unwilling to help pay for it by allowing ads. You missed the word targeted there. And the massive background dissemination of data that accompanies them. That's the issue.
- downandout 8y agoThey don't. That's not a legitimate interest. While I live in the US, I used an EU VPN for a few weeks just to see what would actually happen under GDPR as an EU user. I couldn't stand the popups after a while - GDPR has ruined the user experience of the web for 500 million people. But through that experience I saw that most sites based in the EU are either a) ignoring GDPR entirely, or b) taking the position that showing ads from third party ad networks without specific consent is a "legitimate interest" - whether you agree with that position or not. I also witnessed countless sites that required user consent in order to view content.
- farazzz 8y agohttps://outline.com/7WY9hk https://outline.com/7WY9hk