I think the problem is prodigy has two general connotations. If one reads the definition/s of the word both are there. 1. It means just means highly talented.

I think the problem is prodigy has two general connotations. If one reads the definition/s of the word both are there. 1. It means just means highly talented. 2. Some who accomplishes/performs something rare/unusual/novel. I tend to go with number two as well, but for instance if you look at the etymology its roots are more in the first definition.[1] [1] https://www.etymonline.com/word/prodigy https://www.etymonline.com/word/prodigy