3 ms·
Believe me, if I could think of a way to make karma more accurately reflect the value of comments, I'd already have done it.
by pg 19y ago
Believe me, if I could think of a way to make karma more accurately reflect the value of comments, I'd already have done it.
- jdroid 19y agotowel thrower!
- bkbleikamp 19y agoWhat about weighting votes based on karma + time on site? So the top 10 contributors would have karma votes that count for more than someone new to the site?
- xenoterracide 19y agoI'm not sure that I see that as fair. Why is it just because you've been around for 5 years that your opinions should be greater than those of someone of 5 minutes? or that they should be greater than those who are too busy to spend every waking moment on HN. This would actually allow trolls who have nothing better to do to have better karma than those who actually make intelligent comments. I think the karma system is fine, and in fact better than some others. The only thing I'd change is the # of karma points something need to get into the rss feed.
- smhinsey 19y agoThis is something I've been mulling over for our site (one of the big US newsmags) which gets a lot of comments but has very limited community. One of the approaches I've decided to explore a little further is tying your karma to the votes on other articles, outside of a certain threshold. I'd like to use the threshold to prevent people from getting "bombed" if they upset the wrong person. The general hypothesis is that there is a relationship between the quality of your contribution and your support of quality contributions from others. the general implementation idea is that when you vote, it impacts your karma. For example, if you upvote an unhelpful but witty comment and others come and vote it down, you'd lose karma. If you voted up a comment that others also voted up, you'd gain karma. There are a lot of ways to game such a system, so you'd need to be really careful about the side-effects of this (it should probably only account for a small portion of your karma, for example) but I think it has promise nonetheless. I like to think of it sort of as Page Rank for comment karma.
- hugh 19y agoWouldn't this just encourage people to "pile on" by upvoting things which already have high scores, or downvoting things which already have low scores?
- smhinsey 19y agoThat's why I emphasize that the key is making sure you set thresholds around it. For example, don't perform the calculation when the post has more than a 10% distribution in votes, or you could add a freshness component, so you would only gain the karma when you are the first upvote on something that ended up being popular.
- meredydd 19y agoCounting 'freshness' is even worse - that just turns the whole thing into a game of speculation. "Piling on" to existing popular consensus does enough damage to originality, but what you propose would explicitly reward a proactive chase of the lowest common denominator. For an exploration of similar ideas, take a clicky: http://www.nplusonemag.com/?q=node/473 http://www.nplusonemag.com/?q=node/473 (I actually think I might have seen here first, but forgotten to save it...)
- smhinsey 19y agoIt's worse only in the narrow context in which it's allowed to be dominant. This isn't a zero sum game. Taking the time differential between when a contribution was posted and when it first met a "value" threshold (say, 5 upvotes) and rewarding one of the people who voted in the affirmative by giving them, say, .25 karma points for it, does not reward the lowest common denominator. My hypothesis is that it might have exactly the opposite effect by encouraging those who might otherwise be excessively frugal with their votes to use their voting opportunities in a meaningful way. In other words, if you want to look at this in absolutes and think that when I say that I think it's a good idea to take a given variable into account that I am somehow implying that the variable is free of all bias and in every other way perfect, you are making a mistake. You will never have high confidence for all of your variables when they describe human interaction, but that low confidence doesn't speak to the utility of the variable, it speaks to its importance in the overall calculation.
- joseakle 19y agoHere´s an idea. Comments with downvotes are like spam. Comments with upvotes are like good email. Train spam filter with comments. Use auto karma for comments with few votes, maybe they were just late to the conversation. Comments with little votes get boosted or downgraded based on spammyness.
- meredydd 19y agoTo that, I can only reply: Startup Y Combinator startup Lisp Paul Graham startup startup hacker startup.