4 ms·
> They said she was 45.306 percent Hispanic, 32.321 percent Middle Eastern, 13.714 percent European and 8.659 percent “other,” which included a mere 2.978 perce
by BurningFrog 8y ago
> They said she was 45.306 percent Hispanic, 32.321 percent Middle Eastern, 13.714 percent European and 8.659 percent “other,” which included a mere 2.978 percent African.
Decimals aside, since when is "Hispanic" a race? What could that even mean?
That too aside, 3% African is black according to the still predominant "one drop" doctrine of blackness in this country.
- Nasrudith 8y agoTechnically it is an ethnicity but the South American population does have a larger percent of assimilated natives than continental Spain and a long history of a caste system which put born natives lower in the hierarchy than those born in Spain which could arguably make them a more divergent set of genetic traits being messily correlated. One can argue about the name but "Hispanic" is a workable proxy for the broad brush of 'everything below the continental born caste'. Of course if you want to talk genetics instead of silly human labels you look at the actual contents of their genome.
- masonic 8y agoTechnically it is an ethnicity No, it's defined by geography only. Someone of pure Spanish blood and another of purely Mayan blood can both be "Hispanic". "African" is similarly vague. A pure Bantu, an Egyptian, and an Amazight from Morocco are all African.
- Nasrudith 8y agoI realized afterwards that I had meant nationality but that wouldn't be quite accurate either - unless you count former ones like "was once a part of the USSR". And even that would probably be pushing it.
- BurningFrog 8y ago"Hispanic" is a useful concept in some contexts. I don't see how DNA analysis can be one of them!