4 ms·
There are a number of flaws with this argument, but one major obvious one is the idea that finding life on mars would show the probability of life generating on
by cortesoft 8y ago
There are a number of flaws with this argument, but one major obvious one is the idea that finding life on mars would show the probability of life generating on a random planet is high. The premise of this argument relies on assuming life arising on Earth and Mars are stochastic processes that each occurred independently; on the contrary, there could be shared featured of Earth and Mars that make life more probable on those two planets than elsewhere.
The 'great filter' could be shared between the two planets.
- rlpb 8y agoEarth and Mars are also close enough to have seeded each other: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Martian_meteorite https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Martian_meteorite
- starbeast 8y agoGiven the amount of waterbears and the fact that they are small enough to get blown off the top of the atmosphere by solar winds, I suspect that perhaps one waterbear per century has the conditions to briefly wake up on Mars and wonder what the hell is going on before dying.
- 8fingerlouie 8y agoConsidering that they can survive the vacuum of space, 1000 times more radiation than other animals, few days at -200C (30 years at -20C), and they can be dehydrated for 10 years, i'd say they'd probably briefly wake up, wonder what the hell is going on, then doze off in a 30+ year hibernation state.
- tynpeddler 8y agoFinding life on Mars, or anywhere in the solar system, would be huge and would radically improve our ability to predict life elsewhere. If it's chemically different from earth life, that would revolutionize our knowledge of complex chemistries. If Mars life is chemically similar but independent of earth life, that would suggest that life tends to use common chemistry. If life on earth and mars has a common origin, that would tell us a lot about the early solar system. In short, N=2 doesn't sound great, but it is lightyears better than N=1.
- anonytrary 8y agoIt's about as meaningful as asking 9 people in the same, small, rural town if they like going to the library, then concluding that x/10 people, in general, like going to the library. Maybe that particular town has a really shitty library.
- dcbadacd 8y agoOr a really good one.
- anonytrary 8y agoOr, maybe 9 just isn't enough to get an idea of the other 900,000,000,000,000,000,000... planets.
- bufferoverflow 8y agoI like reading, but i hate libraries (as in physical buildings), at least in the western countries. With almost everyone having internet access, there's no point. Digitize everything, put it online.
- tropdrop 8y agoI hate sports, but I don't argue there's no point to them because there's no point to them for me. A library's advantage isn't just "musty old books" books (some young people, myself included, love physical books and have small apartments!). It's also a free, public space you can come to just be. If you're a kid who has no spending money, you can come to do your homework, or code. Especially relevant for kids who have a poor learning environment at home (too many siblings, parents fighting, etc.)
- lawlorino 8y agoThanks for sharing your opinion I guess?
- starbeast 8y agoAre you currently in charge of the UK government, by any chance? I only ask, because presumably someone has to be and it doesn't look like it is the people on the telly.
- SubiculumCode 8y agoI think you are on to something about shared dependencies, but have trouble thinking about the impact of these might be. They share more similar cosmic positions in the galaxy, perhaps have more similar chemical compositions, they both share the same sun. Is that enough?
- jack9 8y ago> The premise of this argument relies on assuming life arising on Earth and Mars are stochastic processes that each occurred independently That isn't the premise. It's the premise of how it got there for a straightforward example, but doesn't avert the filter questions (regardless of how it got there).