5 ms·
You guys should make them a proposal - scrap all the Diaspora code, replace it with Appleseed code, then rebrand it Diaspora. Best of both worlds - the more ma
by SkyMarshal 16y ago
You guys should make them a proposal - scrap all the Diaspora code, replace it with Appleseed code, then rebrand it Diaspora. Best of both worlds - the more mature Appleseed codebase, and the fame of Diaspora (get it quick before it's squandered).
You could even continue calling the codebase 'Appleseed', while the public brand/trademark/implementation would be Diaspora.
- patrickaljord 16y agoAppleseed is php soup, no ruby dev would touch it, and certainly not the diaspora devs.
- michaelchisari 16y agoPatrick, I'd be interesting in hearing what you mean by "php soup." I've developed what I consider (having over a decade of software development experience) to be a very capable MVC framework. Are you speaking to your particular feelings on PHP itself, or do you have specific criticisms of the codebase?
- patrickaljord 16y agoI'm more speaking of php in general, sorry about that. My point is you will have a hard time convincing a ruby dev to do php.
- karterk 16y agoHaven't we already put an end to this "PHP is crap" line of thinking? Every language has its good and bad. Any dev worth his salt should be able to understand it, rather than attaching blind faith and getting tied to one specific language or technology.
- patrickaljord 16y agoI like many languages, I just happen not to like php, sorry if I offended you. I don't know any dev who don't have a language they don't like.
- castis 16y agoThats okay, I'm a php developer and you couldn't pay me to touch ruby ;) I don't like the feeling of someone else doing the work for me
- tiles 16y agoJust as with any field, I think competition in the distributed social networking space will only be beneficial in the long run. Why should Diaspora adopt Appleseed if they want to tackle the problem space in their own way, with their own ideas? More importantly, why should Diaspora hijack the work of Appleseed, simply because they're a more popular brand? I agree that it would be much quicker to start the movement away from Facebook if Diaspora leveraged other people's experience, but I'd be remiss to dictate how they should run their startup simply because they became popular so fast and I want to use them as a flagship for distributed social networking. This movement will eventually succeed on its own merits, whether or not Diaspora succeeds itself. In the meantime, let two teams with great potential (Appleseed and Diaspora) continue to develop their ideas about how they'd accomplish it.