3 ms·
Ask HN: Recommend an Online Encyclopedia for Home-Schooling
My kids are a bit to young for unfettered access to Wikipedia. ("Daddy what's 'fisting'[1]?")
Does anyone have any experience with any online Encyclopedias? Please and thanks.
-----
[1]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fisting/ <-- NSFW
- Mithrandir 16y agoUnfortunately, the only way right now [1] (at least, that I know of) is to use a blocker like Dan's Guradian [2] or similar, to block sexual term filled sites. You could also use search engines like DuckDuckGo and Google to search articles, as those engines block sexually related terms. __________ 1: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:CENSOR http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:CENSOR Obvious link. ;) 2: http://dansguardian.org/ http://dansguardian.org/ Unsure if it can block Wikipedia
- shawndumas 16y agoI use a white list so blocking is not the issue. I need to find a first class encyclopedia to complement our curriculum. And thanks for the wiki link. Illuminating...
- drallison 16y agoWhy not allow unfettered access to Wikipedia? What are you afraid will happen? That your kids will grow up with a positive attitude about sex and some knowledge about what it entails? Or are you worried that your kids will want to talk with you about a topic you find difficult or embarrassing to discuss? Or what? Kid's interests are normally age appropriate although they may mimic or mirror parental interests and behavior to gain your approval. Many kids are sexually active at a fairly early age. The average age of menarche in the US is 13.5 years; the average age of first intercourse is 15 years. Breast development, which usually indicates the beginning of puberty, starts in about 10% of US white females at age seven. Kids are beginning sexual development earlier and earlier. Seems to me that an informed sex positive kid is better equipped to deal with life than one who is kept in the dark.
- shawndumas 16y agoEven if I agreed it's still an issue of timing. Would you agree that somethings are age appropriate and other things are not?
- drallison 16y agoI think that kids should be allowed, even encouraged, to explore anything that captures their interest, particularly when the thing being explored exists in the world of ideas. It's really hard to break your arm or get a concussion from reading a book, stumbling on an idea, or surfing the web. I'd even go so far as to extend that permission to their parents (and other older people). In the more physical realm, I also think exploration should be encouraged, but there some adult supervision makes sense, but only to mitigate the possibility of significant injuries. You want to teach your kids how to explore the physical world safely and cautiously, and do it without restricting their imagination and actions. Most scientists and engineers will tell you about the many things they did as a kid that were dangerous and educational. We owe it to our kids to let them learn about things on their own. Kids interests change over time; "age appropriate" means, for me, that the materials are things which most kids of a particular age are known to be interested in and that the content is of such a level that the target audience can understand it. For example, it's age appropriate to talk about mathematical concepts such as counting, sequences, and sets to a preschool child, but it's probably not appropriate to do it with a formal set of axioms, theorems, and proofs. Kids are pretty good at self-selecting their own materials.
- shawndumas 16y ago"I think that kids should be allowed, even encouraged, to explore anything that captures their interest..." anything?! Really? Ok, rhetorically speaking; What about race-hate propaganda? How about a book that praises the joys of religious intolerance? Might we want to see books on these topics held in reserve for an older more discerning audience? Now a real question: So fisting is ok at what age-range then? Don't miss the direct question. I am asking for an age-range so that you won't say something like, "well.. that er... depends on the child". Pick a range when fisting is, in your opinion, a healthy endeavor for male children.
- Mz 16y agoOff the top of my head, I don't know of something like that. I went to my own website to see if I had something like that listed and I don't seem to. I do have some links to educational resources (though I really don't maintain the site these days so there are probably a lot of dead links). I imagine a good homeschool list would be able to give you a lot more links to kid-safe websites than HN can. Though a quick google turns up this list: http://ivyjoy.com/rayne/kidssearch.html http://ivyjoy.com/rayne/kidssearch.html (FWIW, I basically did give my homeschooled sons unfettered access to the web with two rules: 1) no porn and 2) no learning how to blow up the world.) FYI: I copied and pasted the wikipedia URL you posted and it tells me something totally safe for work: "Wikipedia does not have an article with this exact name. Please search for Fisting/ in Wikipedia to check for alternative titles or spellings. Start the Fisting/ article, using the Article Wizard if you wish, or add a request for it. Search for "Fisting/" in existing articles...."
- shawndumas 16y agothank you very much. you are correct in the home schooling sites giving recommendations but I wanted something first class and HN is the place I thing of when thinking first class websites. oh and as to NSFW: leave off the final '/'
- hga 16y agoWell, most home schoolers start with the landmark 1911 11th edition of the Encyclopædia Britannica because it's very good and now public domain: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Encyclop%C3%A6dia_Britannica_Eleventh_Edition http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Encyclop%C3%A6dia_Britannica_El... If the above doesn't provide adequate versions I know of one that's available on CDs for installing on your computer(s). This one does however I gather violate the "no access to 'learning how to blow up the world'" or at least yourself requirement. And of course it doesn't cover anything since then.
- Mz 16y agoThis one does however I gather violate the "no access to 'learning how to blow up the world'" or at least yourself requirement. The OP didn't express a concern about that. That was my general rule of thumb, which was rooted in the fact that (as I understand it) specific knowledge about how to create thermonuclear weapons is classified, controlled info and simply expressing zealous interest in trying to acquire it can potentially get one in trouble with the government. Also, I pulled my kids out of school in part to avoid being the next Columbine: My oldest was fantasizing about running over the school with a tank and his father had the keys to a military motor pool. I'm not sure if it contained any tanks but I am sure it contained Bradley fighting vehicles. Most civilians seem unable to tell them apart and I'm sure an angry adolescent would not have quibbled about the difference while taking it on a joyride through the school building. My sons know quite a lot more than the average person about military tactics and weapons. It wasn't a real restrictive rule. The question of "how to blow up oneself" never came up. I had no reason to believe my sons were suicidal, just potentially homicidally angry about some of their school experiences.
- shawndumas 16y agoSent it on to the wife. Thanks! (Though it not having anything since 1911 is a severe limitation.)