10 ms·
That is called "not happened yet" in our lightcone. It's an easy concept to grasp, but many people resist considering an event to have not yet happened when it
by dotancohen 8y ago
That is called "not happened yet" in our lightcone.
It's an easy concept to grasp, but many people resist considering an event to have not yet happened when it has not yet crossed our lightcone. If you are really interested, then I suggest Stephen Hawking's book A Brief History of Time.
- mitchty 8y agoYep, if we haven't observed it, it is effectively not happened. Same as finally observing some of the first galaxies created after the big bang. Speed of light ~= speed of information. If we haven't seen indication of it directly or indirectly, its at best an inference.
- bsmitty5000 8y agoIsn't there two events here: the actual supernova and our observation of the supernova. So the actual supernova event could have occurred but our observation is when it crosses our 'lightcone'?
- arnarbi 8y agoYes, but the point here is that the first event is unobservable and thus not worth considering.
- trhway 8y agoThat is extremely incorrect. If for example we know for sure that the observations we've made so far lead to supernova explosion in 10 years and thus the resulting life-threatening gamma burst reaching Earth in 2028, it would make sense to do something before the actual "observation" of the burst.
- btilly 8y agoThe issue is that "now" is not well-defined since it depends on the reference frame. Therefore what we consider "already happened" another observer may consider "still in the future". All observers will agree on the order of events if and only if the light from each event traveled to the next before the next happened.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- sctb 8y agoMost of your comments break the guidelines by being uncivil and/or unsubstantive, so we've banned the account. If you'd like to start using the site as intended you're welcome to email us at hn@ycombinator.com.
- krastanov 8y agoYou are right, there are two points in space-time (the definition of the word "event" in special relativity). But the "space time distance" between them is zero! (another way to say that is that the two points have light-like separation) All of the weirdness of special relativity stems from that definition of "space time distance", which is just an extension of Pythagoras' theorem: distance = sqrt(x^2+y^2+z^2-(c*t)^2) x, y, and z are the differences in spacial coordinates between the two events (in a given coordinate system) and t is the difference in time coordinates (in the same coordinate system). The minus sign is where the interesting effects stem from.
- jackhack 8y agoSchrödinger's cat emits a meow, indicating "yes."
- nightcracker 8y agoThere is no "the actual supernova". That's the whole point of relativity.
- AnimalMuppet 8y agoIn relativistic terms, "the actual supernova" is an event (an x, y, z, t quad). It's a perfectly well understood entity in relativity. The point in relativity is that different coordinate systems put different numbers on x, y, z, and t, but they all are talking about the same event. When we see it, we will be able to put a perfectly accurate x, y, z, and t on the supernova in our coordinate system, with t being "8000 years ago". All this has nothing to do with relativity, merely with the finite propagation speed of light.
- dotancohen 8y agoYou are right about everything except the t. When we observe the supernova, we will call that moment t=0.
- AnimalMuppet 8y agoIf we call the moment at which the light reaches us t=0, then we will say that the supernova occurred at t=-8000, because we know where it occurred, and we know what the speed of light is.
- nightcracker 8y ago> When we see it, we will be able to put a perfectly accurate x, y, z, and t on the supernova in our coordinate system > our coordinate system You just defined the whole issue away. "Our coordinate system" is not shared by anyone not in our frame of reference.
- raattgift 8y ago> "Our coordinate system" is not shared by anyone General relativity provides a toolset for a complete transformation from "our coordinate system" to any other: a diffeomorphism between coordinates, and laws of physics written in generally covariant form and obeying some constraint equations for values on any three-dimensional submanifold. If the supernova's matter is that of the standard model of particle physics, you get everything after the comma in the previous paragraph. So any two observers of the supernova have a straightforward mechanism for relating observations against their idiosyncratic choice (or choices, they aren't restricted to just one!) of system of coordinates. The actual observables are independent of the choice of coordinate systems. You'll find (mathematical) proofs of this in discussions of the initial value problem in General Relativity; (physical) evidence is the same as that from astrophysical tests of General Relativity. As a practical matter, realistic observers will only measure a tiny subset of the total observables of the supernova, and different observers will measure a different subset, even if they use precisely the same system of coordinates. Obscuration by dust or distance is not caused by the coordinates in which one expresses distance or the size of dust particles. > There is no "the actual supernova". That's the whole point of relativity. No, coarsely, there is a 4d-worldtube along which one finds a WR star, a supernova of type Ib or Ic, and a remnant. Or more finely, there are worldtubes for large numbers of particles that are bound together gravitationally and through standard-model interactions into these more macroscopic objects. In some compact region of spacetime a collection of these particles is best described as the start of a Ib or Ic supernova; their worldtubes diverge (possibly spectacularly) elsewhere in spacetime. Or, if you like, we take a roughly 4-cylindrical section through the spacetime-filling fields of the standard model such that somewhere in that 4-cylinder the excitations of the fields are best described as the start of a Ib or Ic supernova. Really, it doesn't matter, because we know mathematically how to relate each of these descriptions, and have a good idea about why we might choose one description over another when asking various questions. That is the whole point of relativity.
- andrewflnr 8y agoIt's not the light cone that matters for simultaneity, it's the reference frame. Everyone in the same reference frame (or close enough) is going to agree about the order of events once they compare notes when the dust settles. I don't think this system is moving fast enough relative to ours for relativity to screw things the common sense meaning of "happened yet". At least, this is how I was taught in my college physics class.
- gregdunn 8y ago> Everyone in the same reference frame (or close enough) is going to agree about the order of events Not necessarily. On a macro scale for general human interactions, for the most part, but the only thing observers have to agree on is space time interval and causality. Space, time, and order (if not important to causality) might be different.
- andrewflnr 8y agoThat's because humans are mostly all in the same reference frame. And hey, so is this binary system, within astronomy- sized error bars anyway. I'm not sure the terminology of "observer" is totally consistent, but it's definitely true that you can only disagree with another observer on ordering of events if you're in a different reference frame, basically if you're moving at a (noticeably) different velocity. In the presentation of SR I saw, "observers" are basically identical with reference frames. What is "observed" is exactly the sequence of events pieced together from instruments in that reference frame, close enough to "see" all the relevant events with negligible lightspeed delay, all with synchronized clocks. "Seeing" a distant event, the time when light from that event reaches a particular point, is an entirely different question that, frankly, we mostly ignored.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- colechristensen 8y agoIt is debatable whether or not that is the correct way language should handle whether or not an event has happened. Counterexamples in two situations: 1) The cosmic microwave background is, in short, the light still traveling from an early stage in the big bang when the universe turned transparent (380,000 years after the big bang, when the universe became cool enough to form hydrogen atoms) You can see the big bang happening. So when would you say this phase transition to transparency happened? Here you would say it happened 13.5 billion years ago. At the source of the CMB photons you can see, you would say that is happening now. With that language construct you have an event which happened across the universe simultaneously happening both 13.5 billion years ago AND right now, depending on location. Which, I think, is absurd. 2) Talking to an astronaut on Mars. Mars is between 3 and 22 light-minutes away. If you want to say hello to your Martian friend, it will take between 6 and 45 minutes for your radio to play the sound of your friend saying hello in response. What is happening while you are waiting for the response? (how do you discuss the time, what "now" means) To your friend your message has "not happened yet" while to you it already happened. It is silly to have a definition of "to be" that must ignore the practicalities of simultaneous events which involve non-trivial light transit time. It is very easy to talk about a "now" where both Earth and Mars have the same timeline dispensing with the light cone and talking about light travel taking time. It is not so easy the other way around.
- hgdsraj 8y agoRelativity of silmulntaneity https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Relativity_of_simultaneity https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Relativity_of_simultaneity
- shkkmo 8y agoAs far as I understand it, there is no such thing as simultaneous events that don't occupy identical locations. There is no "now" that is shared and can be discussed meaningfully. Simultaneity can only exist within a spaciotemporal frame of reference. E.g. events that appear simultaneous on Earth will usually not appear simultaneous on Mars. This may seem silly, but this is how reality works and as humans adjust to opperating in multiple spaciotemporal frames of reference, our language will have to adapt
- Certhas 8y agoThat's a bit like saying "Going 50 miles an hour is a meaningless concept, you should say 50 miles an hour relative to the surface of the earth". There is an implied reference frame here.
- fspeech 8y agoI see confusion about reference frame. It is perfectly okay to say something is happening at 1 million light years away. And there is no ambiguity within our presumed Earth reference frame. Of course we won't know for another million years if such a claim is true. But if it is, it is perfectly sane to say it happened a million years ago when we do observe it. The point is given a reference frame, it is perfectly fine to specify an event with location and time, so long as you specify both location and time. These have nothing to do with light cones. [Add] To give another more relevant example if we observe a signal today coming from a location one million light years away, there is no ambiguity to say it happened a million years ago at such and such location. Anyone in a different frame can compute the time and location of the event unambiguously for their own frame, knowing the relative velocity between the frames.
- gregdunn 8y ago> It is perfectly okay to say something is happening at 1 million light years away. Well, maybe. Maybe not. Carlo Rovelli would argue that time doesn't exist like that (or at all) and that saying that something is happening now when it is beyond our lightcone would be a meaningless statement, and a lot of physicists would agree with him. (A lot would disagree, too.) Reference frames only clear this up if time does exist in a meaningful way and 'now' is more than a construction of our own observation.
- raattgift 8y ago> (or at all) Rovelli's position is that time is not fundamental, not that it does not exist. It emerges from something more fundamental. That is, he argues that there exists a theory (or family of theories) from which one can derive both General Relativity and Relativistic Quantum Field Theory in their effective limits, and that such a theory does not need to be paramaterized by time (or more broadly, does not need to explicitly reference the notion of time at all). More precisely, he and Connes propose[1] that statistical regularities in a generally covariant quantum system (our block universe) are just as much "laws" as dynamical relations like F = ma or F = dp/dt = \gamma(v)^3 m_0 a_parallel + \gamma(v)^1 m_0 a_perpendicular. There are macroscopic constraints and a low-entropy initial condition in the universe that takes our system away from being in just any configuration with equal probability, and towards a configuration with an entropy gradient. From that entropy gradient we can recover a notion of time, and even coordinatize it. Time emerges in a block universe (and indeed most subregions thereof) arranged in this way. > something is happening now when it is beyond our lightcone Galaxies probably don't cease to exist at the moment they cross out of our causal cone with the metric expansion, or soon afterwards. We exist even though there are observers who saw our ancestors cross out of their causal cones. Do you think the density and spectrum of the CMB evolve very differently for them and for us? Do you assert that such a question is meaningless? Do you think Rovelli does? (If so, why do you think that?) - -- [1] A. Connes, C. Rovelli, "Von Neumann Algebra Automorphisms and Time-Thermodynamics Relation in General Covariant Quantum Theories", Class. Quantum Grav. 11:2899–2918, 1994. https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9406019 https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9406019