3 ms·
I'm not making any claims about what environmentalists are doing. I'm making a claim about the marketing. People don't like their industries, their beliefs, o
by amluto 8y ago
I'm not making any claims about what environmentalists are doing. I'm making a claim about the marketing. People don't like their industries, their beliefs, or their ideas being painted as evil or immoral. There are plenty of good people out there who are involved in the coal industry, some of whom are or were coal miners.
If you want their votes and you tell them that coal is evil and should be eliminated, you're going to gain a lot of opposition. I think that, instead, environmental groups should cast it as: coal is being outcompeted in sustainability, and, when the cost of handling emissions and waste is factored in, cost. (And it's often being outcompeted in cost even without any of that.) I think that people who have an economic state in coal should instead be encouraged to demand that the coal companies apply some good ol' American ingenuity and some genuine R&D investment into making coal remain useful.
(A similar idea applies to industries like steel. Blaming foreign countries for the US steel industry's declines at various times may appeal to some voters, but a more productive message would be to blame steel industry executives for sitting on their collective arses. [0]) A message demanding that they spend money and effort to keep up might be much more effective.
[0] https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2018-03-05/steel-history-shows-how-america-lost-ground-to-europe https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2018-03-05/steel-...