8 ms·
the jobs that are mentioned in the article that are being hit the hardest are teachers, firefighters, caretakers and so forth. How many of those have been auto
by Barrin92 8y ago
the jobs that are mentioned in the article that are being hit the hardest are teachers, firefighters, caretakers and so forth. How many of those have been automated away?
It seems that tech workers in the valley have found their own analog to blaming immigrants for downward wage pressure, their particular boogeyman seems to be the robots.
No, the answer is much more trivial. As the article points out, the huge influx of capital in the area is being returned only to the tech sector, who merrily spend it and drive up the cost of living. The machines are not to blame for this one.
- empath75 8y agoI think there’s a step missing in the analysis there. If tech workers are spending all this money — what are they spending it _on_? If they’re spending it locally shouldn’t that increase wages locally?
- jameslevy 8y agoShelter and avocado toast.
- x3n0ph3n3 8y agoWe're spending it on housing, mostly.
- jchrisa 8y agoRent. Are the landlords local?
- mlindner 8y agoAll apartment complexes around here are owned by Californian corporations. So yes, they're local. For example, Essex: https://www.essexapartmenthomes.com/about https://www.essexapartmenthomes.com/about They're even publicly listed: NYSE:ESS Or the Irvine company, after which Irvine, California is named after because they designed the city. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Irvine_Company https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Irvine_Company
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- tomjakubowski 8y agoIrvine and the Irvine Company are both named for the Irvine Ranch and James Irvine who developed the property after donating a chunk to the University of California. A fun fact is that the University of California, Irvine, was named that six years before the city was incorporated.
- theDoug 8y agoAn area it's being spent on is rent at properties largely owned by property firms. In the case of the building I live in (in "downtown" Sunnyvale), the three front office workers and two maintenance persons come nowhere near making a dent in the $4.5 million in income this one property earns yearly. Can't speak to the wages of the staff in the other >12 buildings in the portfolio, but the folks keeping this place running aren't driving Teslas.
- burlesona 8y agoNo. They’re spending it all on housing. To be clear the flow is: tech companies make enormous revenue but require high skill workers. To make this work they pay whatever it costs to get workers and no more - in this case that means just enough to offset the enormous cost of housing. Since the baby boomers practically banned all housing development in the bay once their little burns were built, this result in a little see-saw battle where landlords raise the rent until tech companies are forced to raise wages, back and forth. Employees are left with an equation that looks basically like: enormous salary - obscene rent = just a bit more cash flow than you’d earn in software anywhere else. Thus the flow of capital is from tech companies to landlords, in an arms race that will only end when the landlords have taken so much of the capital out of tech that the industry sputters and moves away.
- rrcaptain 8y agoOr until landlords are abolished like they should be.
- orangecat 8y agoEmployees are left with an equation that looks basically like: enormous salary - obscene rent = just a bit more cash flow than you’d earn in software anywhere else. It's probably true that the cost of minimally acceptable housing drives entry level tech salaries, but they go way up from there. A senior SWE at Google with salary+bonus+stock of $300k/year has a whole lot of disposable income even after the ridiculous housing expenses.
- solidsnack9000 8y agoThere are very few senior SWEs at Google, relative to tech employees as a whole.
- burlesona 8y agoFirst off, Google employees are the outliers even in SF. Second, there are many situational factors that make a huge difference as to whether 300k leaves “a whole lot of disposable income.” The simplest is families living on one income. In most of the country this is easily achievable if you can break six figures, but in SF housing is priced for two full area incomes, so if you want to make it work with one parent at home you either have a relatively small and ratty apartment (compared to housing stock elsewhere) or you spend $6000+ per month on housing which takes a dramatic bite out of that $300k you’re taking about.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> I think there’s a step missing in the analysis there. If tech workers are spending all this money — what are they spending it _on_? They often aren't, they are saving it (effectively, often directly, investing in the global capital markets and/or, insofar as their compensation has an equity component, directly in their own firm.)
- someguydave 8y agoRight there are no immigrants to speak of in silicon valley
- hiram112 8y ago> It seems that tech workers in the valley have found their own analog to blaming immigrants for downward wage pressure, their particular boogeyman seems to be the robots. While you'll no doubt continue telling the deplorables that they're racist and xenophobic for failing to welcome their currency and cost-of-living arbitraging foreign-replacements with open arms, could you at least refrain from pretending that the basic laws of economics (i.e supply and demand) no longer exist? Immigrants increase the supply of labor, and thus lower wages. That's not a boogieman. It's a fact.
- adamch 8y agoPresumably those immigrants also increase demand for food, housing, services, transport, etc. Whether the increased demand outdoes the increased supply or vice-versa is going to vary situation by situation.
- matt4077 8y ago> That's not a boogieman. It's a fact. Nope.... Immigrants are more likely to start businesses than the local population, thus creating jobs. Mostly that's small service and retail businesses. But also Google and Tesla. Plus, obviously, a population increase also drives demand. In fact, for every job that somebody has, exactly one job was somehow created, on average. In your theory, the US could radically lower unemployment by simply splitting up.
- someguydave 8y agoYes and SV is famously flooded with immigrants.
- grandmczeb 8y ago> As the article points out, the huge influx of capital in the area is being returned only to the tech sector, who merrily spend it and drive up the cost of living. Most of the cost of living increase is due to bone-headed housing polices happily voted in by existing residents, the vast majority of which do not work in tech. I personally find it very sad that we've prioritized rewarding a tiny, vocal minority at the expense of literally everyone else, but it seems a large number of people would rather point fingers at the villian-of-the-day than change anything.
- beaconstudios 8y ago> I personally find it very sad that we've prioritized rewarding a tiny, vocal minority at the expense of literally everyone else you mean the tech industry? I mean, sure NIMBYism is a big problem but the tech industry gentrifies everything it touches.
- throwawaythekey 8y agoAre the policies bone headed? I'm not American so may not have this perfectly right but the Detroit of the past seems to be a good analogue to SV. Lots of well paid jobs in a single industry. When the eventual downturn occurs you don't want to be left with a ghost town.
- village-idiot 8y agoCA voted in an effective freeze to property taxes back in the 1970s, with property tax increases being capped at 1% per year and the rate being transferable to your children. This has created a landed aristocracy in CA cities of those paying well less than the normal rate in taxes, badly distorting the market and local economies (no property tax, no services), resulting in lots of silly policy choices.
- praxulus 8y agoDetroit enjoyed ~3 generations of prosperity before declining. It would be silly to deny the opportunities provided by the tech industry and the wealth it generates to millions of people just because the area might eventually decline.
- kokokokoko 8y agoThere was a study which I cannot locate right now which discussed that one of the substantial impacts of a Walmart moving into a town was that all the "community leadership" type jobs left. Things like accountants and office admins and other business professionals. This was because the small businesses Walmart replaced were the ones that used these services locally. Walmart did these things at it's corporate office far away from the community. So those who did mid-level things like accounting or office administrative work could no longer find work locally and either had to move or take a lower paying service worker position at Walmart. Essentially what that reveals is that most of these mid-level jobs are susceptible to the Balassa-Samuelson (BS) effect [1] Which means that most jobs that do not require physical labor onsite are either being rapidly outsourced to cheaper markets or automated if possible. This ends up being that group in the middle of the pay range and likely accounts for the reduction in overall wages for that group. [1] http://www.bankpedia.org/index.php/en/87-english/b/23137-balassa-samuelson-effect-encyclopedia http://www.bankpedia.org/index.php/en/87-english/b/23137-bal...
- Ibethewalrus 8y agoThe Walmart study sounds quite interesting, and makes sense. Source?
- jldugger 8y agoIt's not wrong, a LOT of tech companies have opened up support offices in Texas. The inexplicable thing is why engineering stays in SV.
- root_axis 8y agoThat's like asking why banking stays on Wallstreet. It's because that's where the biggest and most influential firms are headquartered.
- jldugger 8y agoI think it's a fair question though. Obviously talent is tough enough to recruit that you don't tell engineers they're relocating and expect to keep them. But you can choose to build offices outside one very influential city: - Google bought the Port Authority building, which is like 2 empire state buildings in terms of office space. They have plenty of engineers working there: https://www.wired.com/2010/12/google-nyc/ https://www.wired.com/2010/12/google-nyc/ This year they bought the building next door: https://www.blog.google/inside-google/company-announcements/furthering-our-new-york-investment/ https://www.blog.google/inside-google/company-announcements/... - Apple has a large campus in Austin: http://fortune.com/2016/09/01/apple-austin-campus/ http://fortune.com/2016/09/01/apple-austin-campus/ - Amazon's obviously diversifying "HQ" locations The question is why companies hiring engineers by the thousands every year keep pushing to open more offices in the valley. Why is it ideal to shift HR and accounting away from the west coast but keep engineering local?
- Reedx 8y agoNot really. The money mostly goes to landlords. VC -> Startup -> Employee -> Landlord
- dredmorbius 8y agoTime to relearn the basic classes of economic goods, and their corresponding pricing behaviours: commodities, wages, rents, interest, public goods. Land, monopolies, skills and talent endowments, capital, and power all return rents. Likely risk as we'll. Most of books 1, 2, and 5 of Smith. https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/The_Wealth_of_Nations https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/The_Wealth_of_Nations
- solidsnack9000 8y agoOne point Smith makes is that land rents tend to eat all other forms of revenue over time, since (a) the supply does not increase, (b) the use of land is necessary for every enterprise and (c) over time all the land that can be put to some use is and then it's just about competition over it.
- dredmorbius 8y agoRents are defined as goods or services in which the seller captures not merely costs but consumer surplus.
- solidsnack9000 8y agoSmith talks about land specifically. Not sure where you're going here.
- dredmorbius 8y agoConsumer surplus is a modern definition. It follows from Smith, though somewhat indirectly. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economic_rent https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economic_rent
- pkaye 8y agoIf you look up Transparent California, some public employees make pretty good income. In San Jose, there are quite a few of them making >$500k. Similar with other cities. And that doesn't count the lifetime pension, health, early retirement some of them get. https://transparentcalifornia.com/salaries/2017/san-jose/ https://transparentcalifornia.com/salaries/2017/san-jose/
- rrcaptain 8y ago>And that doesn't count the lifetime pension, health, early retirement some of them get. That website explicitly includes benefits, what are you talking about?
- gpm 8y agoFirefighters - fire retardant buildings, sprinklers? Anecdotally I've heard that we need a lot less fire fighting these days because fires don't spread the same way anymore. I would be interested in seeing real data though. Caretakers - all those robotic vacuums that are starting to become ubiquitous. Certainly not a total replacement but it lowers demand for humans. But you don't need to automate a job to depress it's wages, just increase the supply of potential workers by automating many of the other jobs.
- davidgay 8y ago> Anecdotally I've heard that we need a lot less fire fighting these days because fires don't spread the same way anymore. Hmm. In California? No. [Ok, the bit about "spread[ing] the same way" may be relevant, but not in the implied direction. And yes, the need for large numbers of firefighters in an emergency undoubtably makes planning/costs tricky.]
- gpm 8y agoI assume you are referencing the forest fires? As I understand it city fire fighters are a rather different profession. (But no, no one involved in that discussion was from California)
- davidgay 8y agoRe firefighters: my understanding is that local fire departments from all over the state send assistance to large fires, see, e.g., https://abc30.com/local-fire-departments-assisting-in-wildfires-preparing-for-search-and-rescue-missions/4678230/ https://abc30.com/local-fire-departments-assisting-in-wildfi... I'm confused by "(But no, no one involved in that discussion was from California)" in the context of a discussion about salaries in Silicon Valley... Edit: and from out of state too: https://www.stgeorgeutah.com/news/archive/2018/11/11/cgb-13-utah-fire-crews-leave-to-assist-california-firefighters-battling-devastating-fires-on-both-ends-of-the-state/#.W_QmCHpKjUI https://www.stgeorgeutah.com/news/archive/2018/11/11/cgb-13-...
- gowld 8y ago"Cost of living" increases hit hard, but it's not a wage drop. It's an extra point included in the article, not the thesis, which is about wage drops. The article does NOT say that teachers and firefighters are seeing wage cuts. > Workers in low and middle income jobs, such as teachers and firefighters or nannies and cooks, are key to the local economy. teachers and firefighters are middle income, and are the core of that bracket who have demand inelasticity. Store clerks do not enjoy that, so they just lose their middle-income jobs.