4 ms·
I would also like to see the environmental groups and the left in general stop branding coal as somehow immoral. How about instead trying to make coal compete
by amluto 8y ago
I would also like to see the environmental groups and the left in general stop branding coal as somehow immoral. How about instead trying to make coal compete on level ground: tax its carbon emissions, tax its particulate emissions, require real management for whatever waste it produces, and see if any investors or inventors want to keep it alive.
If the CO2 emissions could be adequately captured, the particulates scrubbed, and the fly ash turned into concrete [0], there may very well be a place for coal for hundreds of years.
[0] Fly ash appears to be a pretty good replacement for a large amount of Portland cement, and the latter also comes with quite a bit of CO2 emissions.
- francisofascii 8y agoThe environmental impact is one thing, but I would argue consuming coal unnecessarily is immoral because coal is not easily replaceable. If you cut down a bunch of trees, at least you can replace them in few decades. How long does it take coal to form? Thousands? Millions of years? My point is, one you burn coal, you can't get is back.
- 24gttghh 8y agoCoal can apparently form after "only" many thousands of years, but most of today's mined coal seems to come from the Carboniferous (290-360 Million years ago) and the Cretaceous period (69-144 Million years ago).[0] [0]https://energyeducation.ca/encyclopedia/Coal_formation https://energyeducation.ca/encyclopedia/Coal_formation
- mobilefriendly 8y agoUnfortunately in the real world, with the best available technology, mining coal is dirty, the particulates can't be fully scrubbed, and coal ash is toxic.
- jamesrcole 8y agoThe comment was talking about the hypothetical future ("If the CO2 emissions could be adequately captured, ...") not the present.
- agumonkey 8y agoThere were some stories about a Chinese coal plant manager who made "clean coal" (claims of near 100% clean). Never saw anyone debunking it. I wish to know how true the claims are.
- CodeWriter23 8y agoYour efforts to illustrate potential solutions to coal’s issues at the point of consumption fail to consider production-side problems such as strip mining, slurry pits and ground water contamination.
- Qworg 8y agoThis paper [1] is pretty interesting RE: the effects of fly ash in concrete mixes. It isn't a replacement, certainly, and brings both problems and benefits. [1] https://www.cement.org/docs/default-source/fc_concrete_technology/is548-optimizing-the-use-of-fly-ash-concrete.pdf https://www.cement.org/docs/default-source/fc_concrete_techn...
- WhompingWindows 8y agoI agree with your philosophical stance, however carbon taxes are unfortunately a pipe dream in the US, at least. Look at Washington, a liberal bastion, which was not even close to passing their carbon tax ballot initiative. In this political climate and this atmosphere of denial and propaganda, unfortunately morality is one of the only actually effective weapons left to those who actually care about the environment and the planet. It's all fine and good to prefer a carbon tax, but if that's all you push for, NOTHING has gotten done in this country on that score. The other ways to make a difference, besides pushing hard against the very negative and misery-causing emissions, are to innovate tech, to make clean energy experiences better for consumers, and to push tangentially related policies like EV credits, solar credits, and other policies which help non-toxic energy sources.
- amluto 8y agoI highly support a carbon tax, but I'm unconvinced it makes that much sense on a state level.
- jnurmine 8y agoWon't fly ash leak contaminants to the groundwater supply?
- hristov 8y ago" tax its carbon emissions, tax its particulate emissions, require real management for whatever waste it produces, and see if any investors or inventors want to keep it alive." Actually, this is exactly what environmentalists have been trying to do. This is what the cap and trade system which has been pushed by various environmental organisations was all about. But of course it was blocked by conservatives paid by the energy industry. There is one rare fact that both environmentalists and coal executives agree on -- if the coal industry is forced to pay for their emissions it will die. So I can confidently answer your question -- there would be no investors wanting to keep it alive. Furthermore, the US government has spent literary billions of taxpayer money to make coal environmentally acceptable. All kinds of schemes have been tried -- carbon capture, coal liquification, coal gasification, etc. None of them work. It turns out it is very expensive to capture large amounts of gases for an indefinite period of time. You can liquify or gasify coal at a significant cost, but it still turns out much dirtier than gasoline or natural gas. Even with its current preferential treatment, where it does not have to pay for damage it causes and it uses much government subsidies, the coal industry is generally losing money. Most major US coal companies went through bankruptcies in the last several years. It is highly doubtful investors would want to put good money in coal plants that actually have to pay for their environmental damage.
- amluto 8y agoI'm not making any claims about what environmentalists are doing. I'm making a claim about the marketing. People don't like their industries, their beliefs, or their ideas being painted as evil or immoral. There are plenty of good people out there who are involved in the coal industry, some of whom are or were coal miners. If you want their votes and you tell them that coal is evil and should be eliminated, you're going to gain a lot of opposition. I think that, instead, environmental groups should cast it as: coal is being outcompeted in sustainability, and, when the cost of handling emissions and waste is factored in, cost. (And it's often being outcompeted in cost even without any of that.) I think that people who have an economic state in coal should instead be encouraged to demand that the coal companies apply some good ol' American ingenuity and some genuine R&D investment into making coal remain useful. (A similar idea applies to industries like steel. Blaming foreign countries for the US steel industry's declines at various times may appeal to some voters, but a more productive message would be to blame steel industry executives for sitting on their collective arses. [0]) A message demanding that they spend money and effort to keep up might be much more effective. [0] https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2018-03-05/steel-history-shows-how-america-lost-ground-to-europe https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2018-03-05/steel-...
- SubiculumCode 8y agoI'll take your point to mean this: People who want coal jobs to come back are really just pro- blue collar job. So yes, a good wind blue collar campaign showing hard working men and women that does not harp on the 'evil' of coal, but instead 'harps' on how damn good these new jobs are.
- spenrose 8y ago"I would also like to see the environmental groups and the left in general stop branding coal as somehow immoral. How about instead trying to make coal compete on level ground: tax its carbon emissions, tax its particulate emissions, require real management for whatever waste it produces, and see if any investors or inventors want to keep it alive." As "hristov" notes above, your argument is concisely self-refuting. The coal industry fights tooth and nail to prevent these things, which makes the coal industry immoral by the terms you list. "Coal" is of course a chemical compound. Burning coal at utility scale is only done in contravention of the moral framework you put forth by people who oppose that framework with everything they have.
- flukus 8y ago> How about instead trying to make coal compete on level ground: tax its carbon emissions, tax its particulate emissions, require real management for whatever waste it produces, and see if any investors or inventors want to keep it alive. They've been trying to do this at the international, national and state level for decades now. The Kyoto protocol (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kyoto_Protocol https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kyoto_Protocol) was signed in 1997. Unfortunately right wing parties in most of the anglosphere think market driven solutions are left wing conspiracy theories.
- eigenstuff 8y agoCoal IS immoral, and you don't even have to bring climate change into it. The US coal industry was built by exploiting the poor in Appalachia, from the beginning all the way until today, and then taking all the wealth out of the area and leaving us with nothing. Things I'd like to see talked about? That the largest armed uprisings on American soil since the Civil War were the coal wars in West Virginia in the early 20th century. Coal unions fighting for better than what the coal mine companies, with the backing of local police and sometimes the US military, told them they were just lucky to have. And that of the 900 clean-up workers at the 2008 Kingston fly ash spill, 30 are dead and 250 are dying because they were refused to gear and fired if they brought their own, because if they wore so much as a dust mask, the neighbors might suspect that maybe the largest environmental disaster in US history wasn't as non-toxic as the TVA tried to pretend it was. It will still be years until those people get a dime of compensation. So many places in Appalachia with poisoned water, polluted air, no futures, and no prospects. Cheap energy tho amirite