3 ms·
My feeling: HN is generally negative against blockchain and it's applications, rooting to be proven useless because the Silicon Valley actually missed the windo
by mrtksn 8y ago
My feeling: HN is generally negative against blockchain and it's applications, rooting to be proven useless because the Silicon Valley actually missed the window and it's not on the cutting edge of the wave.
My feelings towards bitcoin(cryptocurrencies in general): A tool to misbehave in a society that is completely regulated and monitored. Its price is going to match the market for misbehaviour. The size of the market for misbehaviour is going to be based on how much the society deviates from moderate: that is, in total anarchy bitcoin can replace the total global money supply and reach millions of dollars equivalent per bitcoin and in totalitarian governments in multipole world order it can be the currency to trade between camps and illegals when the governments tells you not to.
Edit: Hey, it would be nice if you also write why you disagree.
- jhwang5 8y agoFeel exact opposite. HN had a ton of pro-crypto articles trending earlier this year, as well as brigading from pro-crypto subreddits bombing the comments section.
- tyingq 8y ago"HN is generally negative against blockchain" I agree with this part. However, many of us are just negative because of the tendency to try and make blockchain a solution when it's not needed. Especially when it's used somewhere where you already have to trust a 3rd party. In those cases, a traditional ledger is fine.
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> A tool to misbehave Cash is a better tool for misbehaving. Bitcoin is a good tool for misbehaving remotely at a small scale, though even there something like Monero has it beat. The market for small-scale remote misbehaviour is small. Extant, but small—much smaller than the present cryptocurrency markets.
- mrtksn 8y agoI agree but the cash has it's own limitations and governments are trying to get rid of it and actually succeeding in some places like the Nordic countries.
- ageitgey 8y agoI don't think SV missed the window. Coinbase has done very well. I think the reasons a lot of HN people are negative on bitcoin and blockchain are: - For most use cases, blockchains seem like a really inefficient database. While blockchains are are neat data structure and might have some great uses in the future, most of the proposed use cases seem better served by a normal DB. Would love to be proven wrong. - The "power used vs. utility provided" ratio of BTC seems insanely bad. A fairly small financial network (at the global scale) is sucking up a noticeable fraction of energy production. - Crypto brought a wave of very non-technical get-rich hucksters into the tech scene doing pump and dump ICOs and the like. - It seems like a lot of non-sophisticated, non-technical investors are getting duped out of their money. I hear all the time about working class people "getting into crypto" because they think it's a magic money machine and don't really understand the risk. - And the biggest for me: Almost every crypto investor/fan I ask in person has NEVER used crypto to buy anything other than more crypto or to make small purchases. Crypto fans make huge claims like crypto is transforming commerce but it doesn't seem to jive with real life experience.
- mrtksn 8y agoYes there is Coinbase but it is just an exchange, one of many. A really nice one but still just a marketplace(Kids in Japan were doing it like a decade ago). It used to be the other way around, that is, Silicon Valley is early in something that gets big from nothing and the rest of the world makes it's own version after it's proven to be worthwhile. Other than that I agree that there's lot's of BS going on but on the early days of the Web, there was also a lot of BS happening too.
- the_snooze 8y ago>For most use cases, blockchains seem like a really inefficient database. While blockchains are are neat data structure and might have some great uses in the future, most of the proposed use cases seem better served by a normal DB. Would love to be proven wrong. As a corollary to this, a lot of blockchain "solutions" don't seem to even understand the problems they're purporting to solve. They're shoehorning blockchain into issues where it's absolutely inappropriate and claiming victory. Elections come to mind.