3 ms·
> If the results cannot be defended without resorting to an appeal to authority then that is more anti-science than challenging the work itself. I think trusti
by paganel 8y ago
> If the results cannot be defended without resorting to an appeal to authority then that is more anti-science than challenging the work itself.
I think trusting "an independent analysis commissioned by the national science academy" compared to a political action initiated by a few politicians is not "an appeal to authority", quite the contrary. At some point we do have to trust some people who are better prepared and informed than us on a particularly given subject. Especially in the Italian political and social context, where some other scientists have been recently prosecuted for "failing" to predict earthquakes.
- beaconstudios 8y agoto be clear, I was addressing the original complaint, not the response to the independent analysis. If your allegations are addressed by an independent third party and you continue to reject the outcome, then it's pretty clearly conspiracy-based.