8 ms·
Life inside MPEG
- cure 8y agoSee also this thread https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18207478 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18207478 for what that Genomics 'standard' they are trying to push is actually like. MPEG is a rent-seeking organization that doesn't actually contribute anything useful to society. It just tries to lock up technology and standards behind patents, and then extorts money for use of those standards.
- SllX 8y agoArguably MPEG isn't the problem, it's just a symptom. You will not find many people as disgusted by rent-seeking as I am, but the real target in my scope would be US Patent law here. MPEG is the rent-seeking arm of several organizations, some of which actually do excellent technical work that is arguably beneficial to society. They don't have a monopoly on doing excellent technical work, even the kind that is beneficial to society, and back when you could count on MPEG LA being the only contact you needed to license a set of patents, it wasn't the worst state of affairs in the world. Not ideal, but definitely not the worst that an army of lawyers could come up with.
- rayiner 8y ago> MPEG is a rent-seeking organization that doesn't actually contribute anything useful to society. It just tries to lock up technology and standards behind patents, and then extorts money for use of those standards. It’s not “extortion” to charge money for people to use technology you developed, and its a better business model for society than bankrolling that technology through advertising (which is the FB/Google alternative to R&D). MPEG-LA is not locking up technology that already existed or other people developed. Its members are the folks who originally developed this technology. It’s notable that no open-source entity developed something like h.264 first.
- shmerl 8y agoSoftware patents protection racket is a morally bankrupt "business model". It only exists because of the broken legal system that allows such parasites to slow down progress.
- rayiner 8y agoWhile software patents may be broken in many instances, I don’t think video codecs are one of them. It’s not like MPEG-LA is suing people for using independently-developed designs that just happen to infringe. If you’re infringing the MPEG patents it’s likely because you’re purposefully building on their work. And that’s okay in my book. I much preferred the old days when everyone just paid Sony and Panasonic for a license than the current model where “free” codecs are bankrolled by spying on everyone’s email and helping Russians fix elections.
- shmerl 8y agoMPEG-LA are actively trying to impede development of open codecs, or slow them down with FUD and threats. They are acting like a classic racketeer thug. I'm surprised some are trying to whitewash their behavior. I guess glorified mafia is the way to "move things into the future" according to MPEG-LA supporters.
- CamperBob2 8y agoThe problem comes in when patents have the effect of walling off an entire subfield of computer science from the perspective of the commercial R&D world. Classic cases in point are IBM's patent on arithmetic encoding, which rendered that entire class of algorithms radioactive in the 1980s-1990s era, and the original Lempel-Ziv patent claims dating back to 1978. We are most certainly not better off as a society because we granted decade+ monopolies on those claims, and I see no reason to think any differently of MPEG.
- vetinari 8y ago> It’s not like MPEG-LA is suing people for using independently-developed designs that just happen to infringe I think you missed the whole FUD campaign against VPx, where they tried to persuade the public that VPx does infringe patents in their pool.
- masklinn 8y ago> MPEG is a rent-seeking organization that doesn't actually contribute anything useful to society. It just tries to lock up technology and standards behind patents, and then extorts money for use of those standards. You're thinking about MPEG-LA, and even then your description is debatable. MPEG itself is a standardisation organisms (technically a joint subgroup of ISO and IEC), defining standards out of technologies both patented and not. MPEG-LA is a separate and completely unaffiliated entity which licenses patent pools: MPEG-LA does not create or hold patents itself, they get agreements from patent holders and sell "bundled" licenses for all patents essential to implement a relevant technology (or so they claim e.g. MPEG-LA created a patent pool for DisplayPort independently from VESA, which disputes this necessity and asserts the standard is completely royalty-free).
- gsnedders 8y ago> MPEG itself is a standardisation organisms (technically a joint subgroup of ISO and IEC), defining standards out of technologies both patented and not. One could argue that the MPEG could take a stronger stance by requiring a RF grant from its participants like some other SDOs do.
- masklinn 8y agoOne could definitely argue that, but that's a far cry from "a rent-seeking organization that doesn't actually contribute anything useful to society".
- tialaramex 8y ago> standardisation organisms (technically a joint subgroup of ISO and IEC Guessing you wanted "standards organisation" and technically MPEG is a Working Group of a Subcommittee of the Joint Technical Committee between ISO and IEC. Patents are sad because they create an incentive to argue for a technically inferior choice that you "own" over a superior choice that you don't own. CA/B Forum (which isn't an SDO but bear with me) ran into trouble when setting up the Ten Blessed Methods (our name, not theirs) for validating control over an FQDN because it turns out some ways to implement these methods were patented by members. Although CA/B isn't an SDO, the effect of it making rules about how things are done is to set a standard, since all significant vendors in this space are members of CA/B, and all major trust stores require you to obey CA/B rules even if you're not a member. The patents didn't cover any of the good ways to implement the Ten Blessed Methods. Literally in every case the patent described the most unsatisfactory half-arsed way to achieve something you could imagine, the existence of these patents was causing vendors to prefer to do something bad (which they'd patented) rather than something good (which they had not). But there was a reluctance to just say "OK, we patented all this stinking garbage, but forget about that" and get on with it, this stalled things for many months. After all patents aren't free, who wants to admit they bought something worthless? Ugh.
- cwyers 8y agoCommercial development of codecs has put a lot of resources towards codec development, the ability to be compensated for that work enables continued investment, and the ability of standards to incorporate patents means that this work that can be used in broad-based standards. All that society has gotten out of it is cheap, ubiquitous video on a lot of devices that wouldn't have it otherwise without consumers having to pay attention to what video formats they're paying for using.
- microcolonel 8y agoWithout any conscious input, I cringed when I read "MPEG" in the title.
- shmerl 8y agoMPEG hit the unavoidable dead end by pushing the broken patent system to extreme. Their patents aren't driving progress forward, they are slowing it down, and MPEG now reap what they sowed.
- bingobob 8y agoSupport AV1 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AV1 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AV1
- userbinator 8y agoThe MPEG-2 patents expired earlier this year; are H.264 patents expiring very soon, or do they just want to bring in more royalties by putting out H.265 and already working on what comes after it?
- freeone3000 8y agoOf course they want this. This is how they make money - by developing novel video specifications, usually highly competent ones (H.264 was so much better than WMV9 it was silly, and Thora came much later). H.265 isn't quite as good as VP10 in picture quality, so they're developing a new format to fight for marketshare.
- ksec 8y agoEnds in 2027 / 2028. So quite a long time to go still.
- xvilka 8y agoAll these people do more harm than good. Their formats should be abandoned in favor of royalty free formats, for example like AV1.
- wolfgke 8y ago> All these people do more harm than good. Their formats should be abandoned in favor of royalty free formats, for example like AV1. Know your enemy. :-)