4 ms·
This is a very good comment and I hope it rises to the top of the heap. I wrote this post on an HN comment, but I wonder, "Is there an actual Facebook crisis,
by jseliger 8y ago
This is a very good comment and I hope it rises to the top of the heap.
I wrote this post on an HN comment, but I wonder, "Is there an actual Facebook crisis, or media narrative about Facebook crisis?" https://jakeseliger.com/2018/11/14/is-there-an-actual-facebook-crisis-or-media-narrative-about-facebook-crisis https://jakeseliger.com/2018/11/14/is-there-an-actual-facebo...
It seems to me that Zuckerberg doesn't know that he's in a media scapegoating situation. When you've become the scapegoat, there is nothing you can do to stop it. You can observe the scapegoating mechanism, but even that will likely do very little to halt it in action.
The media cannot accept (or comprehensively address) its own culpability for the 2016 election. So let's put the blame on those guys, over there, instead of looking at ourselves.
- GreeniFi 8y agoYou’ve been reading Rene Girard it would seem. And he’s a good guide to what’s going on: they were all at it, but Zuck is soaking up the blame not just for the ills of the social media biz model but the ills of late capitalism.
- Zelphyr 8y agoHe may be soaking up undeserved blame but a lot of it is deserved. He has demonstrated time and again that he has little care for user privacy when that got in the way of selling an ad. People are (hopefully) starting to wake up to how dangerous that is.
- pm90 8y agoI think its the danger part that was not sufficiently recognized and is only now being realized. When the personal data was used to sell soap, nobody really cared. When its used to instead sell political agenda and conspiracy theories... that is when the danger starts.
- aylmao 8y agoTo be fair, it has always been used to sell political agendas. Politicians have advertised in online platforms way before 2016.
- pm90 8y ago> To be fair, it has always been used to sell political agendas. Politicians have advertised in online platforms way before 2016. Agreed. Perhaps a better way to phrase it is that its only in 2016 that the true power of the platform to spread misinformation with a political agenda was realized. Which naturally people care about a lot more than product placements.
- GreeniFi 8y agoFor sure it’s deserved, but as is often the case with scapegoats, FB is not the only one. The Gusrdian collects and sells used data to advertisers, for example.
- nkozyra 8y agoPlenty of blame to spare, but "the media" is a vast and wide net without any specific claims. Regardless, it's whataboutism here. And let's face an uncomfortable fact: the "media" once meant the gatekeepers for information. Facebook is absolutely fulfilling that role in 2018. You cannot separate the two.
- spamizbad 8y agoFacebook received largely anodyne coverage for most of its life; it's only been the last few years that people took a critical eye. And I don't understand your media argument. "The media" spends a tremendous amount of time analyzing and criticizing its own output, even within institutions. If anything, the media tends to catch flack for too much navel-gazing instead of covering actual news. Facebook would benefit from some of that introspection, rather than top-down order-following.
- toomim 8y ago> Facebook received largely anodyne coverage for most of its life; it's only been the last few years that people took a critical eye. No way. You're totally forgetting how much fear the media heaped on Facebook in 2005 first over children having (gasp) photos of themselves on the internet, some people even listing their phone numbers publicly, and then in 2006 and 2007 it was about college kids posting photos of themselves drinking alcohol, which (it was hypothesized) would prevent them from getting jobs when their future employer went through their facebook account. Please. The media narrative around Facebook has been exaggerated fear from the beginning. The only thing new today is the choice of fear to exaggerate.
- spamizbad 8y agoThe examples you give are all “people behaving badly” on Facebook, not Facebook explicitly acting in bad faith.
- behavingbadly 8y agoHere is one (of many examples.) Facebook COO Sandberg hires a right-wing firm to spread rumors and shift blame onto George Soros. This isnt just bad behavior -- this is abhorrent. George Soros gets bears brunt of anti-semitism (recall just weeks ago a rightist sent him a bomb due to propaganda blaming him for literally everything.) https://www.nytimes.com/2018/11/14/technology/facebook-data-russia-election-racism.html https://www.nytimes.com/2018/11/14/technology/facebook-data-... Delay, Deny and Deflect: How Facebook’s Leaders Fought Through Crisis Ms. Sandberg has overseen an aggressive lobbying campaign to combat Facebook’s critics, shift public anger toward rival companies and ward off damaging regulation. Facebook employed a Republican opposition-research firm to discredit activist protesters, in part by linking them to the liberal financier George Soros. It also tapped its business relationships, lobbying a Jewish civil rights group to cast some criticism of the company as anti-Semitic.
- pm90 8y agoIt is not a good comment at all. I know its the go-to reaction for engineers in SV to empathize with a fellow engineer and portray him as a martyr in the altar of an east-coast elitist media. But please look at the facts and details of what NYT has uncovered. > It seems to me that Zuckerberg doesn't know that he's in a media scapegoating situation. When you've become the scapegoat, there is nothing you can do to stop it. You can observe the scapegoating mechanism, but even that will likely do very little to halt it in action. He's much much smarter than you give him credit for. A lot of folks think of him as a clueless programming genius, but this is brilliant guy who understands politics a lot better than most engineers in SV. All the feel-good tours were not for his personal political ambition, but to create goodwill for his most precious, valuable child, Facebook. And he has done every thing in his power to cut the criticism, scapegoat critics and regulation. > The media cannot accept (or comprehensively address) its own culpability for the 2016 election. So let's put the blame on those guys, over there, instead of looking at ourselves. Certainly there is some aspect of that. But please lets look at the facts. Facebook did hire a PR firm that spread Soros-based conspiracy theories against its critics. They fired Stamos when he exposed the extent of Russian intervention and kept quiet or dismissed the magnitude of Russian activity until it became untenable for them to do so. All the steps they have taken to become better, have been forced onto them ... by who? Its by the Media. The media uncovering facts about the company. That's their job: to bring to light these facts. Let them do their job, and lets hope Facebook does its job as well.
- kodablah 8y agoI'm not hearing anyone dispute these facts. Media-driven fervor is rarely devoid of facts. Rather, with story choice and interspersed op-eds, the narrative becomes clear even if not untrue. For every fact-based article, there are dozens of opinion ones (happening with all big-web tech) and my flag-clicking finger grows weary. These digital opinion pieces sharing the same domain become much harder to differentiate than in print. Even if you're focusing on facts, many don't care about them or at least don't consider them or their consequences as damning as the coverage might deserve. At this point, I'll take my bulleted lists of uncovered facts and eschew the rest of this crap. Sadly my peers, pitchforks in hand, can't do so and are hastily cheering on government oversight. Something none of us can ever recover from (a one way street in almost all instances).
- codyb 8y agoThere's a ton of things which impacted the 2016 election (disproporionate representation, 24 hour news cycle's obsession with Trump, foreign interference, people seeming to get most of their media from social media, disinformation, billions of dollars of dark money, disenfranchisement, Comey, etc). However, Facebook's stock has dropped from a high of 220 to 140 (today) in less than six months. That seems like an actual Facebook crisis to me.
- mcphage 8y ago> The media cannot accept (or comprehensively address) its own culpability for the 2016 election. So let's put the blame on those guys, over there, instead of looking at ourselves. After all this time, do you still not realize that Facebook is part of the media, perhaps even the biggest part.
- siidooloo 8y agoFacebook is ‘the media.’ Newspapers, magazines and TV are just advertisements with enough other stuff in the middle to get you attention. Facebook is the same thing.
- tomjen3 8y agoInteresting point. I am not entirely sure that Facebook can't do anything to get out the scapegoat situation though. Of the top of my head, they could say that they want to focus more on your friend and friends, so for the next 2 weeks it will not be possible to share news articles at all and the feed will prioritize messages from people you have lots of mutual friends with. It is kind of hard to argue with, and it would show the media exactly how much power Facebook has over them.
- philwelch 8y agoMaking matters worse, the legacy media blame the tech industry for their own decline and fight back the only way they can, with hit pieces. The NYT did the same to Amazon a few years ago. Facebook, which is a more direct competitor, is an even bigger target.