3 ms·
First off, this is a great thing for Michael Bloomberg to do so props to him, but I think there needs to be a much broader discussion about moving away from col
by Barrin92 8y ago
First off, this is a great thing for Michael Bloomberg to do so props to him, but I think there needs to be a much broader discussion about moving away from college as a sort of 'eye of the needle' mechanism for upwards mobility in the United States.
I'm German so my perspective may be biased, but over here you can pick up an apprenticeship, a dual university/work program and still earn comparable wages to college graduates, and if you enter a family business, potentially even more as they are starving for the next generation to take over.
In the US there seems to be a huge gap between prestigious universities degrees and the fear of ending up working for Starbucks your entire life. Expanding access to universities is fine, but a university education is not for everyone, and should not be a prerequisite for a good shot at life.
- marsrover 8y agoYou can enter a trade school in the US and earn more than many college graduates. I think it’s more of a mindset problem than anything. College degrees give a person a baseline social status whereas trade schools are looked down on as low class.
- dlp211 8y agoCitation needed. This is one of those things that large swaths of the internet believe is true, but is filled with anecdotal evidence and not actual research.
- foxyv 8y agoMost of the people I know who went to trade schools ended up with 7-10x as much student loan debt as I have for my BS and are now working in jobs that require only a High School diploma.
- jorblumesea 8y agoThe US does have numerous vocational schools and training programs, and they result in placement in positions which do pay reasonably livable wages. They are pretty effective, the problem here is a class issue. Getting into the middle class in the US still means you are at the mercy of a variety of problems. Higher education is still the ticket to an upper middle class life, partly due to ingrained structures like larger cities lacking affordable housing, a tax system that favors capital classes, and high healthcare costs for the poor and middle classes. Containing/reducing medical costs, reducing housing costs and a fairer tax system might be the real answer here. The core issue is that, for example, the poor and middle classes can easily be bankrupted by a medical bill, whereas white collar software engineers are likely to have very good and cheap health insurance that covers much more.
- wenc 8y agoOn a related note, we often hear about folks losing their jobs and having a hard time retraining. A college degree is theoretically supposed to teach one critical thinking and self-didactic skills. I wonder if vocational education is less robust to economic shifts than a college degree? Certain trades like cooking, plumbing and electrical work are always going to be in demand, but suppose one trained as a machinist and finds oneself unemployed as society deindustrializes. Is it harder for a machinist to retrain than for an English major to pick up basic clerical skills?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- maxxxxx 8y agoIn Germany the vocational system is also declining. You can still have a decent job but if I had kids I would recommend them got a masters or bachelors. What Germany doesn't have is that extreme split between universities with big names and the rest.