3 ms·
These article are pretty ridiculous and I see this political bent more and more on here. The article/book makes a huge leap in assuming progressive cities are
by jayd16 8y ago
These article are pretty ridiculous and I see this political bent more and more on here.
The article/book makes a huge leap in assuming progressive cities are somehow worse at housing. The reality is people actually want to live there.
The most densely populated cities in the US, and in general all cities, lean left politically. Finding new housing is important but we're really losing perspective on how successful these policies have been historically.
Its a silly as writing an article about NASCAR crashes. They must be terrible drivers.
- Domark 8y agoThe problem is, I've been hearing about these problems since I lived there in 1995. 1995 would have given an intelligent species enough time to build a money-losing, poor-people housing skyscraper or two. Yes building vertically in crowded places is a challenge and expensive but those are just excuses. Since 1995 they could have figured out a way to get the job done, so now we have to examine what the problems are.
- jayd16 8y agoBut again, you're starting at the point of assuming failure, when in fact these cities are the most dense. Feel free to examine but the core assumption that this is obviously the wrong way to do it is baseless.
- mynegation 8y agoI am all for vertical build but this idea is scary. The standards for maintaining tall buildings are especially high. There is a high chance this ends up being Kowloon city or going down in flames like Grenfell Tower. Let alone the political optics of putting a lot of poor people into a very limited space.
- gaadd33 8y agoIsn't that what the "towers in a park" style of public housing from the 60s and 70s are? From that we've found that it isn't a good solution, eg Cabrini–Green Homes or Robert Taylor Homes I think people have been looking into these issues for far longer than 1995.
- twelvechairs 8y agoSpeaking as someone who works in this field theres a lot weve learned about towers. Suffice to say dont build them in the middle of nowhere, for the poorest in society only, and with acres of non-defensible space in front. The best planning in cities today is building transit oriented development at a scale to match your city's housing need. Do it in the right places with a reasonable design and it works great
- skewart 8y agoI don't think the issues that emerged at Cabrini Green and Robert Taylor Homes can be blamed primarily on their design. I suspect the systemic lack of maintenance and overall poor management were far more significant factors. There are thousands of safe, clean, and healthy "towers in the park" public housing projects around the world - from Singapore to Spain. And there are plenty of low-rise and townhome public housing projects in the US that suffer from health and safety problems.
- TeMPOraL 8y ago> 1995 would have given an intelligent species enough time to build a money-losing, poor-people housing skyscraper or two. Welcome to planet Earth. We humans are intelligent as individuals, but not as a species. At species level, we're just gradient descenders with delusions of grandeur.
- rhizome 8y ago"No true intelligent species" is a new one. A little misanthropic for me, but whatev. Since 1995 they could have figured out a way to get the job done If only someone tried. I mean, for how long have people agreed on what "the job" is? Too long, if at all?
- thrav 8y agoThere’s no denying that building is a hell of a lot easier in a place like Houston without zoning than anywhere else though.
- Bucephalus355 8y agoGrew up in Houston and now live in Austin and your statement is 100% accurate. Housing in Houston means you can get an 1800 ft house for 90k 15 miles from downtown. In Northwest Austin, let’s say 20 miles from the city center, such a house would cost 300k plus.
- jayd16 8y agoI've never lived in either place. How is the transit there? In SF and Los Angeles, 20 mile could mean an hour commute. We do bump up against natural obstacles but it could certainly be better.
- davidf18 8y agoIf one studies basic microeconomics, then one understand the concept of "market failure" or market inefficiency. They include rent-seeking, externalities, and information asymmetry. The housing shortage is nothing more than a classic case of rent-seeking, which in this case is that special interests, for example, wealthy landlords, using politics to create an artificial scarcity of land through zoning density restrictions. The typically Democratic city councils are bought out by the wealthy landlord special interests and everyone else is harmed, including basic wealth creation (the wealthy landlords are not creating wealth but are taking their unfair share through political influence). The Democratic city councils, while publicly critical of Trump, actually embrace policies of zoning density restrictions that make Trump far, far wealthier than he would be in an efficient market and normal people far poorer. The fix to the housing crisis is quite simple: remove the market failures, eliminate the zoning density restrictions. Japan did just that almost 20 years ago by having a federal law that override local zoning density restrictions. The result: in 2014, in Tokyo alone, 140,000 housing units built. NYC only 20,000 and all of California about 90,000. In today's world, a fundamental course in Economics should be required just as basic courses in English and writing are required. It is astonishing how many college students and college grads don't understand even the most basic concepts for microeconomics and market failures. For further reading: Havard Economist Edward Glaeser: Build Big, Bill (NYC Mayor). https://www.nydailynews.com/opinion/build-big-bill-article-1.1913739 https://www.nydailynews.com/opinion/build-big-bill-article-1...
- darren0 8y agoYour assuming the government made the city desirable. An argument can be made that geography made the city desirable and government made it less.