4 ms·
I believe the cause of this may be the use of student evaluations. Students don't like hard professors, and give them bad evaluations. To some extent, professor
by yummyfajitas 16y ago
I believe the cause of this may be the use of student evaluations. Students don't like hard professors, and give them bad evaluations. To some extent, professor's continued employment is dependent on having good evaluations. Hence, grade inflation.
In my personal experience, you can lose 20-30% of your evaluation based on hard grading. My reason for believing this? When I was a TA (i.e., "I don't write the tests, but I'll help you pass them"), I got typical evals of about 4.5. When I became a postdoc and started writing my own tests, my evals dropped to about 3. I don't think I became a worse teacher over the course of a single year, so I'm guessing my low evals resulted from not giving out easy tests.
(Not to mention several comments on the evals claimed that tests were too hard. I.e., "bad professor, highest grade on midterm was 75 out of 110!")
This is an agency problem which is fairly easy to solve: standardize exams and evaluate professor quality based on VAM instead of student opinion.
- jseliger 16y agoI believe the cause of this may be the use of student evaluations I would posit that evaluations aren't the problem, per se. The real problem is one of incentives: professors are hired and fired (otherwise called "denied tenure") based almost entirely on publication at most big public universities. Teaching plays a nominal role in hiring and promotion decisions. This gives professors an enormous incentive to optimize what they're going to be judged on -- research. Evals are a problem because they only look at what students think of the prof. A more useful measure than just what students think would be a graph of what students think versus the class's average/median grade, plotted against others teaching similar courses. Then you could correct for "easy graders" and "hard graders." standardize exams and evaluate professor quality based on VAM instead of student opinion. A lot of disciplines don't have standardized content, especially in the humanities and social sciences. A lot of profs emphasize different topics and ways of doing things, even in science and math. This might create problems worse than the problem it's trying to solve without solving the incentive issue. Those of you waiting for a proposed solution from me are going to be disappointed: the only solution I can see is "incorporate teaching into hiring and tenure decisions," but I don't see a way to get universities to do that. The New York Times Magazine wrote a very good article about prof evals: http://www.nytimes.com/2008/09/21/magazine/21wwln-evaluations-t.html http://www.nytimes.com/2008/09/21/magazine/21wwln-evaluation... . I'm a grad student, and I'd like to say that I grade as fairly as I would if I didn't know that evals correlate to grades. But...
- yummyfajitas 16y agoI agree with you that teaching matters little at Research I universities, at least for full profs. It does, however, matter to the army of adjuncts working there, as well as to profs anyplace besides Research I schools. At Research I schools, the incentives for inflation are mainly about avoiding non-research work. An actual conversation I was involved in: Student: "But how can you fail me? I'm graduating, and I won't get my math minor!" Me: "A math minor is a signal to future employers that you can multiply two matrices by hand when asked, and perhaps even write a proof. You haven't demonstrated any ability to do those things." Student's father: "How can you fail my daughter? She worked so hard for this!" The dean's office: "Some student's father is complaining about you! Give her a retest!" Student's father, about a month after she failed the retest: "When are you going to give my daughter a retest and a passing grade?"
- hga 16y agoNot all Research I universities: at MIT, a lot of full professors take teaching very seriously (in my admittedly limited experience, the ones not interested in undergraduates were the exception rather than the rule, although of course not all were able to turn that into great teaching). And there are no adjuncts to speak of, all are tenure track or tenured and all classes are taught by them (I know of one grad student exception in the '80s who proved the rule). However your point about research is spot on WRT the incentives: at MIT the undergraduates are potentially in the graduate student ecological niche and there's a formal Undergraduate Research Opportunities Program (UROP) that allows professors to hire them for credit or a "UROP Minimum Wage" ... that doesn't have overhead levied upon it (that's used mostly for January and summer). Also, a professor who's truly bad or impossible at teaching will not get tenure. And I've watched or rather overhead (sort of an open office setup) a department head force a tenured professor you've probably heard of read every evaluation form submitted for a particular required foundational class, all but one of which (which was a special case) were highly negative, and then tell the professor he'd never be allowed to teach that particular course again. As for the general topic, MIT's big grade inflation period seems to track pretty well with the Vietnam War and the draft: http://www.gradeinflation.com/MIT.html http://www.gradeinflation.com/MIT.html.
- tkahn6 16y agostandardize exams and evaluate professor quality based on VAM instead of student opinion. As a student I'm fine with standardized tests if you can absolutely guarantee that the the tests test core understanding of the concepts and not just rote application of memorized algorithms and formulas. In other words, you have to guarantee that "teaching to the test" is a good thing and not a sign of poor priorities.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoI can't guarantee that, but I also can't make that guarantee about non-standardized tests. Plenty of professors make crappy tests which are just rote memorization - that's a pretty easy way to improve your evaluations. Forcing students to think on a test will only hurt your scores.