4 ms·
This piece reads like a 7th grade given an assignment to write 1000 words on a confusing subject. I thought there was a second page because it ended so abruptly
by prepend 8y ago
This piece reads like a 7th grade given an assignment to write 1000 words on a confusing subject. I thought there was a second page because it ended so abruptly.
It’s a bunch of content on Brand and then makes a slew of subjective statements that seem like I’m supposed to know the author. Or look for future pieces.
So the piece informs and then adds some apocalyptic musings with no basis other than the author’s neuroses.
“
As I sat on the couch in my apartment, overheating in the late-afternoon sun, I felt a growing unease that this vision for the future, however soothing, was largely fantasy. For weeks, all I had been able to feel for the future was grief. I pictured woolly mammoths roaming the charred landscape of Northern California and future archeologists discovering the remains of the ten-thousand-year clock in a swamp of nuclear waste. While antagonism between millennials and boomers is a Freudian trope, Brand’s generation will leave behind a frightening, if unintentional, inheritance. My generation, and those after us, are staring down a ravaged environment, eviscerated institutions, and the increasing erosion of democracy. In this context, the long-term view is as seductive as the apolitical, inward turn of the communards from the nineteen-sixties. What a luxury it is to be released from politics––to picture it all panning out.“
- TheOtherHobbes 8y agoNo, it doesn't read like that at all. It appears you simply didn't like - and possibly didn't understand - the conclusion.
- jameskegel 8y agoNo, I think Prepend is right. This is painful to read, feels disjointed at times, then ends abruptly. Good articles aren't written this way.
- prepend 8y agoI don’t want to have to like a conclusion to get it. I want to understand the reasoning behind the conclusion to appreciate and learn.
- lbarrow 8y agoI honestly think you didn't understand the article. Let me summarize what I got out of it - we can agree to disagree about the quality of the prose. In the late 60s, as the early political struggles of the the baby boomers were coming into full flower, Stewart Brand published a series of books about how to build back-to-the-land communes. While they were high quality productions and somewhat influential, they were written based on some mushy political ideologies that have since been discredited. In the present day Brand, now an old man, has realized some of his mistakes and half-heartedly distanced himself from the premises of the "Whole Earth Catalogue". Instead of a sort of pseudo-intellectual hippy libertarianism, he now identifies with the thinking of people like Steven Pinker, another baby boomer, who has written extensively about how despite the obvious growing problems of the early 21st century, everything is actually fine. The author closes by musing on the damage the boomer generation has caused. The paragraph at the end is not a random addition - it's the point of the article. The point is: Brand had it wrong in the 60s and he has it wrong today. His calls to retreat from politics and build utopian communes in the 60s reflect his panglossian attitude now; in both cases, he washes his hands of the hard work of actually building and surviving the real world. Also - if you're not familiar with Anna Wiener, I think her best work is the essay "Uncanny Valley": https://nplusonemag.com/issue-25/on-the-fringe/uncanny-valley/ https://nplusonemag.com/issue-25/on-the-fringe/uncanny-valle...
- briandear 8y agoIf it isn’t understandable, isn’t that the very definition of deficient writing?
- prepend 8y agoThanks for breaking this out and providing more background. I’m completely unfamiliar with Anna Wiener and I’ve added uncanney valley to my reading list. I think knowing this piece is part of a larger set of work helps me with my wtf perception. It seems odd to wrap up lots of different issues in a single individuals contributions. I don’t know if boomer problems can be pinned in the whole earth catalog as a failure. It’s possible that the catalog can be valuable without curing all ailments and would like to see the authors thoughts on net positive/negative. (As opposed to description of catalog, description to current problems)